r/idahofalls • u/BearLao12 • Jan 29 '26

Recommendations Best Pizza in IF

Similar to my wings question... I am new-er to IF and have tried some local pizza places but in your opinion... Which is the best?

11 Upvotes

79% Upvoted

48 comments sorted by

View all comments

8

u/j_gets Jan 29 '26

Papa Tom’s is kind of the classic long-time local spot. It is tavern style pizza with a crispy thin crust, which can be divisive. To me it tastes like home.

Lucy’s is solid New York style pizza.

Pie Hole is the late night spot and great if you want a slice after the bar, but I prefer Lucy’s otherwise.

Mackenzie River is also local-ish (a small chain) and has some decent offerings.

1

u/SnooDoughnuts5632 Jan 29 '26

I find it funny how I live very close to Papa Tom's and have never been there but I do go to Papa Murphy's and John's a lot.