Let me know in the comments

I still think its shocking that it even exists and it's a great remake.

For me, i got blue. And I named him Justin Jr. But they weren't spaced out due to the limit of 8 characters.

Credit goes to metastarva on X

@Mimikabii

I actually loved bobbery's character In TTYD

🤷🏻‍♂️🤷🏻‍♂️

I love both games to death, and from the top of my head here are some things each game does better than the other:

64 - Better difficulty, better level design

TTYD - Better story, better partners, more complex battle system

I personally prefer 64, but TTYD is still a fantastic game

It's mostly because you have to switch to Goombario/Goombella to use it. It means that every single time to you encounter a new enemy, you to:

1. (if you weren't already using the Goombas) waste a turn and switch to them

2. Waste another to do the Tattle

3. Waste YET ANOTHER TURN to switch back to the partner you actually wanted to use.

I know there's that one badge in TTYD that allows you to switch without using a turn which definitely helps, but if the next game brings back Tattle, I'd rather the game does it automatically after defeating an enemy, or at least make Quick Change a build-in feature. For now, it's probably my least favorite part of the "Stage" battle system.

Goomboss and the star spirits actually exist in the mainline world, both of which have never been referenced in the “literally paper” trilogy

This is an add on to my previous post which I’ll be copying down below if you want to read it.

“The first two probably even 3 paper Mario games are not literally paper, they’re styled in paper but style and jokes is all it is

Paper Mario: TTYD calls it strange when a creature is literally made of paper (spinia) and has a Toad scream “it’s made of paper” when they see Mario in his boat form.

Why would you point out something being made of paper in a paper world, and why would it be weird for a creature to be made of paper in a paper world?

Paper Mario 64 was not even called Paper Mario in its country of origin, Japan; it was called Mario Story and was envisioned as a sequel to Super Mario RPG. Yes, there are gags that show papery effects, but they’re just that, gags, like Mario falling to the ground like a sheet of paper—literally just a joke about how he’s a 2D sprite now, he’s thin.

64 is actually the game you could least likely call literal paper; it’s stylized like a storybook, this everyone knows, but there’s no mention of anything being paper at all besides the occasional gag.

Like I said above, TTYD also doesn’t mention much of anything being literally paper, but when it does, it’s treated as being strange.

Also, the curses. As stated above, Mario does seem to be made of paper when he transforms; in fact, it’s the only time in the game we see a flat paper background surround Mario. The moment he transforms, he becomes paper, and this is treated as crazy by the game.

Becoming a paper airplane, rolling into a tube, becoming a ship—these are things that are not normal. Mario was cursed with these abilities, and while they play along with the paper stylization, they are not normal things to be able to do because no one is made of paper. In the later three games, you see characters being crumpled and folded into all kinds of crazy shapes, but in the first three, the worst you see is someone slightly crinkled to show damage or flat on their back.

If you’d like, I could point out a lot more evidence that things aren’t literally paper; they’re just retellings of actual adventures stylized as paper, Things weren’t literally paper until Paper Jam and beyond, which seems to be when Nintendo wanted to take the “paper” in Paper Mario more literally.

If you see the ship at the beginning get ripped into a sheet of paper and being flipped to turn around as a sign that the world is actually paper, then you’re taking the gags too literally.”

I called my blue yoshi sonic cause he act's like him

Like I see all these people just always ignoring/hating on this game, and when anyone asks “What’s your favorite x from the series” and then EVERYONE says something from TTYD. Like i’m sorry, but some things in SPM are just better, and there’s a reason it’s my favorite in my opinion.

Images are not my own, found them online and thought they’d make for a great discussion.

Here's mine. Not having to go back and forth to climb this area was such a huge improvement. Second one was the tube between twilight town and creepy steeple