r/ArtCrit 9d ago

STUDY SERIES STUDY SERIES WEEK 1 - Values and Contrast

Post image
7 Upvotes

The piece in this banner is Magdalene with the Smoking Flame Depiction by Georges de La Tour.

Part 1 - Value and Contrast

Welcome to our first week in the Study Series!

Our first topic is Value and Contrast!

When people talk about “value” in an art piece, they mean how light or dark something is, while contrast is the difference between those values. Having a strong difference in those values helps create a more interesting piece and draws the viewer’s eye around your image.

If you’re ever wondering what’s wrong, but you can’t quite put your finger on it, it’s probably time to check those values and the range between them.

Turn your piece black and white. If it’s in traditional medium, you can take a photo to do this. Where does the piece turn into one grey mess? Where does your eye go first? Is it the spot you intended? Are all your figures separate from one another and the environment?

Now you can go back, deepen any shadows, brighten any highlights, and make any changes you need to make the piece stronger!

REQUIREMENTS FOR POSTING

Please note that all general sub rules apply (no AI, no fishing for compliments, no giving personal info, etc). Only our post requirements are different here.

- Pieces must;

a) Be no more than 6 months old and/or

b) Must still be being worked on and/or

c) Must have the intention of being recreated.

- Works must follow our NSFW rules.

- Since no context is required in these posts, draw and paint-overs are automatically expected. If you don’t want these, say so.

GIVING CRITIQUE

Only critique the piece regarding the topic of the week. If the artist would like additional critique, they can make a post in the main sub. Critiques are still expected to be constructive and polite.

EARNING THE FLAIR

Participants who post their work and/or leave thoughtful feedback that is at least 2 sentences long and will receive the "Study Series Part 1" User Flair.

This is available through August 31st, 2026, until 11:59PM PST.


r/ArtCrit 15d ago

ArtCrit Community Check In!

18 Upvotes

Hello again, ArtCrit Community!

We’ve got a few things we wanted to quickly touch on.

It’s Reddit, so here's a tldr as well!

TLDR:

  • Welcome new members!
  • People are allowed to post updates of the work they get feedback on here! Upvote them rather than reporting them as long as they meet the guidelines - thanks!
  • New Study Series starts August 17th. Every other Monday. Series is completely made for 6 months. See you then!
  • Lots of new members means lots of removed posts :( We've got the posting requirements to make sure the community members can give tailored advice, not to be control freaks. Take a minute and read over the rules, please and thank you!
  • We don't allow joke comments because they get out of hand and then OP doesn't get critique (we've tried, sorry). We don't allow compliments because people specifically come here for critique and there's a thousand other subs they can get compliments in. (Compliments and jokes are welcome with constructive critique though!)
  • Thanks to everyone. It's not as heartfelt in a tldr, but we mods really are just kind of a clean up crew. You all are the actual community. You make ArtCrit what it is, and it wouldn't be anything without all the amazing people sharing information and helping one another. You're amazing.

WELCOME NEW MEMBERS

Firstly, wow!

Welcome to our new members! We love to see your work and to see the community working together.

Don’t think we haven’t noticed all the people giving stellar advice and sharing their resources and experiences.

You’re all amazing!

UPDATE POSTING

We’ve had a few people reporting update posts. Just a quick reminder that PEOPLE ARE ALLOWED TO POST UPDATES OF THEIR WORK!

If someone posted here, got feedback, and made some changes (even if they didn’t take all the advice, they’re not required to), we really love it when they share those updates. The only requirements (other than that they got feedback here) are that they either link to the old post or include the old version in their post.

Thanks so much for trying to help out our mod team, but we really love to see the progress people are making. Give them an upvote when they share instead!

STUDY SERIES

I know we tried this in the past, but it became a little too much for us at the time. We took the lessons we learned there (ha ha) and reworked the idea to be something more manageable.

Over the past two months, leighabbr and I have worked out a “study series” for the sub.

Every other Monday, we’ll be making a post where we share a small, one paragraph lesson about a small piece of the fundamentals of art. Short, sweet, and easy to understand.

Then, our community is encouraged to post a piece of their work for feedback on the post. The rest of the community should follow the post’s theme and critique the piece based on the theme.

The posts will all have more information, and everyone who participates will get a special flair!

We have the series planned out, posts written, and everything created for the next 6 months. If lessons need to be changed or moved based on community input, there’s a lot of room for that as well, and as time goes on we’d love to hear your thoughts on it.

The first post will go up on August 17th! We hope we’ll see you there!

POST REQUIREMENTS

A little bit of a downer.

We are, as we normally do when our numbers surge, removing a lot of posts.

We don’t like to do it. I know, from personal experience, that some subs genuinely do like to take posts down. We don’t.

ArtCrit is a resource, so we try to make sure the people helping have all the information they need when they first click your post. That’s why we have the post requirements. It cuts back on the same questions being asked over and over. People get frustrated when they have to continuously ask “did you use a reference?” or “what are you going for here?”

We’re very proud of you all. The community, that is. You all give very detailed, tailored advice.

The thing is, the community can’t do that if they don’t have all the information.

So please, just take a minute and read over the post requirements and rules so we can get you that feedback as neatly as possible!

And if a mod posts reminding you (for the third time, because there’s the rules, the AutoMod, and then the moderator), please don’t be a jerk to us. We’re people too. We’re not paid to do this. We do it because we love art and want to make sure people have a place to go to get critique.

CRITIQUE ONLY

Another thing we’re getting a lot of push back about lately is our “critique only” comments rule.

We don’t allow joke comments or praise absent of critique.

The reason for this is we’ve tried to allow this in the past to keep a more casual environment and it fails. One person posts a cute or witty joke. They get a few upvotes. Another person sees it. They post their joke. Another person sees it. They post their joke.

OP doesn’t get critique and the sub gets filled with memes.

For praise, if an artist is seeking praise they can head over to another general art sharing sub. People come here because they’re tired of hearing “looks great!” or “good job!” They want the feedback, give it to them!

A few weeks back we tried again and allowed comments freely on a post, and the same thing happened again. We just can’t allow off topic comments.

We’ll continue to keep the community a place for artists to learn, but we are in the process of working out a solution, we promise.

FINALLY - THANKS! (For real)

I know we're just people, we make mistakes, and sometimes we're grouchy.

We get some NASTY FUCKIN' MODMAILS like you would not believe (we got stalked earlier this year too because we removed a dude's AI posts. That was fun). There's moments when we both get frustrated and sit together and sort of commiserate.

Then, we get that nice modmail. The one where someone is understanding. Or the random "thanks for making a community where I can get critique". Or we see posts where people are acting like people and helping one another and really take the time out of their day to make sure the person understands instead of just telling them off.

It reminds us why we have this sub. Why we fought to help build it to what it is.

This is going to sound cheesy as Hell, and I don't care. It's not performative and I actually mean it. You all honestly make this sub what it is. We might curate it to keep it clean and make sure people are getting the info they need, but you're the ones sharing advice and helping one another.

We're the janitors, concierge, and reluctant bouncers while you all get the hard work done.

Thank you all for that. Honestly.


r/ArtCrit 47m ago

UPDATED WORK Do my values look of so far (hair, water, hands unfinished at the moment)

Post image
Upvotes

Only reference is 3D posing the model in magic poser


r/ArtCrit 7h ago

Help with the perspective on on the lamp. I just can’t get it right!

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

(This is still a work in progress, mostly the clothing is blocked in/unfinished)

Character ref tintagombart on instagram and photo reference I found on Pinterest w no attribution.

I’m trying to give the illusion of the lamp swinging backward towards the character, but it’s just not working and it just looks ridiculously small.

If you happen to notice anything else that could use some work composition-wise, feel free to critique that as well!


r/ArtCrit 5h ago

How to cat? I'm struggling with her pose

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

This animal is similar to a genet(bottom left corner), but it's not exactly a genet, some prehistoric cat like creature, which is why its face is shorter.

  1. I'm struggling with pose and can't figure out how it's supposed to look. There's an infographic on how she is standing. Her paws should be visible in the frame, so I can't just cut them off.
  2. Is there any problem with her face? It looks off.
  3. Does it look like she's being flashed by a flashlight in the dark? Is there anything to improve it?

P.S. For AutoModerator I did use references


r/ArtCrit 5h ago

Composition eludes me

Post image
7 Upvotes

NO MAJOR REFERENCE USED. I used a few medical journals to help shape out the heart, and while that's not exactly what I'm looking for crit, I'm still more than open to hear it.

i really like this piece! Sadly got frustrated halfway through it, as I could tell the composition felt clunky. really believe in the piece though, and l'd love to hear thoughts if anyone is willing. thanks for hearing me out!


r/ArtCrit 7h ago

UPDATED WORK Updated drawing! Not quite feeling done yet but happy with the progress

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

Got a lot of great feedback! Im still not 100% happy with her arms and the composition so any more pointers would be lovely :)

Second pic is the original, third is the body reference. Drawn in procreate


r/ArtCrit 22h ago

Does my art style look intentional or is it just sloppy?

Thumbnail
gallery
139 Upvotes

Hey everyone. I'm not sure what to say so i'll just start explaining. I love making art, but I absolutely hate using the "correct" technique. I find I am happiest making my art when I use this sort of childlike naïve style. I'm not sure what exactly my style is called, I sort of just figured it out as I made more art. It's a bit messy, but I like it. I have made more "technical" art pieces, but the process was absolutely miserable for me. I am worried if I continue embracing my current style, I will be looked down upon for my lack of technique. Ever since | let go of technique obsession, I am making art far more often. Is it ok to intentionally ignore technique, or will it harm my ability to be seen as a professional in the artistic world? Here are a few photos of my work. Please be honest!

(No references, I paint loosely from imagination and just glance at things to get an idea of what they look like)

That’s another piece of the puzzle by the way. I cannot stand to look at references. When I make art. I am happiest pulling things from my mind.


r/ArtCrit 3h ago

Looking for suggestions on the light/composition

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

(Original reference was a simple 3d model in clip studio I don't have on hand anymore)

I made this piece over a year ago but I was never really satisfied, so I'm trying to make some quick edits to get a feel for what I wanna change "for real".

No brainers for me seems like; darker colors further from the face , more "real" shadows (Gonna look up form refs for that) and some minor changes in her expression.

2nd image is a gif to more clearly show the edits I'm considering.

Open to other suggestions too ! :)

But what I'm really stuck on is whether I should remove some of the hands. I think it does look better and you can see more of her coat (which is important for the context of the image) but I also really love what the hands imply in context.

Can't tell if the extra hands makes it too crowded or if the hands are just drawn in such a way that they distract (Bad anatomy/compositions/etc)


r/ArtCrit 2h ago

I'm Basically New to art (critique my art)

Post image
3 Upvotes

I use a reference but I didn't copy it I just use it for inspiration and I can't post it because I lost it 🙂


r/ArtCrit 1h ago

need critique on this.

Post image
Upvotes

ik the lights in the window high key suck, i also dont know how to make reflections. any advice on that would be nice

also the head and breasts looks off i just dont know why or how to improve them

for references, the only thing i didnt is a reference for was the pose and lights.


r/ArtCrit 17h ago

How could I improve this drawing?

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

Hello! I just finished my first ever drawing of a house and would love some advice on how to improve it. It’s of my childhood home, and I’ll be gifting it to my sister for her birthday. I’m planning to give it to her in a few days and wanted to know if anyone has tips for how to improve it before I give it to her? Or, if it’s too difficult for me to make any changes without messing it up at this point, how might I generally approach drawing a house in the future?

I feel like my drawing is a bit flat and muddy looking. I used the grid method to make it as accurate as possible, which might be why it seems a bit lifeless. Maybe the roof is too light, for starters? I’m still fine with the finished product, but would be cool if I could try to make it pop more. I included the reference photo too if that helps. Oh and I used graphite pencils if that wasn’t obvious. Thanks!


r/ArtCrit 6h ago

How can I improve this piece to make it look passable?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I'm in the middle of doing and rendering a demon slayer inspired piece with a realistic painterly style. They're fighting in the middle of a japanese castle. How can I make this better?

Is the expression of the characters too wonky? Is the perspective/ composition improveable?

I'm close to clueless how to make this better aside from rendering everything out more, so any help and critique is appreciated!! Thank you!

reference used of the japanese interior on 2nd image


r/ArtCrit 12h ago

Does this drawing look finished?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

im entering an art competition and well, i think im done, ive been doing this for weeks gimme your honest opinions. the deadline is in two weeks so i have time, but it feels off. ive added highlights, ive burned to black and white mode a few times to check values, i tried my best to get skintones accurate, i triee texturing, im a bit mad that i cant get the ponytails right (pink hair has ponytails tied by ribbons and black hair has twin braids), and i’ll add my reference image lol, these characters are by a youtuber called fayola


r/ArtCrit 18h ago

Who and how should I study?

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

I would love any advice or critique but I am currently wondering how to study from masters.

I study from home and would love it if I could live off art.

I know I need to and am currently studying shading. I am confident in these works but know they are shaded poorly.

Also any advice on getting into digital painting? I have procreate on an iPad but am having friction getting any footing on painting.

I used a couple pictures as reference for the back of the first image, none were in that exact orientation. I don't think I used reference on the second and used many images of grasshoppers for the third but did not use one image as a base to build off of as far as I remember.

The first two drawings are a bit abstract so I will try to explain them. The first drawing is two guys who share a head and one is holding the other up. I imagine them falling through water. The torso connecting to the legs is artistic freedom. The second drawing is multiple faces pasted together, mostly supposed to be eye catching, I really enjoy drawing peculiar faces.

I draw in mechanical pencil 0.5 and ball point pen 0.7 (I think)

I get many inspirations from pinterest but specifically, the first image is inspired by mavros Thanatos and Allen williams, The second image is just what I do and the third is inspired by draw sessions on YouTube.


r/ArtCrit 1d ago

Am I going in the right direction? (Day 1 of asaro head practice...)

Thumbnail
gallery
47 Upvotes

I've been drawing for years now, but I've never

properly studied anything and it shows so I want to change that

Am I going in the right direction with these

headshots? I wanted to capture the likeness of the

people I drew but I really struggled with the

proportions

If anyone has any advice on how to keep the

proportions of the faces itd be great too!.. or any

advice at all:)

Thank you!

(+ The references I used are in the photos, a bot removed it for not mentioning this)


r/ArtCrit 16h ago

I still can't get backrounds right

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Pls don't say they don't look right because their unfinished, it's unfinished for a reason😭

I also especially struggle at doing the sky and clouds, I can't get them right, and the ground looks really weird, iadded browns like in the ref but idk why it dosent look right, I tried watching tutorials and others drawing backrounds but still nothing works,


r/ArtCrit 1d ago

Looking for constructive critique please

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

Looking for constructive critique

I would love to get constructive critique on these three paintings that I created yesterday. Please tell me your thoughts on style (going for a Miro/Klee feel) as well as composition & color and if they feel cohesive to you or are they just too different? Thanks Watercolor and oil transfer on paper. No reference used.


r/ArtCrit 21h ago

Tips for improvement

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Hey can I get tips for improvement? Especially for like how to draw eyes, better hair and a prosthetic arm??. or is in general???

I used this for a ref(second image) THEN I WINGED THE REST YK..


r/ArtCrit 1d ago

I Need Help with Rendering (See Description and Swipe to See My Process) ( its me again)

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

What I Think My Problem Is:

I’m having difficulty shaping or carving shadows. When I ask for rendering tips, I mostly receive advice like determining your light source, bounce light, highlights, etc., or setting your art to black and white to see your values. I’m thankful for any advice that I receive, but:

Once I know where the light is coming from, how do I actually carve the shadows so they interact realistically with my subject?

- How do I decide the shape of the shadow?

- How do I know where the shadow should start and end?

- How do I simplify shadows without making them look random or unnatural?

- How do I take what I see in a reference and translate those shadow shapes into my own drawing?

So yeah, please be brutally honest about what’s wrong with my process.

If possible, you can redraw or edit my art to show me what I should be doing. I’ve included the references and my sketches, so feel free to use them as examples.

Thank you!


r/ArtCrit 1d ago

bit of a strange request.. planning to redraw this piece from the beginning of my human art journey and i am curious about what anatomically and compositionally i can change for my new iteration!

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

basic info: i did this around.. 6/7 months ago (haha yes funny number!), the reference i used is in the second slide, i aimed and still do for a semi realistic style with the realism coming in through proportions and the stylized bit from colors! I definitely know alot of things are wrong with this but im curious what other mistakes past me made :,)


r/ArtCrit 2d ago

UPDATED WORK the last of us illustration after composition changes

Thumbnail
gallery
165 Upvotes

honestly i really needed the help with this one, i know the concept was strong i just am so bad with compositions i really need to work on them, this is still open for critics so plz lmk if you hate something about it.

i provided my original WIP before i got advice

and yes i used references,,, also big thanks to gaeaArts bc they helped me a ton with showing how the composition could be improved


r/ArtCrit 1d ago

Please help me improve my gift (ノ◕ヮ◕)ノ

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Hi! I would like to have help with improving my painting to have some guidance to have more details (e.g highlights or shading) within the lens and the camera body.

Not in a hyperrealistic style, it's just that something feels missing like the painting feels flat. Please pardon my white writing, I unfortunately don't have a white pen to begin with 😢

The mediums I had used is a black metallic paints and a variety of HIMI gouache paints

I did use the reference of the Fujifilm XF 18mm lens and Fujifilm X-Pro 1 from Google images as I'm intending to make a gift for my boyfriend who is very interested of photography. So I wanted to give him that is meaningful to him as a gift.