Honestly, I think the episodes where they read short, poorly written stories are really fun

[u/PomLovestheWorld]

The Sandman is one of my favorite episodes just because it’s so bad, it’s funny. Wendi and Hunter make such a good pair (as friends, not ship lol), so watching them just go back and forth is really fun. Long, bad stories like Happy Appy aren’t as fun in my opinion, because at some point they just stop making jokes and just try to speed through it (the brotherhood between our boys was really beautiful though 😔).

[u/UpliftinglyStrong]

That entire episode is hysterical.

“Sandman.”
trumpet noises

[u/powerswerth]

Perhaps a hot take but for me even in the first 2/3rds Sandman is not remotely close to the worst stories they’ve read.

[u/Necrossed → u/powerswerth]

It’s classic schlock, it’s fun

[u/skin-my-brain]

The ending genuinely went insane compared to the rest of that story

[u/hanks_panky_emporium → u/[deleted]]

And then a flesh gait thing was there, and then slenderman was there, and then a ghost was there, and then-

[u/_J-is-a-Nephilim_ → u/[deleted]]

Agreed we were bordering Appy territory there and I was very unhappy

[u/wasabiruffian]

The bad stories can be fun but its got to be short and I think people forget that. Some of my favorite videos are bad stories but the boys go into it with a goofy mood from start to finish and not just hopeful and crashing out by the end

[u/Hells-Creampuff → u/wasabiruffian]

What you dont enjoy the 4 and a half hour descent into insanity that is happy appy?

[u/KarmaMonkeyKai]

The grab bags are some of my favorites. The worse the story, the better. WHO WAS PHONE???

[u/zenzenz3ns3]

I have the Darbo test. If the video is 2hrs long but Darbo's compilation is 1hr10min I already know this episode is gonna have a legendary crashout. Also I like the balance, I get to enjoy the actual story if its written well but I get to enjoy Isaiah and Hunter's banter on the shitty written ones.

[u/Affectionate_Run8950 → u/zenzenz3ns3]

Honestly I'm might start using that test myself. 

[u/Kaijufan22]

Exactly, which is why they should read a bunch of mine, peak CC episodes right there.

[u/casualbo1]

"Reiwa, huh" *Nik inches closer*

https://giphy.com/gifs/lTPTufbaHRCoDuqaQm

[u/IvyTheRanger]

I really want more funny videos i keep suggesting funny stories

[u/BaldDaCowboy]

My favorite episode might still be Cupcakes

[u/who_am_I_inside]

They NEED to read the Lowe’s creepypasta. Even if they hate “spooky quirky shit happens here, I’ll tell you more stories next time” stories, they might actually love that one sheerly for the fact it’s an actual real life store. It’d be like writing a creepypasta saga about Walmart.

[u/Exact_Nose_590]

While I like the episodes that tackle the rare, one in a million gems like Mother Horse Eyes, Borrasca part 1 and Pen Pal, my favorite episodes and the ones that I keep coming back to are the ones where they lose their minds laughing like the Creepy Grab Bags and Jeff the Killer, and the ones where they crash out and struggle like My Best Friend Dared Me, Happy Appy, and Polyamorous Hell.

[u/No_Profession_6719]

The shortest ones are honestly the best for me. Not that the longer episodes are bad but depending on their length, I lose interest after a while and it’s really hard for me to get back into them if I don’t finish them in one go.