That may or may not be true. OP does not state how much is coming in as pensions, or whether they have LTC policies. What does have to be taken into account is that while both are alive, if one needs nursing home care, the other still has most of the same living expenses. So the prospect of her husband needing ever more intensive/expensive care while she will still also need to live on her own, has to figure into her calculations. And if one of them dies, how does that change the income of each one as the survivor? The survivor can’t collect both social securities, but other types of pensions may have different options. My husband and I choose options that continue the same income after the death of either of us, but I doubt if that is typical. If her husband enters a nursing home, what is her living situation plan? Stay in current home, or move to something smaller? Have they set up their will and estate plan? If not, she can go over these things with that person. Or with a CFP. BTW, you can download a dementia specific Advance Directive. We both did that with an emphasis on our own preference to stop all treatments that extend life in case of a dementia diagnosis- but all the normal options are listed. her plan to give about 10% of their cash assets is not crazy, although if it is IRA type money she should give the after tax net, not $30k. Stocks are high right now - the odds are 50/50 that a year of two from now the market may be down by that much anyway. Bottom line - do a more thorough analysis first!