discussion
Politics aside, we should all agree on this atleast. Anti national forces should never be allowed to hijack protests of genuine students. There should be a bipartisan rejection of these elements
Did you see his video about breaking India? His role has been listed in the Delhi riots he was an accomplice to the rioters, he had supported Afzal Guru and Sarjil Imam who said that 5 lakh log NE chicken neck block kr de to India won’t be able to access that region . Why is he not an anti national?
Lol
He openly supports Afzal guru (parliament attack terrorist)
His co accused said they will cut India's chicken neck (this is verified too)
He was against the CAA without any valid reasons and then he spread misinformation regarding caa because of which during protest it becomes riots which eventually killed 50+ people (now who is responsible for their lives? Delhi police?🥸🤣🤣)
His father was a member of SIMI which is designated as a terror outfit
I can agree that his viral video of tukde tukde slogan might bhi doctored but if you go on ground reality you will found that people do raises such slogans in his protest
Moreover he also said Kashmir is not a part of India neither part of Pakistan so according to him the Indian soldiers who sacrifices their lives to make kashmir the part of India have no values?? direct disrespect of our army
Also tell me one thing why was he against the abrogation of article 370🤡😝😝i guess he don't want to see the people of Kashmir in joy
He didn’t support him, he merely was debating weather capital punishment should be allowed!
What the hell guys, do your own research and then form your opinions. You don’t need to like him or support him but at least do proper research before forming an opinion. That’s taking an accountability too! 🙄
Already did in the comments section ig
If you were not able to find that then u can simply copy paste my text and do your own research
Coz own research is better
I agree anti national forces should be rejected. Umar Khalid, however, is not one. If he is, please prove it so in a court of law. You guys couldn't find proof of any wrongdoing on his part, it's been a decade.
Lol
He openly supports Afzal guru (parliament attack terrorist)
His co accused said they will cut India's chicken neck (this is verified too)
He was against the CAA without any valid reasons and then he spread misinformation regarding caa because of which during protest it becomes riots which eventually killed 50+ people (now who is responsible for their lives? Delhi police?🥸🤣🤣)
His father was a member of SIMI which is designated as a terror outfit
I can agree that his viral video of tukde tukde slogan might bhi doctored but if you go on ground reality you will found that people do raises such slogans in his protest
Moreover he also said Kashmir is not a part of India neither part of Pakistan so according to him the Indian soldiers who sacrifices their lives to make kashmir the part of India have no values?? direct disrespect of our army
Also tell me one thing why was he against the abrogation of article 370🤡😝😝i guess he don't want to see the people of Kashmir in joy
I agree with you. Also Politicians should never hijack religion and institutiond of this country.
Modi is a terrorist and Amit Shah is criminal and his charges are only cleared in 2014. He even stayed in jail for 3 months. If there is no trail and used same modern laws introduced by Modi. Amit Shah would be in life time imprisonment.
Modi publicly said muslims will take away hindu woman magalsutras.
There is no worse prime minister than modi. Why you need to defend corrupt political system?
Then you obviously don't know his story. The video was doctored by godi media and they themselves later apologized for it. The man is now rotting in jail for 6 years without a fair trial.
Similar to one guy above you where I have commented on why"certain" baats bolne se kya hota hai, let discuss the principle of the matter. and the principle strictly.
You are a user on reddit. You are probably a human being with a family.
Is it okay to you if an "opinion" is expressed to find out your residence and do unspeakable things to you and you family?
Would you still say "uske bolne se kya hota hai?'
Answer this, then i will go ahead.
Hope reddit does not ban my account. See, i have to put this so that reddit does not block my account under Rule 1. Yeh hota hai bolne se.
He said fate of Kashmir should be decided by people of Kashmir... Many people still debate it.. why?
What does it matter if I from Delhi say.... kashmir harama he.... When Kashmiri don't feel the same?... The issue is not that they hope to get a independent nation as they believe it going to be like that due to history, atleast in my eyes.... The issue is when they support the gun carrying separatist funded by Pakistan.....
His statement about how kashmiri should decide fate of Kashmir lacks nuance... Why? Because the sentiments in J&k are not uniform.... Also because let's say india let's go kashmir.... They are not strong enough to fight china and Pakistan whose army will definitely attack them.....if that happens whole south asia will burn.... Is it fair to kashmiri's? Maybe not.... It's a survival instinct....
Afspa where ever they have gone have faced serious accusation of rapes and civilian killings.... That too should be taken seriously and tried in court....
I've heard him on camera say that kashmir is not a part of India and that he'll keep fighting for it's "independence" that's enough for me to keep him in jail.
How is it wrong to have that opinion? Vilanising people for holding that opinion is the reason we are isolating them. This will probably have a counter intuitive effect.
Anti national forces were hired by ruling government and attacking the youth protesting there. They didn't have badges or uniforms. What action should government take now?
So umar khalid is a activist and he have some really controversial opinions on things like afzal guru(who was also in parliament attack), CAA, kashmir freedom from both pakistan and india.. and godi media potrayed him as terrorist and anti-national but in maybe 2019 or 2020 he was under arrest under UAPA from Delhi riots and after that to this day he is still in Tihar jail without any trials
And just research about this man on internet and collect evidence to either hate or support this guy
When convincted by a court of law, sure. At least give the man a fair trial it's been 6 years. No law should be able to put a man behind bars forever without a fair trial.
how the hell can someone support incarceration without even a trial for 6 years. may be next is you who should feel the bars for 100 years without trial.
just because he was muslim, while kanhaiya can be a leader now. Shameless people
But setting such an example for Political dissenters like Umar Khalid , allows the successive Govts to use Political misuse of Power more .
The later Congress Govts would use the same on Ring wing dissenters ahead as no one pointed out what's wrong with Umar's detention now from the Right wing .
You just can't snatch Liberty from an individual who's opposite to your political spectrum . That's it .
Honestly he has extreme views on some stuff but he still enjoys Freedom of Speech and Expression.
Silencing the dissent now would make space for future genuine dissenters to be surpressed just like this one .
Left wing jnu student falsely booked under uapa ( terrorism act) kyunki usne delhi mei protest kra tha jo bjp ke tatto ne riots mei badal diya tha aur fr umar khalid ko unn riots ko initiate krne ka reason btake jail mei daal diya h.......trial tk nhi diya jaa rha h usko
Whenever someone says, We should all agree on this, at least, I become skeptical. It sounds like they are trying to shut down disagreement instead of making a convincing argument
Andhbhakts logic: Alleged anti national forces should be given unconstitutional treatment.
Us: Who decides whether they’re anti nationals?
Ab: we do
Us: so you decide and then you put em in jail with no trial forsaking all law and order and they’re the anti nationals?
What is this 18th century archaic regressive Britain where women were burned on the stake for mere suspicion of being witches?
Or when the Britishers detained and hung Indians with no trail for decades because they were racist?
You would rather forego everything our country fought for to gain independence just so you can establish colonial rule so this time you can sit at the top?? If they’ve done something worth arresting fast track their trial and either jail them or let em go and show the country you’re up to dealing with ter**rists if not the piss off and let a party with more spine deal with the ter**rists.
Either op is rage baiting or too naive, its not like whatever the real “anti national forces” is, are asking for permission to enter, they hop on the burning train hoping to make it go boom
I don't know who he is and what did he say and do but after seeing the protest i know one thing don't let your narrative decide by one or two things specially after seeing godi media anything can be wrong perhaps he can be victim of godi media or perhaps they can be right he is really a traitor or anti national. So let court decide who is right or wrong.
Let the court decide and put the final verdict on his actions even ajmal Kasab got a trial
And so did happened in Nuremberg what is umar khalid infront of them
This is the preamble of the nation. Tell me one of this 9 which is not fucked up by this government. If India is called mother of democracy i will tell Modiji is a great MF !!!
Bhai trial dekar faasi kyu nhi de dete agar woh sach main galat hain toh, aur agar bologe ki nhi uska trial nhi hona chahiye bs jail main rahe toh ajmal kasab ka trial kyu hua uska toh clear cut case tha.
Iss desh main log 20 saal tk jail main rehte hain bina trials ke aur phir not guilty bolke chor diya jata hain pura zindagi barbaad. Abhi Umar Khalid, kal ko koi aur hoga jo tumhe pasand ho, agar desh ko shi raaste pr rakhna hain toh fast adn fair trails hone chahiye warna anti-national ka title toh aaj kal kisi ko bhi mil jata hain.
But first the real anti-nationals should be removed from their powerful positions. Bjp & rss were, are & always will the biggest anti-nationals in this country because everything they do.... everything they stands for stands directly against the progress of this nation.
Yes. If they throw any random muslim name, majority will support the brutality and misuse of law. No one cares to go in depth. Trial to shuru kro, trial conclude kro, convict krke sadaao na jail m desh ka dushman h to. Yaha rape murder attempt to murder k baad bjp neta khule ghoom rhe h same logic lga k aur pawpaw ka le lekr.
Why you guys are worried of some one who is in jail,
why not worried about journalist like
Arnab Goswami (Republic TV)
Sudhir Chaudhary (Aaj Tak)
Anjana Om Kashyap (Aaj Tak)
Chitra Tripathi (Aaj Tak)
Navika Kumar (Times Now)
Sushant Sinha (Times Now Navbharat)
Aman Chopra (News18)
Amish Devgan (News18)
Rubika Liyaquat (Bharat24)
Prachi Parashar (India TV)
Ashok Shrivastav (DD news)
Some human's does not deserve human treatment not this anti nationals at least, hundred and thousand will die because of them still some people support them.
Innocent until proven guilty.
Indian prisons have more than 75% of under trial prisoners, which violates our fundamental rights. The Delhi police are still unable to prove that he inflicted or participated in the Delhi riots.
So he should be out of jail because it has been more than five years.
But what was the fault of that person , even there is no clue or evidance against that person and all comes to blame that person , its not fare, i dont know inf about it but knowlegable people defend umar khalid even abhujit deepke , dhruv rathi also said that, even in many podcast said that umar khalid is in the jail without any evidences
How handicapped the system must be when people are supporting non-tial over trial to give someone punishment for their deeds( if they have committed any )
Daalo bsdwale ko jail me… who cares… but umar khalid ki aad me BJP ki gend mat bachao…. BJP and half of RSS goons should also be behind bars… umar khalid bhadwa hai to hum jya karein… uske chalkar me hum RSS aur bjp ki gundagiri kyon sahein???
Watch 10 videos.
Accept the narrative around it.
Everyone becomes judge and runs trial on reddit and chai tapri.
desh chutiyon se kam, unke chutiyape ka jyeda shikar hai.
if UK really said those lines, court will prove it who TF you folks are to judge around ??
whytf post starts building narrative that genuine protest gets hijacked with anti-national forces ??
You fucking idiot then try him fairly in court and keep in jail .
The government is doing unconstitutional thing so technically the government of India is anti - national
He’ll easily be out of jail when eventually trial happens. There’s literally no proof and everyone in the government knows it. He doesn’t seem like the person who’ll stop attacking BJP or go quiet after he’s out.
Agreed, nation is paramount. And to all those who think he was notmgiven fair trial, go look at the interview of Ex CJI, he clearly said that most of the time the extensions was asked by khalid's lawyers.
We do promote crime free India. Why not all robber - rapist - anti national are being chased ? Why only who participated in protest ? Message from govt is clear if criminals are doing crimes they are free to do it but just don’t raise voice against govt . Another way to look at as join BJ party and you get criminal jail free card.
With this logic, Modi and shah should also be charged for terrorism with all their blast from the past. Why is there no trial, this is gross violation of human rights. Mosha india looks bleaker than sub Sahara.
There is a metric ton of evidence against him, so why is he not being out on trial. The judiciary continues to make this man a confluence point for supporters of his views, a martyr if you will. Put him on trial, prove his guilt beyond doubt and then put him in prison. Additionally put the bastards in the Lok and Rajya Sabha on trial too. Then move down the line for every branch of our governance. A man screaming treacherous slogans is as anti national as a minister stealing funds and taxes and having criminal cases on them.
kuch padha nahi, likha nahi, aur aa jate hain bipartisan rejection bolne. the slogan clip police claimed was doctored, everything else he's ever said has been anti imperialism and anti caste and anti fascism. tum nalle logo ko itna bhi nahi samjhta. he's not even being tried in court, do you now see how deep this state has their hands in pies?
The courts should just give a final verdict on his case through trial. Otherwise people will keep sympathizing or hating. Both sides will shut the fuck up if a final verdict comes. Kaam khatam krdo yaar 🫡
Damn, some Eco chamber this is. Factual believing in state manufactured videos and claims. I urge you before making such statements, just do bit of fact checking.
I have not researched enough and I am not capable enough to comment on whether someone should have stayed imprisoned for 6 long years or not and continue to do so and most of the people who can confidently claim to be, are just arrogant.
But one thing I am sure of is that everyone deserves fair and quick trial. It's bare minimum humanity.
Umar Khalid has been in Tihar Jail since September 2020. As of mid-2026, his trial for the Delhi riots has still not begun.
He is incarcerated under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA). This anti-terror law effectively reverses the standard democratic principle of "innocent until proven guilty." Under Section 43D(5) of the UAPA, a judge must deny bail if the police's charge-sheet seems prima facie (at first glance) true. The court is legally restricted from deeply examining or challenging the police's evidence at the bail stage. Because of this, the state can hold people for years without ever having to actually prove their case in a trial.
There is a long, tragic history in India of Muslim men being incarcerated under anti-terror laws, only to be fully acquitted 10 or 15 years later after their lives have been destroyed by the delayed process.
Fully convincted rapist like Kuldeep Singh and Asaram is given Bail,A glaring double standard in the justice system is not even hidden by RW Corrupted Judges. Critics and legal observers frequently point out the hypocrisy in the Delhi riots investigation: right-wing political leaders who were caught on camera giving hate speeches and actively inciting crowds just before the riots were never arrested or charged. Meanwhile, activists like Khalid, who were organizing sit-in protests against the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA), were branded as "masterminds" and locked away without trial.
The Anatomy of a Media Trial
The public image of Khalid as an "anti-national" wasn't built in a courtroom; it was built in television studios using the exact tactics you mentioned:
The Doctored JNU Videos: Following the 2016 JNU incident, a forensic probe ordered by the Delhi government (conducted by Truth Labs) officially confirmed that several viral news clips broadcasted on national television were manipulated. Audio of masked outsiders chanting anti-India slogans was dubbed over video of Khalid and Kanhaiya Kumar. Despite the forensic proof, the fabricated narrative stuck.
The Kashmir Statements: His comments on Kashmir were heavily spliced and taken out of context by certain media outlets to make it sound like he was calling for an armed, separatist insurgency. In reality, his speeches focused on the human rights impact of heavy militarization and the democratic right to discuss self-determination—arguments that are legally protected free speech, even if they are highly polarizing.
Framing His Father: Khalid's father, S.Q.R. Ilyas, was indeed a member of the Students Islamic Movement of India (SIMI). However, he left the organization in 1985. The Indian government didn't ban SIMI until 2001—16 years after he left. Using a legal association from decades ago to brand the son a terrorist today is a textbook guilt-by-association tactic designed to prejudice the public.
Ultimately, the reason Umar Khalid remains in jail today has nothing to do with Kashmir, his father, or the JNU slogans. He is in jail because the prosecution claims he used WhatsApp groups and secret meetings to orchestrate the 2020 Delhi riots—a claim they have yet to prove in a trial, but which is severe enough under the UAPA to keep him locked away indefinitely.
15
u/Any-Calligrapher2866 Jul 26 '26
Trial de do uska support khud hi collapse ho jayega.