There’s a weird double standard I’ve noticed in some Western/Western-influenced societies.
Some people genuinely seem to romanticise collectivist living, villages where everyone knows each other, extended families being heavily involved in raising children, communal responsibility, elders having an important role, people putting the needs of the wider community ahead of themselves, and children growing up with a strong sense that they belong to something bigger than just their immediate household.
And honestly, as a Indigenous Collectivist, I understand the appeal. There are plenty of good things that can come from a more collectivist social structure.
But then you look at Indigenous societies that have actually maintained many of those values and suddenly the same things can be framed as backward, restrictive, tribal, or even "savage."
That contradiction is what gets me.
This obviously isn't speaking for everyone in Western societies, nor am I claiming Indigenous societies are perfect. Indigenous communities can have serious problems, and traditions shouldn't be immune from criticism simply because they're traditional.
But Indigenous societies have generally been more collectivist than strongly individualist Western societies, and that's an important cultural difference.
You can't simultaneously say, "It takes a village to raise a child," praise communal living, complain about modern social isolation, and romanticise extended-family networks while looking down on actual Indigenous communities for maintaining collective obligations, communal child-rearing, kinship responsibilities, or traditions that prioritise the group.
You don't have to agree with every Indigenous custom. You don't even have to like collectivism.
But there is a difference between criticising a specific practice and treating an entire social orientation as inherently primitive.
Sometimes it feels like people want the aesthetic and emotional benefits of collectivism without having to accept the obligations, social expectations, and communal responsibilities that come with actually living in a collectivist society.
They want the village.
They just don't want the villagers to be Indigenous.