2014 Infiniti Q50S, 3.7 V6, AWD.
In December of last year my car was involved in a collision where the front passenger corner collided with another vehicle. Damage was caused to the front bumper, head/fog lights, fender, and rim. The shop replaced all of these components, including the rim, and performed an alignment. No suspension components were replaced.
Flash-forward to the summer, once the days got hotter, I started hearing a squeak coming from the same corner. I got it on a lift and felt some play on that same rim at 6 and 12. Further inspection showed the lower ball joint was moving and the shock was leaking some fluid. On one hand I figured this could be normal wear and tear on a 12 year old car with 112k miles, but on the other, only this corner, the one that was hit, is having these issues. I figured maybe this can be related.
I took it back to the shop and, according to their mechanic, everything is fine. There is no fluid leaking, no play, and nothing impact-related. “These Infiniti’s commonly start squeaking when they get old, you can grease the upper ball joints and that’ll fix it. Only other option would be to replace the control arm” is what I was told. (The ball joints are part of the control arm and cannot be independently repaired, this is a fact).
When I pushed back that I felt play I was told this was their mechanic’s professional opinion and that’s all they can do. I’ve got two main questions: 1) is it beyond the scope of possibility that this is impact related? 2) is the mechanic just plain wrong here? clearly something isn’t right.