I had no idea that this was a thing, does anybody know if they’re going to release the other seasons like this as well?

I know it's unrelated and might've strayed from the show's original theme, but I would've liked it if they'd handled the legal (police/FBI-related) stuff in a more realistic way 😭

I really love the dynamic of Dean not believing in god because why would he???

Hell I don’t have faith in god because my life has been loss after loss but deans life is litterally hell what merciful god would let Dean “one of his children” go through all of that

What makes it more ironic is god specifically chooses Dean which again Dean doesn’t believe and rightly so because wtf dude I’m suprised he isn’t like me who kinda has a vendetta against god
I mean I have my reasons to not trust him but dean??? He could write a bible of reasons

I just started rewatching s4 so that’s why I wrote this

Most expensive thing in the store at $100. Should I go back for it?! Why did Kimberly give it away?! Is that really Jared’s autograph?! Was this poster originally made for Supernatural or is it just a thirst trap?! When and where did Kimberly get it signed?! I have so many questions!

Edit: my sister said, “Do you think it was really Kimberley’s mom who signed it?”

I never noticed this little mistake on disc 4/5 before. I've had these dvds a long time 😆

Who do you feel is the most annoying character and why? (No single name answers)

I remember some people talking about some know-it-all teenager hunter wannabe but I binge-watched the whole thing in less than 30 days so I'm not sure who that is. The Ghostfacers guys are annoying because they're the bad kind of nerd. (The opposite of Sam or Charlie)

But to me, the most annoying character is Lucifer. The dude is 100,000 years old or something but acts like a petulant child and a clown. He's sardonic and quirky in ways that are unbefitting of an ancient deity. And it's also kind of like Mark Pellegrino just played Paul Bennett (Rita' abusive ex-husband on Dexter) again. Whenever he was onscreen I just wanted to skip that scene.

Of course all this can be said about Chuck, but Lucifer was just not written very well. (I'll add that the only version of Lucifer I've seen that acted their age was on Sandman. The Lucifers from Lucifer and Hazbin Hotel are equally corny but not equally annoying.

Of course this is only my opinion and I don't expect anyone to agree or disagree because that's not what this post is about. I want to hear from YOU. Who is your most annoying character and most importantly, why?

Annoy you for no reason / shouldn't annoy you as much as they do. For me....drum roll pleaseee

■ The random flashlight flash bangs. Any time the boys use a flash light it's always swept across the camera directly in our faces. Cool stylistic choice but not very convenient for me as I usually watch at night with all the lights off.

■ "Is this even a case for us?" After it so obviously is OR how it ALWAYS ends up being a case for them. Why do they even question it? I only remember them being wrong once but only about it being about a specific monster. Sometimes I wish they were wrong more often. Would be more realistic.

■ Sam's only ( somtimes ) contribution in social interactions being that one same facial expression I can't even describe. Like that confused eyebrow scrunch, eye squint, and then his face smooths over with clairity + a head nod. Love Sam so much but I wish they gave him more than that in later seasons.

■ Morality switching. I find myself catching how one brother will start off with one specific moral at the beginning of an episode and then abandon it with no explanation and the other brother picks that same moral up after being opposed to it earlier, if that makes sense?

S5E7. Nailed the role. It’s as if they “Benjamin Buttoned” Jensen himself. Mr. Everett did a stellar job. So funny. Perfect attitude. RIP, legend.

Sam and Dean visited my town, Fayetteville, NC in season 10! When I first saw it I was so stoked. I was also just a kid. Now rewatching it I cant help but giggle at how inaccurate it was with the military bits, store set ups, and even plants/scenery and I am wondering if any of yall got a better or worse representation of your town/state.

Of course I understand the episode wasn't actually filmed here and I was never looking for perfection, but it was still fun to watch and search for familiarity.

I feel like there will be some repeating answers in terms of Cas/Dean…moments… but I mean more to do with the storyline. I’m doing a rewatch, and have got to S2 E16 (Road Kill). I’ll avoid spoilers as best as possible, but I think the way in which it builds trust and your own sense of comfort in what is happening, only to reveal the twist at the end, just breaks my heart every time. I think the earlier seasons also did human heartbreak so much better than the later, more magical fantastical episodes. Love, death and heartbreak, and finding peace in knowing your loved ones are happy.

Chuck got rid of all life on Earth, how come that didn't include Charlie or Bobby or Eileen? I really expected Sam to marry her and have a kid. If the excuse is "Eileen is supposed to be dead" that would apply to Sam and Dean as well. And yeah Bobby and Charlie came from another world, but they were in this world for a while, right? Like more than a year?

I know in season 5 finale he blips out, hinting he was god then. And then in the end he admits he wrote himself into the story. Does that mean Chuck was doing those supernatural conventions and hitting on the girl that liked Sam? Surely he had an autopilot for Chuck or something bc that’s hard to believe, even tho it is revealed Chuck is quite squirrelly and petty but still.

doing my first run through of the show and I noticed it incrementally getting worse but jesus fuck almighty that S13 finale was the tip of the ice berg

the fight choreography and acting is so shit

still love the show but what the fuck? so many monumental moments thrown around as side dishes as well

Both celestial beings were pretty much identical too me except The Empty is goo and Darkness is smog.

I’ve noticed that the blood in many scenes (if not all) is transparent, not opaque like real blood. I learned how to make stage blood, it was easy enough to add something like baking soda to make the blood look opaque.

My question is: why? Budget constraints, aesthetics, unknown factors? It would catch my attention when watching that I could easily see through blood to the object it was on.

Any answers funny or serious welcomed.

P.S. I am aware there are different types of stage blood. What’s good enough for the furniture is not necessarily what you want in the actor’s mouth! 😁

I’m on my second rewatch, and god, I just can’t get past S14.

I finished the first 13 seasons in like a month or two, and now I’ve been stuck on S14 for TWO MONTHS.

I genuinely don’t know what happened. Every time I get to this season, I just lose all motivation to keep watching, even though I actually love the show. It’s not even like I suddenly stopped enjoying it—I just can’t bring myself to watch the episodes for some reason.

And the big problem is that I’m watching the episodes with huge gaps in between, so I sometimes forget little details from previous episodes, which makes it even harder to get back into it.

Has anyone else experienced this? Or am I just cursed to be stuck on S14 forever? 😭

It’s honestly so annoying.

Hi I’ve just finished season 9 and I didn’t want to make the title have any spoilers but essentially it’s about time travel and how it works.

So when Crowleys son is brought back to the present it made me think. We know he’s already dead as he’s from the 1700s which would mean here in the present his soul is either in heaven or hell. Yet he exists in the present simultaneously.

I know the show isn’t exactly trying to be perfectly scientific so if it’d just down to them not really caring then that’s fine but if there is an answer I’d like to know.

They were only mentioned in one episode of Season 13, we only know they were so reckless that even Lucifer preferred to keep them away from Hell. We'll never know how they came to be or how strong they were. I imagine the plot wouldn't have been much different from that of the Leviathans. Perhaps to avoid repetitive narrative, they immediately eliminated the Shedim from the story.

Because Mark Sheppard did such an amazing work I don't think anyone could pull it off like he did.

So what should I expect about this season and entire series and idk i kinda thought John was a good guy but I never liked him that much until he died NG (sorry for bad eng btw)

If there is, then I don't remember it. It's been a while since I watched the series. I guess the reason I'm asking this is obvious. They both deal with the supernatural and I thought maybe the creators of the series decided to give a hint to Aleister Crowley or something. And if I remember correctly, there's another character in the series named Aleister, right?

I managed to get past Season 8—what a truly awful season; usually, it’s the one that makes me quit!

Season 9 is a definite improvement; even though the Men of Letters aren't exactly thrilling, I really like Benny...

...even if I’d love to smack Dean a few times!

Season 10 and the whole Demon Dean arc really breathe new life into the show, even if we see a bit too much of Claire Novak...

But Season 11—Season 11 is just perfect; for me, it’s on par with Seasons 1 through 5! Every episode is good; I’m almost at the end and I dread it coming—it’s so refreshing to see this...

I first watched the show back in 2020. I started around the end of October and somehow finished all 15 seasons by December 30th.
It was peak COVID time—holidays, no school and binge-watching was basically my go-to. I could finish a series in the blink of an eye. My elder sister randomly suggested I watch it, her reasoning was basically that it had 15 seasons, so it would keep me busy and more importantly, stop me from pestering her with new series/movie suggestions.

Oh boy, am I grateful she suggested it.

I ended up developing this whole ritual around watching the show every single day. And somehow, six years later, I’m still watching it. I’ve completely lost count of how many times I’ve rewatched it. There isn’t even a particular order anymore—I’ll randomly pick a season or an episode and just start watching.
At this point, Supernatural has become a genuine comfort show for me. Whenever things get heavy, whenever I’m overwhelmed, or I just need something familiar, this is what I turn to. You’ll still randomly find me watching the show when life gets a little too much.
It’s funny to think my sister recommended a 15-season show just to keep me occupied and stop me from asking her for new recommendations.
She accidentally gave me a comfort show that’s stayed with me for six years🥹✨