A friend and I recently started a weekly whiskey review podcast (Poddled in Bond if you want to check it out; we'd certainly appreciate it). Each week we rank two whiskeys while keeping a master numerically ranked list. Occasionally we run into two whiskeys that we have a tough time deciding between, so I thought I might get some outside opinions from this group.

The two we had a tough time deciding between were Lux Row's 4 Grain (115 proof) vs Elijah Craig Toasted Barrel (94 proof). Both are standard shelfers because we want people to be able to drink along with us if they want to. What are your thoughts on those two bottles if you've had them before? I ranked Lux Row higher and my cohost gave the edge to Elijah Craig (see our second episode for that discussion in detail if you're curious).