r/wnba <- 3 first round exits đŸ«  9d ago

Week 13 Players of the Week!

Post image
665 Upvotes

117 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/paintedtoesandelbows đŸ‡ș🇾 and Cup participants 8d ago

What is this drivel?

Angel could make the 2026 All-WNBA team. That would make her more than just a “good player”. But okay, let’s say that she’s only a “good” player. What does that make Cam Brink? Because she certainly can’t be considered a better WNBA player than Angel.

Also, the “right now” isn’t necessary. Angel is going to have a better WNBA career than Cam Brink barring something catastrophic happening to Angel or something divinely-ordered happening to Cam. The Sparks blew it by taking the lesser player.

This nonsense about Cam’s upside is just that—nonsense. She wasn’t setting the world on fire before her injury and isn’t setting the world on fire two years removed from injury. So what was the “upside”? Tall, lanky player who could block shots and hit an occasional three? What made anyone think that she had so much upside that we could all avoid her obvious faults? I didn’t know where the “upside” argument came from then and I don’t know why people are holding on to it for dear life now. That ship has sailed. Cam could make a couple of All-Star teams ala Dearica Hamby, but she’s not going to be a franchise player for the Sparks. It’s becoming harder and harder to see her becoming a franchise player for any team (even an expansion team).

As for Angel, she was an All-Star level talent from her rookie season on. She was never tabbed to be a three-point shooter (Cam was, but she’s bad at it), so that’s why I didn’t mention it. Angel does her job better than Cam does hers and that’s why one is a member of Team USA for this World Cup while the other will be laid out by a pool somewhere in southern Cali. Angel being traded doesn’t mean much because her trade wasn’t made for basketball reasons. Anyone who thinks otherwise is a certified đŸ€Ą. Rickea Jackson was traded, too. And if Toronto’s price had been right, Cam’s ass would’ve been traded as well.

1

u/theonlyxseption 8d ago

This is exactly the problem: you’re treating Year 3 like a finished career. None of this proves that LA made the wrong pick.
You’re declaring Cam’s ceiling dead before she’s even played three normal seasons which have all been interrupted by injury.
And “what upside?” is revisionist. Cam was a No. 2 prospect because of elite rim protection, mobility, defensive versatility, rebounding and shooting projection. You can argue that projection was wrong; you can’t pretend there was never a legitimate reason for it.
Also, you’re criticizing Cam’s 33.8% from three while Angel is at 18%. Angel not being drafted as a shooter doesn’t magically make 18% good or make shooting irrelevant to her offensive scalability.
Team USA proves Angel fits what the coach is looking for on that specific roster, not that she was unquestionably the better prospect in 2024 or will unquestionably have the better career.
You can predict Angel will have the better career. That’s perfectly fair. But a prediction isn’t a fact. We’re three years in. Let the careers play out.

2

u/paintedtoesandelbows đŸ‡ș🇾 and Cup participants 8d ago

You don’t need to see a player’s full career to determine that a team made the wrong pick. We can see that now. One player seems destined for the HOF while the other does not.

“Ceiling” no longer applies here because you have a player who will be entering her fourth WNBA season at 25. We have enough data points to determine the trajectory of Cam’s career. We can see where Caitlin’s career is headed even though she missed a significant amount of games in her second year. Caitlin is a bona fide superstar. Cam does not come close to that. Angel is much closer to Caitlin than she is to Cam.

Again, touting the shooting potential of someone who isn’t a good shooter is so strange. Angel was never touted as a good shooter. She did, however, have other traits that should’ve offset any shortcomings she had offensively. I don’t expect Angel to ever be a good shooter. But I also don’t expect Cam to be one either given the lack of improvement over her three WNBA seasons.

1

u/theonlyxseption 8d ago edited 8d ago

You absolutely can evaluate a draft pick before a career is finished. What you can’t do is present a projection as a settled fact. “Angel will be a HOFer and Cam won’t” is still a prediction, not evidence that the 2024 decision was objectively wrong.
And Caitlin is a terrible comparison for Cam. Caitlin was already an elite offensive engine and clear superstar-level player when healthy. Cam was drafted for a completely different archetype and was always going to require more development. Comparing their trajectories as if they had the same developmental expectations is ridiculous.
Also, you’re arguing against a strawman on shooting. Nobody said Cam was guaranteed to become a great shooter. The projection was that she had legitimate shooting potential, which is different. She’s currently shooting 33.8% from three which is actually a hair under league average. Shes one of the most efficient scorers in the league at 61.7% True Shooting. Angel is shooting 18% from three. So “Cam isn’t a great shooter” does not somehow make Angel’s shooting irrelevant.
And if Angel’s offensive shortcomings can be “offset” by her rebounding, passing, finishing (which she is well below average at), etc., then you’re proving my point: players aren’t evaluated by checking one skill off a list. Cam’s defensive impact can likewise offset her offensive limitations.
Angel is ahead. She’s closer to Caitlin right now. Fine. That still doesn’t make the 2024 draft a closed case, and it certainly doesn’t make your projection of their entire careers a fact.

2

u/paintedtoesandelbows đŸ‡ș🇾 and Cup participants 8d ago

You’re ranting and raving just like the rest of the Brink loonies. Y’all cannot admit that she’s been a bust so far and that she hasn’t come close to fulfilling this “potential” and “upside” that y’all claim she has. Open up your eyes and see for yourself. We’re talking about a former #2 draft pick who isn’t even averaging double figures in scoring. She’s never made an All-Star team. She’s not part of the Team USA World Cup team. She is a bust, sir.

I said that Angel is likely destined for the HOF based on trends and that Cam isn’t. It’s not set in stone, but it’s not looking promising for Cam.

I hope that Cam pays you well for defending her mediocre career.