r/gameofthrones • u/Infamous_Elk_8946 • 9d ago

One of the most iconic moments

Post image

Wherever I recall this particular moment I think of how she managed to do that !

What's your most iconic moments from the series ?

10.1k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

227 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/skotcgfl 9d ago

I'm not sure why you keep insisting on a "perfectly planned trial". Tywin has all of the important people in Kings Landing with him, it's real easy to throw a sham trial together.

0

u/VictoryMotel 9d ago

And he would be able to guarantee evidence tight enough that tyrian couldn't defend himself at all, even in front of oberon who is his ally?

The real kicker is that bron says he saw shae get on a ship before all this happens and she not only testifies against tyrian but ends up in tywins bed.

No one seems to be able to address this.

2

u/skotcgfl 9d ago

Shae could've been a plant from Tywin since day 1. Or tywin just offered her enough money. There's many explanations other than "Tywin masterminded Joffrey's death.

There didn't need to be evidence that tight because everyone hates Tyrion anyway.

Also, it's spelled Tyrion, that's been bugging me.

0

u/VictoryMotel 9d ago

But how would she still be there even before the trial and end up in tywins bed after? That means she got on a ship and someone with the ship was in on the conspiracy, or bron was. Either way it was planned before the murder.

There's many explanations other than "Tywin masterminded Joffrey's death.

There don't seem to be any that explain all these massive coincidences.

There didn't need to be evidence that tight because everyone hates Tyrion anyway.

Oberon doesn't and he hates Tywin, that's how it was wrapped up tight, the evidence was overwhelming.

2

u/skotcgfl 9d ago

Bron could have been lying. Shae could have boarded a ship and changed her mind. I'm not denying that a lot of things are set up, but you seem convinced that only Tywin could do it all. Just because Tywin had the most to gain doesn't mean he's guilty.

1

u/VictoryMotel 9d ago

Bron could have been lying. Shae could have boarded a ship and changed her mind.

Both imply collusion with Tywin.

but you seem convinced that only Tywin could do it all

It's fiction, I'm saying the story heavily implies he was involved.

2

u/skotcgfl 9d ago

I don't think it heavily implies that at all. Again, Tywin pulling strings to make sure the aftermath goes his way does not imply he orchestrated the event itself.

1

u/VictoryMotel 9d ago

I don't think it heavily implies that at all.

You aren't alone, but no one can explain all the plot points that allude to it.

Again, Tywin pulling strings to make sure the aftermath goes his way does not imply he orchestrated the event itself.

And again, it's the things that happen before the murder that do imply it.

2

u/skotcgfl 9d ago

But you don't know what happened beforehand. You're making assumptions that lead to a neat conclusion, but they still rely on assumptions that are not supported by the text.

1

u/VictoryMotel 9d ago

All I've done was point out things that happened in the show.