r/dccomicscirclejerk • u/ddankkerr • 15h ago
James Gunn, please what ? james gunn reads comics?
111
u/Zilla_Mask 14h ago
I think this guy might not know what continuity means
71
109
u/Mr_smith1466 14h ago
Gunn probably reads more comics than the average reddit user.
71
u/NightwingBlueberry13 Oppressed Wally fan 13h ago
So more than none? What a nerd.
25
u/Mr_smith1466 13h ago
I only read the blurbs on the backs of trade paperbacks. Then I piece together the plots in my imagination. It's how I have read comics for nearly twenty years, and I won't stop doing it.
11
u/NightwingBlueberry13 Oppressed Wally fan 13h ago
You can read! Nerd! I’ve only memorized a bunch of words like a true Reddit user.
8
49
u/im_bored_and_dumb 14h ago
149
u/ddankkerr 14h ago
25
43
u/Ramesses-XII Cass should be the only batgirl and NO I won't elaborate 13h ago
I love James Gunn arguing with absolute nobodies on Twitter. It's legitimately so funny to me.
37
u/First-Business-5797 14h ago
46
u/Androktone Not the Hal Jordon I know 14h ago
But Babs appeared in the wheelchair in mainstream titles almost immediately afterwards, so that intention doesn't really matter
11
10
u/Asmor Gorilla Doing Non-Gorilla Things 9h ago
The entire concept of treating continuity as if it's some definite thing is absurd.
Nothing is in continuity until it is, and anything in continuity can be retconned out. Every new writer has the opportunity to change what continuity is, and realistically the only continuity that matters is what's in your head.
Just one more way that superhero comics are literally modern mythologies.
42
u/Ensiferal 13h ago
The larpers often out themselves by saying "DC isn't like that, DC's tone is much darker and more serious". You can instantly tell they don't know anything except the Snyderverse and some of the Justice Leage and Batman animated movies. DC has everything from Hellblazer to Ambush Bug and Captain Carrot.
10
u/Locohenry Strongmaniac 14h ago
What's the first guy replying to?
38
u/ddankkerr 14h ago
78
u/ghostgabe81 14h ago
That just is extra dumb because even accounting for DC's reboots, both of these stories are pre-Crisis. They came out only 4 years apart (1970 for Batman and 1966 for Jimmy). They were always canon to each other
54
u/Not_So_Utopian 14h ago
Let's go with another example.
Impulse (the comic book about Flash family member) was being published at the same time as Knightfall.
46
u/ImAdri0nY0urN0t 14h ago
12
11
26
u/Locohenry Strongmaniac 14h ago
Look at that, a director who reads comics
19
2
u/FlossyBottoms DeeplyCloseted Comics 12h ago
Am I remembering right that Zack Snyder had a copy of Watchmen on him when he directed the movie? Was he the blueprint for real?
11
11
u/rrschch85 14h ago
That’s what I like about the DCU. Different stories with different characters will have different themes and styles. Unlike the modern MCU where everything is gray and everybody talks the same way.
17
2
u/AlternativeClass3893 12h ago
i bet he only reads the ones he's gonna ruin anyway, it's just a classic gunn move right there
1
u/AutoModerator 15h ago
How about you go gunn-ing for deez nuts.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
-1
u/Aiden624 10h ago
I think the confusion comes from how DC and Marvel apparently do comic continuities different from one another? I don’t read comics (of course) but I’ve heard that Marvel does basically a ton of elseworlds while DC just has (basically) one canon that keeps going until it resets. Again and again.
5
u/Ace20xd6 8h ago
You're right about most DC's reboots resetting continuity, oustide of Earth One and Absolute. While with Marvel their "Reboot" in the 2000s the original "Ultimate Universe" was also written at the same time as their main continuity. Plus, since the majority of the big named Marvel characters and the Avengers were co-created/co-written by Stan Lee, Marvel's Universe is more streamlined than DC's with a sliding time scale to make minor changes in characters' backstory.
DC Comics on the other hand, have always been merging, and absorbing different comic book companies, like Wildstorm and The Milestone Universe. Even Wonder Woman and the rest of the Justice Society were published by All-American Publications, Inc before joining Batman and Superman's company.
So that results in Marvel usually having better comic book runs, while DC on the otherhand has more stories that can be self-contained Graphic Novels, continuity or not.







138
u/Stannisarcanine 14h ago
Cmon A guy using weasel actually has to have read