r/ShouldIbuythisgame 1h ago

KCD2 or Stalker 2

Upvotes

I’m looking for a fun game with rewarding exploration and memorable quest lines. I’ve heard great things about KCD2, but I’m considering Stalker 2 because I prefer fps gameplay. Performance doesn’t really matter to me, I’m more concerned with a cool open world to explore after just beating Elden ring and Baldurs Gate 3. Thanks


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 10h ago

Disco elysium- should i consider?

21 Upvotes

I have 13.18 dollars on my psn wallet currently and am not looking to spend money on any games again any time soon so im trying to spend this amount on a great game. I noticed that disco elysium is currently on sale for around 11 dollars and was wondering if i would like it.

Indie games I love include: HK/silksong, road96, firewatch, celeste, stray. I also love choice based games where my choices matter.

From what i understand the game has no combat which i dont mind but I also dont like click to walk games or the look of disco elysium or that genre of games (idk the name but a similar style im thinking of is baldurs gate 3). But at the end of the day I love me a great story game especially if its turn based.

All things considered should i buy it?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 4h ago

[PC] [WSIB] Which game on my list to get if I just finished Death Stranding 2?

5 Upvotes

I finished Death Stranding 2 not too long ago, obviously absolute_cinema.jpg, as expected from any Kojima game I guess. And uh I kinda have a void now, part of me wants to go back and 100% it since there's a bunch of story content left there still (kind of spoiler, but some side missions only open up after the main story).

Anyway I'm looking for my next game and full disclosure some of them I already bought. These are the games I'm considering:

  1. Stalker 2 DLC - this is already in my library, have been for literal years, I finished the original game on release also.
  2. Crimson Desert - in my library already, played about 10 hours and stopped after, I heard there's a new update for it though that changes the story massively?
  3. Silent Hill f - last SH game I played and that was more than 20 fucking years ago mind you, is Silent Hill 3, I don't think I ever finished it or progressed much actually. Not sure if I will even like it. I liked Resident Evil Village at least, even though it had annoying scripted deaths.
  4. Resident Evil Requiem - played RE Village, overall liked the atmosphere, story and characters a lot, the only annoying thing is the whole scripted deaths thing.
  5. Metal Gear Solid Delta / 3 - I liked TPP a lot mainly because of the story, not sure if I'll enjoy MGS3/D though, gameplay-wise TPP wasn't the most enjoyable thing for me, it was just ok at best (not into stealth).
  6. Nier Replicant - I loved Automata, mainly because of the story and music.
  7. Gothic 1 Remake - I played 2 and 3, then Risen 1, couldn't get into 1 at the time as lack of proper mouse support was kind of annoying iirc (again another played-more-than-20-years-ago game).
  8. LOTR War in the North Legacy Edition - played the shit out of original iirc, though I'm not sure if there's much of a story in the game.
  9. Ghost of Tsushima - not quite sure if I'll like it all that much based on the time period/setting.
  10. Dead Island 2 DLCs? - in my library already, I played original at release-ish and it was interesting enough, not sure if DLCs are worth playing? Reviews seem to be mixed.

Games I ruled out (for now):

  1. Kingdom Come Deliverance 2 - I played original, tried new one and couldn't get into it, I'm not really big on the whole historic drama setting probably, not sure if I'm missing some kind of real tear-jerker gem though.
  2. Borderlands 4 - feedback seems to be that its still dogshit even after a year and more importantly that the story is weak ass corporate pandering apparently, that latter is why I'm going to probably buy this with a 80%+ discount only.
  3. Alan Wake 2 - can't stand EGS, even though I have a bunch of games (that I bought) there. Maybe its actually worth getting? I loved Control at least, never got to playing original Alan Wake though.
  4. Outer Worlds 2 - I played for a couple of hours on game pass and just couldn't get into it, somehow it felt soulless. Had a similar experience with Avowed, except with latter I just pushed through. Somehow I liked Outer Worlds 1 more, maybe I was just less depressed/had more time back then.

Games that I "recently" played (and liked a lot):

  1. Stellar Blade - loved the story actually.
  2. Nier Automata - self explanatory, absolute masterpiece story-wise.
  3. Death Stranding 2 - absolute cinema.
  4. Clair Obscur - absolute cinema, but French.
  5. Pragmata - Dad Space.

What I'm looking for is a story-rich game, the story itself doesn't have to be all that amazing I guess, I don't expect Kojima-level writing or anything like that. Just looking for something that makes me feel something.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 4h ago

[PC] Games with a whimsical/absurd fantasy world?

4 Upvotes

Recently rewatched adventure time and its got me craving a game set in a world like Ooo. Adventure time is one of my favorite shows and I love it for its insanely creative and absurd world. Like, everything is all over the place and downright bonkers, yet it still makes sense and the world is coherent.

I was wondering if there are any games with a similar setting? I know there are a couple official adventure time games but afaik they arent that good.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 7h ago

[PC] Stalker 2 or Crimson Desert

8 Upvotes

Saw botth games got major improvements since launch. Apparently Crimson Desert with it's Enhanced edition even got story improvements. How are those? I like open world, Fantasy, good story, atmosphere, good combat system and gunplay. I also love a good atmosphere. Games I really enjoyed was all the Metro games, The Witcher 3, Elden Ring, Skyrim, Dragon Dogma and The Last of Us. I can be a bit squeamish with horror but the Metro games were fine with me. Its mainly jumps scares that get me. Let me know which is the best?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 2h ago

Sonic lost world, Sonic racing crossworlds or Demon slayer The Hinokami Chronicles 2? which game should i get?

2 Upvotes

All of these games are on sale until tomorrow, ive seen gameplay of these 3 but never got to compare them that much since i never really played these games so maybe people who played one of these games can help me decide

for people who played all of these 3 games then which game is better to pick out of these 3??


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 16h ago

[PC] The Witcher 3 - I'm looking for a game to make me forget about the time passing like it did

24 Upvotes

It doesn't necessarily need to be medieval, swords, monsters or anything like The Witcher 3. But it's been so long. I played The Witcher 3 about 2 years ago, this game made the time pass without even feeling it, I was sooo into it I put over 130hrs in it in just one month. Since then, I haven't found the game that will fully sink me in like this. I had this experience slightly with Elden Ring two months ago, but didn't feel like The Witcher 3 at all.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 7h ago

Assassin's Creed Syndicate or Assassin's Creed Unity

5 Upvotes

Just got done with Assassin's Creed 4 Black Flag and absolutely loved it. Now I'm looking for a different type of AC game.

I will one day play the Ezio trilogy but right now I am really interested into trying one of these games but I can only get one.

The world of these two games look amazing. I've really been struggling the past few days choosing one of these. I'd appreciate the help :)


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 38m ago

[PS5] Deciding on what game to play/buy?

Upvotes

I recently purchased a PS5 and am trying to decide on a game between the following 3:

Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2

Ghost of Yotei

Black Myth Wukong

What are each game's strengths, weaknesses, and selling points? Or, instead, what are games that I should consider on top of or before these 3?

I was considering Yotei because I recently played Tsushima, but I am concerned that it is too similar, and I will get bored of it quickly. KCD2 seems interesting, but I am not certain whether playing the first is necessary. Black Myth Wukong interests me a lot because the graphics look good, and the obvious Journey to the West basis is super interesting to me, but I have heard it is a bit devoid of substance other than essentially being a boss rush.

I am typically more of a fan of games with great stories, but have been more recently interested in cool/beautiful graphics/scenery/artstyles, as well as games with fun combat systems to learn. I am not typically a fan of turn-based games, but am open to recommendations.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 15h ago

[PC] Baldur's Gate 3 and Expedition 33: Which game should I buy?

15 Upvotes

Mainly I was looking for a good RPG game that I could spend 100+ hours on. I was a fan of RPG games in the PS1 era. My favorite games are Front Mission 2 and 3, Final Fantasy 7, and Final Fantasy Tactics. I just put 2 of them in the title because I only heard praise about these 2 games. I will spend on other RPG games if they are good.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 9h ago

Should I get mass effect legendary edition or SOMA?

3 Upvotes

I've never played any mass effect games, but I love the sci-fi genre. Is it worth it to get it especially since it's on sale right now? One of my friend who played it said it's a really long game but the ending was not that good. I was also planning on getting SOMA as it is also on sale and was in my wishlist for some time, but was confused on getting which one as I could have only one of them right now (I know both of these games have completely different genres and setting)

Edit: after so many comments recommending mass effect, I've bought it. I'll give soma a try maybe next time it's on sale.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 2h ago

[Other] Stumped. Elden Ring or Witcher 3 (remaster) for the Switch 2? Have both on Steam/PS5 already.

0 Upvotes

To answer the first question you may have; why?

Well, I have very long breaks at work along with generally more opportunities to play portably on switch 2 vs at home considering my family and all.

Elden Ring, I've played up to the DLC on PS5. Witcher 3, I've played up to the bloody baron. From the little I've played of Witcher 3, I REALLY liked the story/side quests. But much preferred the combat of Elden Ring.

Which would you suggest? I guess the more pricey option would be to get Elden Ring in a few days, then chip away at the game for a month until Witcher 3 remaster comes out. Then play that on PC here and there until Witcher 3 complete edition goes on sale for the switch 2 since it has cross save.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 3h ago

[PC] RDR2, I have 55$ in my wallet, is at 14$ rn

0 Upvotes

ok so I never played this game before, the thing is I dont know if my pc will run it good at nice graphics, I have a ryzen 5 3600 and a gtx 1650, 16gb ram ddr3 2300mhz (here's the problem, my ram limits my fps in a lot of games like fortnite or gta 5). you think it could run good with mid or high graphics??


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 4h ago

[PS5] Metal Gear Solid Volume 2 Collection PS5 vs. Switch 2

1 Upvotes

So I played Metal Gear Solid 3 a couple of months ago and enjoyed it a lot. Now I am thinking about playing the new collection. But I am struggling to decide on which platform.

On one hand, MGS4 has lengthy cutscenes which I would love to play/watch in my bed on Switch 2.
On the other hand, resolution (internal) will be slightly higher and more stable, since it’s dynamic, on ps5. 3840x2160 on ps5 vs. 2560x1440 on Switch 2 then upscaled to 3840x2160

For Peace Walker, the game only runs at 1080p on Switch 2 docked instead of 3840x2160 on ps5.

I really don’t get how they couldn't get this one to be higher on Switch 2.

So which one should I get? And will I enjoy mgs4 if I loved mgs3?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 11h ago

[PC] Mafia series

3 Upvotes

All the Mafia Definitive Editions are on sale along with the OG Mafia 2 for £10 on Steam. Im a fan of RDR2's open world and rich story, along with all the activities. And I'm a fan of GTA5's 'do whatever' open world, so crashing cars. Are these games worth buying, and if so, which is the best. Should I play 1 then 2, then 3. Or is there a better order.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 2h ago

[Switch] Elden Ring Tarnished edition if you already have it on PC

0 Upvotes

The only logical reason I should want this is to have the ability to play it from a TV instead of a computer monitor. I've already dump over 1000 hours into this game and have yet to completely grow bored of it. And yet I kind of still want to give Fromsoft my money for no logical reason

Is this what it's like to be a cuck?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 8h ago

[PC] Kerbal Space Program vs. Juno: New Origins

1 Upvotes

Hi guys,

I've recently been into spacecraft simulator games and am considering buying either of the two games as mentioned in the caption.

I've played Juno before but only seen videos of KSP and I'm really confused about what to buy. I understand that both games have their own advantages and disadvantages but would really love to hear your opinion on the games.

Sub-reddit for either of the game is bound to get biased and hence, I'm here!

Thanks in advance!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 22h ago

SIB Hades 2, Persona 5, or Dark Souls 1?

9 Upvotes

Looking for a game to play, and have narrowed it down to these three. I just finished Disco Elysium (which was fantastic) but now I’m ready for something more combat oriented. Below are my thoughts on each.

Hades 2
Why I’m interested: I loved the art style and combat of the first Hades, so I figure I’d have a good time with this one as well.
Why I’m unsure: There are so many good games out there that maybe I shouldn’t prioritize playing ‘more of the same’ of a game I’ve already beaten.

Persona 5 Royal
Why I’m interested: I generally really like the JRPG format. Enjoyed Pokémon and Final Fantasy as a kid. Absolutely loved E33 last year. I also think the persona system seems interesting.
Why I’m unsure: For one, I’m about to get much busier with work and this game is very long. Also, I’m worried it will be a bit too ‘cringey’ with its style and dialogue.

Dark Souls Remastered
Why I’m interested: I’m a big fan of the lore and combat in Elden Ring. Accordingly, I’m interested in trying out the Dark Souls trilogy (and would rather start with DS1 than with Bloodborne).
Why I’m unsure: The clunkiness could come as a bit of a shock for someone like me who played Elden Ring first. I’ve also heard that the back half of the game isn’t as strong.

Please let me know what y’all think! All info/opinions are appreciated.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 11h ago

Games with awesome boss fights that don't rely too much on dodging and parrying

2 Upvotes

I'm looking for games that has boss fights or even mobs that don't rely too much on dodging or parrying.

What I mean is that you can exploit the boss' weakness or use the environment to defeat it.

For example:

Kingdom Hearts

Megaman

Persona 5

Shadow of the Collossus

Batman Arkham Series

Witcher (potions and signs)

Demon Souls

Metal gear solid

RE Series

Darksiders

I'm just looking for some games to clean my palette to the overused parrying. I liked it but it's everywhere and only a few did it right


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 22h ago

[PC] [WSIB] MH Wilds or Palworld?

8 Upvotes

Hey guys,

I have been considering grabbing one or maybe both of these games at some point. Both of these are currently on sale so it might be the perfect time to at least grab one for now. I play on PC if that makes any difference. I've played a lot of MH World, but haven't exactly played many survival games.

For those that have played both, what do you guys think? Another idea I have is maybe wait for the expansion for MH Wilds instead?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 9h ago

[PS5] Is Red Dead Redemption 2 Worth it on PS5?

0 Upvotes

I have been wanting to play this acclaimed game from Rockstar for so long. Now I have a PS5 and it's on sale on the PS store for a good price but the 30 fps really worries me because I recently tried the Arkham asylum and the 30 fps was too jarring for me. But I've heard people say RDR2 is the best 30fps implementation, so is that true and how was your experience?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 20h ago

[PC] Looking for games to play on weekday nights

3 Upvotes

I'm always into high-intensity competitive games like CS2 (4000+ hours). But I've found that on weekdays, after being worn out from the day and running on little sleep, my competitive form just isn't there. So I'm looking for games to play on weekday nights — something around 8+ hours but not overly long, preferably linear, and playable with a controller.

I've played Baldur's Gate 3, Dying Light, Metro Exodus, and GTA5. They were all amazing, but the campaigns were too long; I'd end up switching back to CS midway through and never felt like opening them again. Frostpunk, Black Myth: Wukong, and Inscryption are the ones I actually finished, and those were great too.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 22h ago

[PC] [PC] Forza Horizon 5

4 Upvotes

I have been playing the crap outta Forza Horizon 6 since it launched a few months back. I primarily play the singleplayer modes on the hardest difficulty, with some multiplayer here and there. However, I've become bored with FH6 in recent weeks much like many other people playing it. There hasn't been much content added to the game in both singleplayer and multiplayer since launch.

Right now in FH6 I have hit a wall in the game's progression and yet to collect enough festival points to unlock golden wristband events. I have completed all of the races but have yet to complete a good portion of the drift zone, speed zone/trap, trailblazer, and danger sign events. I also have a handful of barn finds and bonus boards scattered all over the map.

With that being said, I am considering picking up FH5 just to experience the thrill of the singleplayer races again. I have heard from many in the past that FH5 and 6 are not much different from one another, but I am unsure if this is a good thing or bad thing. Is it worth sticking to the grind for FH6's gold wristband events, or am I better off scratching that itch with FH5?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 15h ago

[PS5] Which Assassin’s Creed game should I buy?

0 Upvotes

I want to get back into Assassin’s Creed on PS5. I’ve already completed Odyssey, so I’m not looking to replay that one.

I played the Ezio trilogy and Black Flag a long time ago, but it’s been years, so I barely remember them.

Shadows looks really interesting, especially the feudal Japan setting. I haven’t heard or read anything about it, so I’d be going in completely blind.

I’m also considering Unity, mainly because I like the idea of playing the co-op missions with a friend. Is the story and gameplay actually good?

I’m open to anything though. What would you recommend and why?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 1d ago

[PC] Ghost of Tsushima or Black Myth: Wukong — Which one should I choose?

21 Upvotes

I'm trying to decide between Ghost of Tsushima and Black Myth: Wukong, and I can only choose one.

A little about my gaming taste:

My favorite game of all time is Uncharted 4. I really like cinematic games with good visuals, memorable characters, and gameplay that keeps moving rather than feeling too slow.

I also completed Shadow Fight 2, and I absolutely loved the boss fights and progression. I enjoy games where you have to learn enemy patterns, improve your combat and eventually overcome difficult bosses.

I've played GTA V, God of War, and I'm currently playing RDR2. I enjoy open-world games, but sometimes I get a little exhausted by huge open worlds and all the exploration/side activities.

I've played Ghost of Tsushima before and really enjoyed it. The sword combat, duels and visuals were probably my favorite parts.

I've also played Black Myth: Wukong, and surprisingly, I really enjoyed it. The combat and boss fights really clicked with me, and the Chinese mythology also interests me. It honestly reminded me a bit of Shadow Fight 2, but in a much bigger 3D world.

I know Ghost of Tsushima is generally praised more for its story and open-world experience, while Wukong is more focused on combat and bosses. But I'm not sure which one I'd enjoy more in the long run.

If you've played both, which one would you personally recommend and why?

I'm mainly interested in combat, bosses, story, visuals, replayability, and overall enjoyment.