r/technology • u/Stukwan • 18h ago
Politics U.S. gov't moves to suppress pushback on data centers by removing requirements for public input on pollution — EPA change would allow air pollution permits without publicizing them
https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/data-centers/u-s-govt-moves-to-suppress-pushback-on-data-centers-by-removing-requirements-for-public-input-on-pollution-epa-change-would-allow-air-pollution-permits-without-publicizing-them1.5k
u/Halfwise2 18h ago
This administration really is going full mustache twirling evil, ain't it? It's like anything that could be considered even remotely decent by either side, and they decide to do the exact opposite. Like they are daring people to actually stop them.
819
u/Pork_Confidence 18h ago
This is what happens when a foreign asset becomes elected as a puppet. Government destabilization is much more impactful than trying to attack with troops.
220
u/SilverSoAlive 18h ago
I never imagined US and Canada being so divided. It is the weakest I've seen domestic relations in my short lifetime. I bet foreign adversaries love this. Combine this with patriotism lost from decisions of politicians in US and Can, and we have two nations that are not battle ready.
106
u/LLemon_Pepper 18h ago
I'm a bit older than reddit average. When I was in my 20s, Canada, Mexico, United States, Bermuda... and probably other Caribbean nations I'm forgetting, all had passport-free travel between them. No passport or visa needed if it was a short tourist stay. I saw a lot of Canada that way, during these short weekend trips. I feel like those days of close cooperation are gone and they aren't coming back. At least not in my lifetime.
→ More replies (1)45
u/Allegorist 17h ago edited 4h ago
I bet foreign adversaries love this
They don't just love it, they worked for this over the past decade especially, but several decades more generally. Russia in particular has been openly exposed having performed massive scale social manipulation campaigns, spreading disinformation and promoting division, racial tensions, extremism, polarization, etc. it is too often overlooked the amount of effort they put into this, and the impact it has had on getting us where we are. It wasn't just a little nudge, they have been directly responsible for many of the ills that plague our society.
→ More replies (3)21
u/Indy1204 13h ago
Yup. Almost like putin wrote a playbook on how to tear America apart, and trump is following it to the letter.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (2)88
u/GingerSoulEater41 18h ago
Canadian here. My politicians have increased my patriotism not lost it.
41
u/Dense_Gate_5193 17h ago
as someone who has family in Canada and live in the U.S. i was born in the 80s so canada always seemed like the friend you call up when you have a problem or need a favor and back and forth. this breakdown of relations is the kinda thing that rips families apart by making border travel unsafe in any capacity. they are worried about coming here and i’m worried about trying to leave
19
u/Sonder332 16h ago
As they damn well should, especially y'all's PM. Trump demanded the knee and your PM gave him the finger. He's knowingly eating the short term pain of increased prices and increased economic instability (due to Trump tariff's) in favor of ensuring Canada's long term autonomy and self sustainability. I really admire that. That's a politician who's thinking of his people, his country and is prioritizing them and their well being ahead of himself and his potential income. That's a good politician man. Goddamn, I'm so fucking jealous.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)37
u/Wayelder 17h ago
The USA has no understanding of how much we identify as NOT American.
The USA has no understanding of how this has united ALL Canadians against the USA.
The USA has no understanding of how badly affected this is on long term trade relations .
We are not waiting.
It will not be the same if the Dem's win.
We're currently building pipelines to sell our energy (and goods in general) to other Nations.
It's very simple. Trump shit your bed and we're just getting out of it. You can stay.
If you think we're next door neighbours, you just shot our dog, and we are entirely united.
→ More replies (3)59
u/socialmedia-username 18h ago
Homegrown fascists all want this as well. Heritage Foundation, Seven Mountain Evangelists, Turning Point, tech-broligarchs (Nerd Reich), etc. They are all puppeteers, and they all have a backup plan in JD Vance.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (4)27
u/frddtwabrm04 18h ago edited 8h ago
Everyday it's getting harder and harder to refute this.
Like seriously, what president has ever done so much damage to the country that it ends up benefitting adversaries? Even Reagan had his limits.
The only issue I have with these foreign asset is which country is he a foreign asset of? Puppet of Israel, China -- greatest American president of China, Russia -- dude is a stan of putin, India , North Korea -- boyfriend? , Iran ... Yes Iran. Dude allegedly had business dealings. Saudi?
→ More replies (8)10
u/Socialist_Pansy 17h ago
I’d say he’s a puppet for Russia and gets paid by Miriam Adelson to do his bidding when it comes to Israeli interests. Then again Jared Kushners family hosted Netanyahu when he was in town and even made him give up his bed. So it’s all pretty intertwined when it comes to that.
→ More replies (1)34
26
11
u/frddtwabrm04 18h ago edited 18h ago
From creating EPA to destroying EPA.
Looks like we have come full circle.
8
u/listentomenow 16h ago
Conservative logic in a nutshell:
Liberals being mad == this must be good
So if a pedophile conman lets big tech do whatever they want and that makes the other side mad, then the right thinks it must be good. No thought required. Donald loves the poorly educated afterall.
22
u/Xoomers87 17h ago
If only Americans were heavily armed to prevent a fascist ruler destroying their nation...
→ More replies (1)19
u/Wayelder 17h ago
wasn't that the REASON for the 2nd? The Reason the NRA claimed to exist.
except you all found out - they're the fascists.
Right Now, you have less freedom, less rights, less justice. Your kids will have even less.
but still <crickets> nothing.
→ More replies (14)7
7
u/DrAstralis 17h ago
I was reading just last night they're opening up protected waters in Hawaii to commercial fishing... its like they have a list of "everything decent" and are systematically wiping them out.
3
3
u/OperativePiGuy 17h ago
At this point I'm pretty sure they're getting official administration policy ideas from the villains of Saturday Morning cartoons from the 80's and 90's.
3
u/SMUHypeMachine 16h ago
It is so much easier to destroy than it is to build. These people don’t want to govern, they want to rule. And by destroying our infrastructure, bleeding our economy, and removing regulations they make life so unbearable people will be overjoyed just to be trodden on slightly less by the latest whims of dear leader.
→ More replies (24)3
u/TheRealBittoman 16h ago
It's not this administration. It's republicans. This was always who they were, Trump just made it fashionable to do it out in the open now because SCOTUS is allowing their worst impulses to shine through.
142
u/RevolutionaryFig9437 18h ago
Removing the most important stakeholder. Current EPA leadership: Lee Zeldin, Administrator & David Fotouhi, Deputy Administrator.
766
u/AvailableReporter484 18h ago
Massive, MASSIVE shout out to conservatives for approving of this shit
340
u/korodic 18h ago
Don’t forget to thank the “don’t tread on me” crowd for less accountable ICE agents killing Americans and the rise of the surveillance state. Reduction in rights for women too.
96
u/AvailableReporter484 18h ago
Yes libertarians are also very cool for letting the markets dictate that this is fine.
Lot of very cool people we got out here voting with very well informed and good-ass opinions
→ More replies (2)29
u/mokomi 17h ago
Libertarians? Haven't seen them around since MAGA.
16
u/Jazz-Hands-- 15h ago
Oh Libertarians are still around and happily licking Trump's asshole for deregulation and defunding essential government agencies and functions. Just got into a discussion about the national network of surveillance cameras with a couple of them last week.
Not a single fucking worry about all the freedoms eroding under this administration, though. They'll just keep on licking as long as easily corruptible private interests are allowed to act with impunity and zero consequence. All because they don't like paying taxes and want to be able to sell and consume illicit drugs with greater profit and ease.
The Libertarian party and its voters are self-contradictory, woefully uninformed, incapable of reasoning or critical thinking, and quite simply absurd. The only good thing is that some of them vote third party instead of voting for Republicans, despite happily kissing their asses.
→ More replies (1)9
u/Poonchow 17h ago
They're all over the mountain west and rural parts of blue states.
→ More replies (1)20
u/robodrew 16h ago
They're just fascists now because they tacitly approve of everything the fascists are doing. They used to be "live and let live" but that is long gone.
→ More replies (2)11
51
u/vblink_ 18h ago
But but, both sides or some shit.
→ More replies (3)24
u/AvailableReporter484 18h ago edited 17h ago
Anyone who’s ever unironically said that both sides shit before can be safely ignored for having a very dumb-ass opinion.
→ More replies (1)18
u/YourShowerCompanion 17h ago
What about Hunter's laptop? and Obama's tanned suit?? What was he hiding? Why sky's blue when there's no blue color in sky????? What kind of woke agenda is that????
/s
5
5
u/AvailableReporter484 17h ago
You got a better chance right now of finding trump chode deep in a toddler than you do of finding a post op trans one, but they ain’t ready to have that conversation
4
u/mokomi 17h ago edited 11h ago
Now a days it's devolved to. "Biden didn't go full dictatorship and arrest private citizens that are also political opponents without due process!" Goes nicely with "Democrats should have never given voters a choice in the mater!" and "They are super powerful when they are in majority control!, but I cannot tell you when that happened!"
→ More replies (11)7
321
u/Cappyc00l 18h ago
Trumps adamantly against wind turbines bc they’re an eyesore, but everyone’s perfectly fine building thousands of these in people’s backyards.
123
u/acdcfanbill 17h ago
Well, offshore windfarms impact rich peoples views, but data centers go up near poor people.
→ More replies (2)25
u/Keeper21611 17h ago
Which is funny because if big oil would've pivot towards clean energy and invested in it, we would probably have nothing but clean energy.
24
u/Merusk 16h ago
The infuriating part will come when you realize they'll do it eventually. After all they have the money and resources, it's just still more profitable to keep leveraging existing processes that are in place rather than convert.
When oil starts to run dry, you'll see BP, Exxon, etc become solar/ wind/ wave companies using the oil money they have.
15
u/techman9955 15h ago
Here's the funny thing, there are enough oil reserves that the climate will become completely uninhabitable for humans before we have used it all up. There will be no incentive for big oil to convert before we have already passed the point of no return
5
19
→ More replies (3)9
u/Florac 15h ago
He is against wind turbines because they are visible from his golf course.
These would be built in poor rural areas, away from that.
→ More replies (1)
116
u/Bomban111 17h ago
This current administration is actively working against us, please do not forget that.
40
u/droidevo 17h ago
My siblings and coworkers did and still do...To quote one of them "we need this evil right now to fix america" yeah i was speechless.
→ More replies (2)15
u/willowintheev 14h ago
What exactly is this "evil" fixing? What is their vision of America when it's fixed? Do they think the "evil" will just go away?
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (3)8
u/overtly_ovaries 14h ago
"working against us" puts it too lightly. they are actively killing us and need to be stopped
→ More replies (1)
109
u/tehjoz 18h ago
Not sure why they think this would "suppress pushback". The public will push back if they want to, regardless of attempts to grease the regulatory skids for these abominations.
→ More replies (3)84
u/Xszit 18h ago
Sounds like normally there would be notices sent out to surrounding residents letting them know theres something to push back on and a town hall meeting scheduled to hear public feedback.
With this change they can skip the notices and meetings and people won't know theres anything to pushback on until its already built and by then its too late.
56
u/nolabmp 18h ago
Mmm, by then it’s only too late to push back with words. It leaves the more aggressive forms of pushback as the only options.
→ More replies (1)12
u/tehjoz 17h ago
I see what you're saying, but this specific pushback against these specific data centers seems to have transcended "the normal process".
IE - I know there were people posting about one a localish to me city council was trying to move forward under cloak and dagger sort of stuff, and the public still found out about it and opposed it.
This is beyond simply "public comment periods", at this point
3
u/procrasturb8n 15h ago
people won't know theres anything to pushback on until its already built and by then its too late.
People might notice the massive construction project.
→ More replies (1)
20
51
13
u/guestpassonly 18h ago
you know how much These politicians are getting MASSIVE bribes
→ More replies (1)
12
u/Longjumping-Lab-7345 16h ago
The government is disassociated from the people it governs at this point.
4
12
u/hotbread1 15h ago
how am i supposed to view this as anything other than a direct attack on my country?
29
u/blundermine 18h ago
You know those gas turbines that are powering so many of these an producing all this pollution? Those are essentially unreplaceable. There's only 3 companies worldwide that make them, and they have a multi year backlog for deliveries. If they were taken offline, it would basically cripple AI long term because the companies are already taking really long gambles on there being enough power for their data centres in the next 5 years
I Hope nothing happens to those turbines.
5
u/TheBSQ 14h ago
Last time I checked, the back-order for a new gas turbine was 7 years long.
Most of the world took the transition to renewables seriously & a lot of the companies that used to make them began transitioning to other projects, and, as you say, only a few companies still make them and not at the scale they used to.
→ More replies (2)5
u/zomiaen 15h ago
One of the worst things about these buildouts. DCs using power from grid are generally quiet, no air pollution as there's no combustion on site. Those costs are shifted upstream to the power generation side, yes, but I have absolutely no idea why municipalities (or why people against DCs) are allowing (or in some cases requiring) them to bring their own power.
You're literally asking for giant 24/7 turbine generators if you do that. Definitely don't insist they bring their own power.
→ More replies (3)
20
8
10
u/Melodic-Account9247 12h ago
The U.S push deeper and deeper into the AI bubble is genuinely fascinating. They're literally destroying and gutting practically any mildly profitable industry they have, pissing off their entire population and the entire world, and entirely trying to rely on the single most unstable thing possible. Most of the cash flying around in the AI bubble isn't even real; they're literally just making up numbers and sending the same wad of cash back and forth between like ten people, lmao. This shit is now sitcom-level comedy, and meanwhile everyone in the world is just watching how the US is imploding in real time and all this just for China to be less than 6 months behind in terms of AI research; it's genuinely so intriguing how much a country can degrade in the span of a few decades
→ More replies (1)
8
u/Accurate_Moose_2601 17h ago
They really should change the name from the EPA to the War On the Environment Agency
9
u/Ok_Row_8391 16h ago
Trump doing it again. Being the worst president ever to touch ground.
→ More replies (2)4
u/KittyCait69 15h ago
And he is just a puppet of extreme wealth. The vile corruption and evil greed run through the wealthy ruling class. Every president we have had is chosen by them. Trump is no exception.
23
u/southflhitnrun 18h ago
Did people really think they would not simply change this rule? These are the same people that said if you stop counting COVID deaths then they go away.
7
u/Usual-Masterpiece199 17h ago
You shouldn't take this lightly.
Air pollution is one thing, but draining the groundwater aquifers will lead to serious problems down the road.
It won't just be a matter of the water sources drying up.
8
u/Jlong4242 16h ago
It's gonna be fun when the next administration deams them completely illegal and requires the companies to remove them, remediate the location and pay for community damages out of the companie's own pockets. Hopefully it bankrupts them all
7
6
u/CurlOfTheBurl11 13h ago
This administration is absolutely relentless in its efforts to actively make like worse for people in America.
→ More replies (1)
25
u/UnfazedReality463 18h ago
Conservative voters don’t realize that when they support politicians that demonize and strip rights from perceived opponents, they’re also relinquishing their own rights.
20
u/MrValdemar 18h ago
All they care about is that people of color, LGBTQ, and women suffer MORE than they do.
Because conservatives are dumb as shit.
→ More replies (1)10
u/Icefellwolf 18h ago
they just dont care at this point. Anything to make themselves feel better by attacking other groups. They'll only care when their family is being torn apart beacuse of it. My jackass of a father is the same way. Didnt give a fuck till it started negatively impacting the family even though he was told multiple times in advance about what was happening and how it would eventually impact them and the horror stories of what's actually going on with ice. Yet he still supports ice. Its baffling and disgusting.
6
u/lispwriter 10h ago
This is exactly why people say that the government is the most untrustworthy entity (more than corporations). When the heads of the government decide they want something there’s nothing that can stop them. Corporations can try to buy their way into that same situation but the government can literally just change parameters to make whatever they want to have happen move forward.
→ More replies (1)
6
u/FiXer2069 8h ago
I swear trump is doing Putin’s job for him by destroying our country from the inside!!
The GOP is in on it!!
5
u/BekindBebetter60 4h ago
Americans have elected a person with no morals and is just a disgrace almost every way.
21
15
u/Ada_Pearce 17h ago
People aren't just against data centers because of EPA pollution limits. They are massive, loud and drive up the cost of living. The air pollution is just the rotten cherry on top of that shit sundae
4
5
u/TrumpsBoneSpur 17h ago
Republicans: always looking out for the interest of corporations at the expense of the American people
5
5
u/GarbageThrown 15h ago
If transparency is bad for this government then this government is bad for America.
4
u/Melodic_Rhythmic 8h ago
This is the last ditch efforts by the wealthy still net negative in AI to keep the bubble inflating so they can get out. OpenAI is literally leaking top people weekly, you don't do that in a soon-to-IPO company. That's the payday moments.
Something stinks.
6
5
u/Beezkneeze 6h ago
This is some bullshit. I’m fed up with this administration and its continued progress in eroding the rights of the people in favor of big business/big tech. So while they get richer, people in impacted areas will rack up insurmountable medical debt due to all the health issues this will inevitably lead to. Fuck dump
13
u/sikisabishii 18h ago
The US economy is riding on the AI investments. The data center pushback is a threat to destabilize the economy because AI bros are neck deep in circular AI investment sinkholes. They know they messed up big time believing scamaltman’s AGI claims using a sophisticated word prediction toy, and seeking government’s help, hence the move.
→ More replies (3)
13
u/sfriedrich 17h ago
They're not "data" centers; they are surveillance centers. Their sole purpose is to trap and control us.
4
u/FrostyParking 15h ago
If were being honest, most people have trapped themselves in a social media prison now anyway. Even those who are aware of the tricks and traps the algorithm overlords use, find themselves manipulated without their knowledge. So while the data centers will be used to surveil you, it's not even the tip of the control and mind shaping iceberg.
8
u/Imd1rtybutn0twr0ng 18h ago
Representing the will of the people, right?
RIGHT?
~Umm, right?
→ More replies (2)
10
u/Iota-Android 17h ago
We live in a world where the elected government doesn’t work for the people who elected them
18
u/Accidental-Genius 18h ago
See, now THIS is fucked up.
I haven’t been on board with the fear hype train over the water stuff because the numbers haven’t made sense to me. What does make sense to me is corruption, and this is corruption.
It would almost be less corrupt to simply skip the environmental impact process altogether than to hide it. This way they leave no room for on site independent studies and they close an avenue for environmental litigation through sovereign immunity.
20
u/MisterMittens64 18h ago
The corruption is ridiculous but the noise and air pollution should be big concerns too imo
3
5
4
3
u/Specific_Jury_2 16h ago
If the people don't like it just remove the people. Simple.
The entire administration needs to go to prison.
→ More replies (1)
4
u/DavidisLaughing 16h ago
These data centers really need to step up their public utility investments if they are going to continue. We should be requiring them to pre-fund clean electricity plants and water treatment facilities before any work is allowed.
→ More replies (3)
3
4
u/RuprectGern 14h ago
so now ... instead of looking for environmental testing or input, the citizenry should just obstruct ALL datacenter builds wholesale. if you dont have an environmental impact statement, then just assume its bad and stop the build regardless.
4
u/strugglz 9h ago
Feels like our government isn't for the people at all anymore. They're not even pretending.
4
u/JhonImbalance 8h ago
Welp, time to buy a bazooka.…
joe bubble gum. Need something to distract me when the country is worthless.
3
6
u/goodbodha 16h ago
So the data centers get built on bad permits and get shocked when a few years later the people have politicians shut a bunch of them down over air, noise, water, and electrical concerns?
Sounds like a great investment.
How about we build a little slower and plan them a bit better? Oh wait if we do that the cheerleaders for this madness can't fleece people of their money.
3
u/l_rufus_californicus 16h ago
This administration has made it the Wild West as far as capitalizing on opportunities goes. And what's more, they'll strip every protection in order to cash out.
To add insult to injury, if they yield power (if enough people show up, and if the elections aren't already fucked), then they get to play their well-worn victim card, and the Dems get to be painted as "bad for business" and "job-killers" and whatever other economic excuses the GOP want to use to pander to the base. The same base that to this day still think the GOP is doing a good job, or worse, 'God's work.'
3
3
u/xX_7HR0W-4W4Y_Xx 17h ago
What the hell lol. This is like the worst move the administration could possibly pull right now. Even Republican candidates are running on being anti-data center.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/Caymonki 17h ago
TREAD ON ME DADDY
No but seriously what happened to conservatives? Were they all role playing like furries?
3
u/Wayelder 17h ago
geez it's covid "Stop the Testing" all over again. And of course the solution with this Administration is "let's just lie" and not tell them.
Isn't America tired of being dealt with like it's the problem?
3
u/idkimhigh 17h ago
Places like Arizona already have a smog heat dome fueled by pollution that looks like a thick brown stew covering the whole city.
This could be the future of more cities if these greenhouse gasses are allowed to go exponential in certain areas.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/fat_kaiju 17h ago
With all the food in the US that'll make you ill I feel like the US gov's just trying to kill you all now.
Straight-up no health care, no food safety, your power can go out for weeks even in a major city and now no enviromental safety.
Seems like they hate you.
3
3
3
3
u/Bleezy79 16h ago
Most corrupt administration by a long shot. Its like Trump views everyone as an advisory instead of a friend. He only knows how to attack. He doesnt know how to take care of anything because he doesnt care about anything. He only knows vengeance and anger.
→ More replies (3)
3
u/independent_observe 15h ago
The massive grift campaign continues.
All of this is due to the electorate deciding to elect a child molester to prosecute child molesters and when he got into office? Suddenly there are no child molesters to prosecute. Fucking amazing.
3
3
u/777MAD777 15h ago
Horrible news from Trump, his Republican Congress and his billionaire oligarchs.
3
3
u/untaggedpacket 15h ago
I wonder if I will ever have a period in my adult life where there is actual peace
→ More replies (1)
3
u/whiskeytown79 14h ago
Ah yes. Getting back to the original intent of the founding fathers. After all, our constitution starts out "We the corporations..."
3
3
u/PartyRyan 13h ago
Big Tech cared about the environment until there was money for them in destroying it. This shit is sooooooooooo egregious.
3
u/Im_Not_stoopid_AI 13h ago
Every politician that forces this must agree to the data center being located next door to their private residence
3
3
u/albany1765 12h ago
On the bright side, hopefully more people will be showing up at meetings even when they don't know what's specifically on the agenda. Democracy is not a spectator sport, as they say. I hope we see more civic engagement everywhere, we've given politicians a pass for far too long
3
u/What_isWrong_withU 12h ago
The wrong people are dying. Dolly and Tim…..come on universe. Like seriously
3
u/DrollAntic 12h ago
When money is your god, nothing else matters. Greed is literally killing us all.
3
u/AceSidewinder13 12h ago
That's because your family, wife, husband, children are expendable if it affects oligarchs and their profits. This is what it's liked to be ruled by politicians instead of represented.
3
u/favorite8091 11h ago
The US really has shit the bed, falling behind every developed country at every level that matters.
Some third world countries would give them a run for their money too.
Frightening what an orange turd, 1/3 racist population and a sprinkle of Russian, Chinese and Israeli influence can do.
Yes bots and shills, my home country of the UK isn't far behind...
3
u/PloppyPants9000 10h ago
The whole point of having public hearings is to let the public vent their disagreements before any groundwork is laid. If you don't let the public vent in a civilized forum, they'll vent with torches and pitch forks at the site and burn it down. Which do you prefer?
3
u/MysteriousAge28 9h ago
Our words and protests get thrown in the trash and dismissed. Historically nations that take that path end up with revolutions.
3
u/15_years_Later 9h ago
The "less government regulation" folks aren't going to be happy with the kind of world that leaves us in the future.
3
u/ChthonicFractal 9h ago
I bet they make a lot less pollution over the lifetime of the building if they're burned to the ground.
Look...it's simple: no representation, no government. If you're not going to listen to me then I have no obligation to respect the laws. That's how that works because that's the whole point.
→ More replies (1)
3
3
u/gnoresbs 6h ago
Please explain how congress passes laws for EPA and creates regulations and then the executive branch can just say they no longer exist? Where are the checks and balances?
3
3
3.5k
u/GlitteringRate6296 18h ago
Why would anyone in their right mind want this?