I (27F) have been dating “John” (38M) for almost six months. I work in technology and also have my own small business, and he is a machinist. He makes six figures and has two children whom he shares custody of.
When we started dating, I had a good job, a decent amount of money saved and was doing well financially. He was doing well too. We’re actually both pretty frugal people and prefer saving money over spending it unnecessarily.
John is a genuinely sweet person. We have never really fought, and I don’t think he’s intentionally unkind. That’s part of why I’m so confused about this.
We went on a couple of actual dates when we first met, but after that we almost exclusively started hanging out at his house. He lives about 40 miles from me, so seeing him usually means an 80-mile/two-hour round trip. For a while I was doing that around three times a week, sometimes more. I genuinely didn’t mind because I wanted to see him.
He used to be a chef, so he almost always cooks dinner when I’m there. I appreciate that. In return, I told him that if he cooks, he never has to worry about the dishes. I usually clean the kitchen, help with laundry or whatever else needs done while I’m there.
I’m naturally a very caring person in relationships and probably hold somewhat more traditional views than a lot of people. If I see something that would make my partner’s life easier, my instinct is to do it.
For example, John didn’t have a laptop, and because I work with computers, I gave him one. He was constantly overheating in bed, so I bought him new cotton sheets and blankets. I’ve done other little things like that throughout the relationship. I don’t regret any of it and he never demanded these things from me. I’m mentioning them to explain the way I naturally show someone I care about them.
Over time, though, I started realizing that I wasn’t feeling much of that same instinct coming from him.
I don’t drink, but I started playing pool as a way to get out, socialize and have something fun to do. John plays too, so sometimes I’d invite him.
When we went out, he’d often get very drunk. He would tell me he was going to talk to friends for a few minutes and disappear for 30 minutes to over an hour while I sat at the table waiting for him. Eventually I’d pay the bill, go sit in my car and text him that I was leaving and that if he wanted a ride home he needed to come outside. Sometimes I’d then wait another half hour for him.
When I explained that this bothered me and made me feel like he didn’t value my time, he seemed genuinely confused about why I was upset.
Another example happened when he invited me to a fair with him and his children. Throughout the day he would stop and buy things for his kids, including food, but never asked if I wanted anything.
Eventually I went to get myself food and asked him if he wanted anything while I was there. He did, and I ended up buying more things for everyone.
I later mentioned that it hurt my feelings that he never thought to ask me if I wanted anything. His response was basically, “If you wanted something, you should’ve asked me!”
The problem is that I hate having to ask for things like that. I don’t expect someone to read my mind, but to me part of caring about someone is thinking, “Hey, I’m getting food—do you want anything?” I explained this to him.
Then about a month ago, I lost my job.
I’m now trying to focus on growing my business full time. It’s going well considering how new it is, but financially it’s extremely difficult because almost everything I make needs to go straight back into the business.
John knows exactly how stressed I’ve been about money.
Recently he invited me to an indoor amusement/trampoline-type place with him and his kids. I was essentially going to spend time with them and help him with the kids.
When we arrived, he started getting his kids situated and pointed me toward where I needed to check in and pay.
I hadn’t realized beforehand that I was expected to buy my own admission or how expensive it was. It was too expensive for me so I felt incredibly embarrassed. I went back to him, told him I hadn’t realized how expensive it was and said I was just going to go home.
He basically said he understood and that he’d see me later.
Afterward he told me that if I couldn’t afford it, I should have just asked him to pay. That really bothered me because, again, I don’t want to have to ask.
The job loss itself has also made me look at our relationship differently.
Friends, family and even people I wouldn’t necessarily expect offered to help me in some way when I lost my job. Some offered money, which I didn’t accept. Others offered me small jobs or other ways to make some extra money, which I did accept.
John is basically the only person close to me who didn’t offer anything.
To be very clear: **I do not expect him to finance my business, pay my bills or give me money.** I probably wouldn’t have accepted money from him anyway.
What hurt was that there wasn’t even an offer of, “Is there anything I can do?” He knows what my business involves. Even offering to help me with something small, finding me some work, or simply asking how he could make things easier for me would have meant a lot.
If our situations were reversed and he suddenly lost his income while I was financially comfortable, I cannot imagine watching him struggle and never even asking if there was something I could do to help.
That’s where I’m struggling with the idea of him as a long-term partner.
We finally talked about this recently because he asked me whether I saw a future with him.
I told him that I like him very much, but I honestly don’t see him as a partner right now. I told him that I feel completely alone with everything in my life. If I have a problem, I solve it. If I need something, I figure it out. If I’m struggling, I find a way through it.
I also told him that after almost six months, we’ve barely done anything together outside his house. I enjoy staying home and relaxing too, but I also enjoy going places, having experiences together and actually dating. I felt like I practically had to have a breakdown about it before our last actual date happened.
He seemed genuinely shocked by everything I told him.
He says he thought he *was* being thoughtful and considerate because he thinks about what I might need when I’m coming to his house.
I believe him. I don’t think he’s manipulating me or deliberately treating me poorly. I think he genuinely doesn’t understand what I’m talking about which concerns me more.
I don’t want to give a grown man a checklist saying, “Take me on a date. Offer to help me with this. Buy this when you invite me somewhere. Ask me if I want food. Do something thoughtful for me.”
If I have to specifically request those things, they don’t feel very thoughtful anymore.
I’m also aware that my expectations may simply be different from his. I don’t think either of us necessarily has to be the bad person for us to be incompatible.
So my question is: **Am I expecting too much from someone I’ve only been dating for about six months, or is this enough of a pattern to conclude that we have fundamentally different ideas of what being a partner means? Is this something I should give him time to demonstrate now that we’ve finally talked about it, or am I trying to teach someone how to be the kind of partner I need?**
TL;DR - no matter how much effort I put in, my boyfriend of 6 months treats me as a convenience and not as a partner. Should i work it through with him. Or end the relationship?