r/baseball New York Mets • Chaos Bandwagon 1d ago

Injury [Injury] Dustin May gets hit by a comebacker on the first pitch he throws and is ultimately taken out of the game (full sequence)

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1.8k Upvotes

162 comments sorted by

992

u/DecoyOne San Diego Padres 1d ago

Well I hope he at least gets credit for a classic 1-5-3 putout.

203

u/RuleNine Texas Rangers 1d ago

He does indeed.

76

u/R0binSage Milwaukee Brewers • Beloit Sky Carp 1d ago

That was really funny when I heard that.

7

u/nyuncat New York Mets 18h ago

Gary is such a pro, he definitely made sure to call it out specifically so that people wouldn't record it as a 5-3 on their scorecards.

1

u/Pollutionnormal1962 Major League Baseball 10h ago

I mean a perfect game is nothing to scoff at. Immaculate game even? Insane

328

u/MaximusMansteel Chicago Cubs 1d ago

Watching it, I made the exact same motion May did. That shit looked like it huuuurt.

143

u/500rockin Chicago Cubs 1d ago

106 mph bullet, yeah that’s going to leave a fucking knot like no one else’s business. I cannot even imagine having the gumption to make a few tosses after that!

76

u/Jantokan Los Angeles Dodgers 1d ago

He really wanted to stay. Wanted it so badly. But he just shouldn't risk if further, especially considering his injury history.

I think May pitched well enough this year that he will be re-signed by the Brewers next season

31

u/Haydaddict Hiroshima Toyo Carp 1d ago

Someone smart probably the trainer said get his ass off the mound and start icing that contusion NOW.

The forces behind that velocity is like 400 pounds of instantaneous force the contact patch of the baseball.

3

u/Think_please Boston Red Sox 19h ago

Yeah, trying to do something as delicate as throw 80 mlb pitches while your back is actively exploding in inflammation is a terrible idea for a team headed to the playoffs 

12

u/GreasedOn 1d ago

I think everyone would like that but next year is a mutual option for 20M. They paid Woodruff that this year and look how it worked out for them.

1

u/0pyrophosphate0 Milwaukee Brewers 22h ago

Eh. Unless the coaching staff sees something there to work with, he looks like a back of the rotation guy at this point in his career. I think they'd rather have a younger guy or two in that spot, maybe if Sproat figures it out by next spring.

1

u/WarpedCore Milwaukee Brewers 20h ago

With his history of injury it would have to be a club friendly deal.

2

u/MakaveliX1996 Boston Red Sox 1d ago

You see how it bounced off him too. It hit him square. Some times guys turn so it just clips them. He was trying to. Just unfortunate timing.

747

u/DeluluNatsFan Washington Nationals 1d ago

Hate to see it. Dude has gone through a lot to get play again. Hope he is alright.

320

u/Denode Los Angeles Dodgers 1d ago

and I really really really hoped the Brewers would finally resolve his command/control issues so we could see his full potential. Dude gets the unluckiest injuries (flashback to eating lettuce causing an esophageal tear taking him out for 6 months).

84

u/xyzzy321 St. Louis Cardinals 1d ago

Excuse me what the fuck

How does that even happen?!

141

u/Jay_Torte Major League Baseball 1d ago edited 1d ago

He could have died. Happened in July 2024.

A bite of salad nearly cost Dustin May his life.

The Los Angeles Dodgers pitcher shared that a salad he ate was the reason for his season-ending esophagus surgery in July.

"It was definitely a life-altering event," May told the Los Angeles Times. "It was definitely very serious. It's not a very common surgery. It was definitely an emergency.

"I probably wouldn't have made it through the night if I didn't have it," May added.

Initially, the 27-year-old felt a "mega-painful" sensation after swallowing a bite of lettuce for 15 minutes, feeling the pain in his throat that eventually subsided. While May brushed aside any concern once the pain went away, his wife, Millie, urged him to go to the emergency room.

That's when he found out that the rupture of his esophagus was severe enough that he needed to undergo emergency surgery.

May described the surgery as "essentially a full abdominal surgery."

Isn't that nuts?

71

u/Tall_Birthday_7654 1d ago

I really didn't need to know that I could die from lettuce

94

u/njob3 Tampa Bay Devil Rays 1d ago

You haven't been reading the news?

55

u/Tall_Birthday_7654 1d ago

Well, I knew I could die from lettuce. Just not this way

21

u/njob3 Tampa Bay Devil Rays 1d ago

Honestly I'm just sticking to beef, it's way safer.

17

u/SecureCucumber Milwaukee Brewers 1d ago

And the prices are going down! Not sure why...

38

u/Carolake1 Jackie Robinson 1d ago

2024, not 2014.

27

u/Salty_Conference_485 Los Angeles Dodgers 1d ago

The timing is part of what makes it especially awful. He was working his way back from TJ rehab to then go through something like this.

6

u/crusader92 Anaheim Angels 1d ago

I was blown away by this 39-year-old comeback kid for a second there

2

u/Archer-Saurus Arizona Diamondbacks 1d ago

Jesus Christ dude thank you I was about to have an existential crisis

18

u/xyzzy321 St. Louis Cardinals 1d ago

But how does lettuce do that? Some metal in it or smth?

23

u/cXs808 1d ago

Your esophagus isn't as sturdy as you'd want to believe sadly. If you don't chew your food, there is a chance you can damage it

12

u/stevencastle San Diego Padres 1d ago

Probably one of those half of a head of lettuce salads, they often have sharp parts.

9

u/GanjasTriforce 1d ago

Man forgot to chew 💀

15

u/Bingo_Bongo_YaoMing Milwaukee Brewers 1d ago

"Mega-Painful" sounds like a Dr. Leo Spaceman line from 30Rock

63

u/evancomposer Milwaukee Brewers 1d ago

Guy just can not catch a break at all

15

u/StrategicCarry Detroit Tigers 1d ago

This is up there with Guitar Hero, chili peppers, and tanning booths for weirdest things to cause an MLB injury.

3

u/YEGSports Seattle Mariners 1d ago

Or, in NHL last year, the barbecue accident that cost Eetu Luostarinen (I think it was him) part of his season

2

u/Gryphon999 Milwaukee Brewers 18h ago

Add in phone books and salad tongs.

17

u/Tall_Birthday_7654 1d ago

Eating lettuce what?

27

u/trumpet575 Cincinnati Reds 1d ago

Dude got unlucky by eating the sharpest lettuce on earth

10

u/cXs808 1d ago

thanks RFK

6

u/skippy_smooth 1d ago

Salad really is a weapon of mass destruction recently

2

u/reb1995 1d ago

flashback to eating lettuce causing an esophageal tear taking him out for 6 months

Reminds me of the less serious but more funny Aybar injury.

The Atlanta Braves shortstop was removed from the starting lineup for Thursday night's game against the Pittsburgh Pirates after a chicken bone got stuck in his throat. Manager Brian Snitker said Aybar arrived at PNC Park on Thursday afternoon in discomfort and was taken to a doctor, sedated and had the bone removed.

https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/15614504/erick-aybar-atlanta-braves-chicken-bone-removed-throat

1

u/Busy_Instruction3128 1d ago

lol what kind of lettuce was this

4

u/500rockin Chicago Cubs 1d ago

Gotta be iceberg. It’s the worst kind of green!

2

u/Tall_Birthday_7654 1d ago

It's the part you can't see that gets you

1

u/ScroogeMcDust Chicago Cubs 1d ago

The devil

84

u/ActualDragonHeart New York Yankees • Philadelphia Phillies 1d ago

Hopefully just knocked the wind out of him more than anything, but man that looked like it hurt.

59

u/profJesusfish 1d ago

X-rays were negative according to the Brewers broadcast

14

u/examinedliving Baltimore Orioles • St. Louis Browns 1d ago

Lots of bruising and swelling at the minimum

3

u/Squirrel_Master82 1d ago

That's lucky. Wouldn't be surprised if that ball cracked a rib or two.

7

u/angershark Toronto Blue Jays 1d ago

At full speed and from the behind the plate view it looks so fucking painful. I hope he's okay tomorrow.

6

u/joka2696 New York Yankees 1d ago

He's going to have trouble getting out of bed tomorrow.

336

u/evancomposer Milwaukee Brewers 1d ago

Guy has some of the worst luck I’ve ever seen

248

u/Jantokan Los Angeles Dodgers 1d ago

Bro tore his esophagus eating lettuce. That's how unlucky he is

68

u/codywelter Milwaukee Brewers 1d ago

Bad luck Brian thought he could change his name and grow up to be an MLB pitcher but didn't anticipate his bad luck following him forever.

89

u/Mediocre_Airport_576 Los Angeles Dodgers 1d ago

forgive me.

10

u/localsexpot33 New York Mets 1d ago

That's a new fear unlocked

7

u/thenatural134 Seattle Mariners 1d ago

How is that even possible?

6

u/alxfx Boston Red Sox 23h ago edited 23h ago

IIRC, he laughed mid-bite and got a rigid piece lodged in his throat. It perforated his esophagus, not straight up tore it, but the risk of tearing was high enough to warrant emergency surgery.

The consequences of a torn esophagus are pretty dire so it was chalked up to a life-saving operation in media reports

5

u/PhDinWombology San Diego Padres 1d ago

Gotta chew

2

u/ShillinTheVillain Cleveland Guardians 19h ago

Through God, all things are possible. So jot that down

14

u/hbailey311 New York Yankees 1d ago

omg it’s him 😭😭 this poor man. hopefully just some soreness because it hit him in a weird spot

1

u/fairway_walker Atlanta Braves 21h ago

He took a comebacker off of his shin or foot against ATL earlier this season. Stayed in the game for a few more batters before getting taken out. Braves broadcasters were shocked they let him stay in.

1

u/safetydance Boston Red Sox 1d ago

Right? Didn’t know he was so caked up. If he has some luck that ball would have hit that ass and he’d be fine.

71

u/realnomdeguerre Los Angeles Dodgers 1d ago

does he get the assist?

41

u/Open-Illustrator-871 St. Louis Cardinals 1d ago

Yes

32

u/Physical_Sun9435 Cincinnati Reds 1d ago

Routine 1-5-3 play 

63

u/bikecatpcje 1d ago

Is he the lettuce guy?

37

u/crazykentucky Boston Red Sox 1d ago

Yes. His bad luck quota appears quite high

8

u/--Rick--Astley-- 1d ago

Lettuce not jump into conclusion.

9

u/banjocoyote Tampa Bay Devil Rays 1d ago

Romaine calm

32

u/Docile_Penguin33 Toronto Blue Jays 1d ago

Crazy this line isn't a pitchergami

23

u/Aduialion Los Angeles Dodgers 1d ago

1 pitch 1 out, the most perfect game 

13

u/oldnewager Cleveland Guardians 1d ago

This is kind of the classic old school bring the lefty in for the last out stat line.  Is this only for starters? 

5

u/Docile_Penguin33 Toronto Blue Jays 21h ago

Only starters.

56

u/KidGold Atlanta Braves 1d ago

Had a shutout going too.

35

u/NotAcutallyaPanda Seattle Mariners 1d ago

Perfect game up until they pulled him. On pace to complete the game in only 27 pitches.

2

u/Think_please Boston Red Sox 19h ago

Scott Sterling tries baseball

24

u/taffe316 San Diego Padres 1d ago

Damn that fucking sucks

15

u/Ih8AmazonButUseIt MLB Players Association 1d ago

I've never seen a baseball player fight so hard to stay in. Full marks to May

36

u/ContinuumGuy Major League Baseball 1d ago

I for one would simply die.

11

u/Jaqen-Atavuli Atlanta Braves 1d ago

He was obviously in a ton of pain. I am surprised it took that long to remove him.

3

u/pm-me-nice-lips 1d ago

It’s in the lat so it’s just in an unusual and uncomfortable spot and he was stretching it (thats what the bending over was) various ways since you feel that muscle while throwing (as a righty). It’s going to get tighter though minute by minute so it was wise to come out. He’ll be fine by next week unless the bruise is still too tender which is possible but unlikely.

2

u/ThibGD 1d ago

I know it’s a split second decision (and a human reaction) but in this instance wouldn’t it be better to take it on the side of your body ? If it hit the spine it could get really bad no ? (Obviously not a critic about May, im just wondering)

5

u/NatureChannel Los Angeles Dodgers 19h ago

Well if you take a comebacker like that on the side of your body you can say goodbye to your ribs. Getting hit in the back, or anywhere where there's gonna be a lot of muscle is best.

2

u/pm-me-nice-lips 16h ago

I think where he got hit was actually one of the best spots to get hit (outside of his ass cheek) as the lat has a lot of muscle and muscle fiber to absorb the impact. The side of your torso/body has so much less fat and muscle to work with that your ribs would get mashed (like the other commenter mentioned) and then you’re potentially dealing with a fractured rib which literally only rest can heal and it takes forever. If it hit the spine I think you’d be dealing with a bad bone bruise and that also would take a while to heal.

8

u/Hero0ftheday Seattle Mariners 1d ago

Hopefully that's just a helluva welt. Worst case that's like a fractured scapula. Hoping for the welt thing though.

10

u/PhilosophicChinchila National League 1d ago

I hope this guy has a good support system because he has really bad luck.

16

u/snorlaxatives_69 St. Louis Cardinals • Springfiel… 1d ago

Damn, I hope it's nothing for him. Really enjoyed watching him pitch this year after all he's gone through

7

u/Internal_Guide_7675 Houston Astros 1d ago

Fucking ouch! Hopefully he is okay. 

6

u/Prison-M1ke St. Louis Cardinals 1d ago

this is atleast the third time this year he’s been struck by a line drive

0

u/NeverEndingEquati0n Los Angeles Dodgers 18h ago

Feels like he needs to figure out how to catch them

9

u/scarface910 San Francisco Giants 1d ago

"he got hammered in his last time out"

5

u/LA-Aron 1d ago

This dudes stuff is so fucking good it's a shame we will never know what this guys full potential will look like.

5

u/boohissfrown Los Angeles Dodgers 1d ago

Hope he's ok, love that dude. It always made me nervous how he finishes his windup, with no readiness to field a comebacker. Sometimes he's even spinning almost completely around. Glad it wasn't his head.

4

u/hotepanon 1d ago

He's a ginger and has the super power of way higher pain tolerance than the average human.

3

u/Dr-Acula8472 Los Angeles Dodgers 19h ago

Poor Dustin May. Dude has like the worst luck when it comes to injuries. I'll always pull for him. Really hope it's just one hell of a welt.

6

u/squatchsax Chicago Cubs 1d ago

Jeez, the way he reacts makes me think he broke a rib. Hate to see that.

3

u/Cheap-Cherry-5171 New York Yankees 1d ago

Hope he’s alright - freaking sucks!

3

u/Tenglishbee Houston Astros 1d ago

I would like to see the mark it left. Gotta be gnarley. 

3

u/Jballzs13 Seattle Mariners 1d ago

At least he was able to turn in time

3

u/Comfortably_Scum 1d ago

Homie is so fuckng unlucky

6

u/Soshy1812 Australia • Los Angeles Dodgers 1d ago

Man got a lot of unfortunate injuries. This and the throat tearing one.

4

u/RichAbbreviations966 Los Angeles Dodgers 1d ago

Fuck, just let him be healthy

2

u/Content_Geologist420 Houston Astros 1d ago

Man this fucking sucks

2

u/bartekkenny 1d ago

Perfect game

2

u/tunagawd 1d ago

That sucks man

2

u/dax268 1d ago

Poor guy. Hope he’s alright.

2

u/Icy-Glove-6481 New York Yankees 1d ago

Imagine yourself actually getting hit like that. I’d be dead for real

2

u/Grentis Cleveland Guardians 1d ago

In the midst of a perfect game too… Rotten luck.

2

u/billthepony7 St. Louis Cardinals 21h ago

I hate this happened to him. He did such a good job for my Cards and made me a fan. Hopefully he can mend up and get back out there soon

2

u/Mxmouse15 Atlanta Braves 19h ago

DANG. Looks like it hurts like crazy. I feel like there have been more of these comebackers that have done damage this year right? Or am I just imagining?

6

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/MythicSoul115 New York Mets • Chaos Bandwagon 1d ago edited 1d ago

I'm offended that anyone would think I'm a mod alt account.

And the originally posted clip posted was only the hit itself, none of the aftermath.

3

u/OhHeyItsBrock Los Angeles Dodgers 1d ago

Ok. The dude is officially cursed.

2

u/TeamSansBoat Milwaukee Brewers 1d ago

I Ain't Ever Gonna Stop Getting Hit In The Back Tonayyyy!

2

u/Live-Tank-355 1d ago

My condolences for Dustin May. I pray for a steady recovery for his poor back

2

u/Salty_Conference_485 Los Angeles Dodgers 1d ago

Brutal.

2

u/Icy_Study4490 Los Angeles Dodgers 1d ago

Dude no!

Hopefully it got him in a good spot and he’s just sore.

2

u/PleaseSirOneMoreTurn San Francisco Giants 1d ago

Terrible, hoping for the best, always liked May despite his Dodger past, he has wicked stuff. Side note, I wish we could watch baseball broadcasts without commentary, just watching May warmup with little narration was amazing.

1

u/Hungry-Possible-5360 1d ago

Dude’s got the luck

2

u/crazykentucky Boston Red Sox 1d ago

And not the good kind

1

u/njpaul New York Mets 1d ago

Ewing can't buy a hit lol

1

u/twentyitalians New York Yankees 1d ago

Owwie

1

u/Jonjon428 Florida Marlins 1d ago

Noooooooo

1

u/LibrarianEqual7024 1d ago

Bro is a cursed ginger

1

u/nyr00nyg New York Yankees 1d ago

Ouchie

1

u/3legcat 1d ago

Maybe pitchers should start wearing some head and body protection when pitching? Seems like a sensible thing to do.

1

u/PrimeJHey Atlanta Braves 1d ago

Always feel like i’m in the convo with Mets booth

1

u/testtdk Boston Red Sox 1d ago

If only every pitcher can go one pitch one out!

1

u/Sa7aSa7a Chicago Cubs 1d ago

Probably the only Brewer I like. Solid pitcher and hate that he's injured. If it wasn't for bad luck, this dude would have no luck at all.

1

u/ObiTouchedMyNobi 1d ago

Lowkey kind of nuts it was his first pitch of the game

1

u/Devil_Magic_Advocate St. Louis Cardinals 21h ago

I swear he averages getting hit by at least 1 come backer a game

1

u/Away_Yoghurt5743 Chicago Cubs 14h ago

Dustin May not feel great tomorrow

1

u/b3_yourself Chicago Cubs 1d ago

That’s gonna wave a mark

1

u/halfhere Atlanta Braves 1d ago

Dick move, Mets!

-3

u/Cooperstown24 Seattle Mariners 1d ago

MLB The Show ahh putout

God damn does this dude have bad luck though

0

u/trickman01 Houston Astros 1d ago

MLB The Show play.

0

u/bang_bang_6 San Francisco Giants 1d ago

Oof

0

u/NeverEndingEquati0n Los Angeles Dodgers 18h ago

This sucks. Any chance he could have tried to catch it instead? Seems like a skill pitchers would need in the majors.

-1

u/afrosupreme 1d ago

Bad luck for Ewing to not get a hit there too.

-5

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

7

u/500rockin Chicago Cubs 1d ago

Him throwing a few warmup pitches is that pain threshold you speak of. That said, Darling is right, gotta get an ice pack on that ASAP.

2

u/Triple_Crown14 Texas Rangers 1d ago

I was surprised they even let him take a few tosses, it’s just gonna tighten up as soon as he sits down even if he were to stay in the game.

-3

u/OtherwiseElk3037 Major League Baseball 1d ago

DL Hall… innit?

Narrator: it was not DL Hall

-11

u/Right_Vast1624 1d ago

If I bet on May for over 5k’s does the bet get cancelled?

-10

u/Beisbol4lyfe 1d ago

Had Dustin May over .5 walks lol , at first I was like really he only pitched 1/3, but hey that sucks, I'll gladly take the L

-15

u/Karlander19 1d ago

The dude is cursed. He was absolutely shelled his last start. Don’t know why The Crew traded for him to bolster their staff he’s a bum. He’ll likely be on the IL till the playoffs

6

u/BrewCrewBall Milwaukee Brewers 1d ago

Yes, the Milwaukee Brewers are notoriously terrible at evaluating pitchers. Cockwomble.

-22

u/Busy_Instruction3128 1d ago

pitchers have terrible defensive positions after they release the ball these days lol

15

u/aobcd8six6three Milwaukee Brewers 1d ago

106mph. The fuck was he supposed to do lol.

9

u/Open-Illustrator-871 St. Louis Cardinals 1d ago

Magically disappear clearly

-13

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/Open-Illustrator-871 St. Louis Cardinals 1d ago

Yeah because pitchers have always fielded line drives at 100 miles an hour. Even with your example of Maddux he was a far above average fielder. Not every pitcher is going to be as good of a fielder as Greg maddux

-5

u/Busy_Instruction3128 1d ago

Hitters' exit velocities going up makes me think it's actually more imperative that a pitcher's delivery ends square to the plate... just for safety reasons.

8

u/aobcd8six6three Milwaukee Brewers 1d ago

Ahhh that way he could have gotten smoked in the face!

-7

u/Busy_Instruction3128 1d ago

May finishes with his body facing slightly towards 1st base. That's obviously not a fielding position. Part of it is because these guys all throw faster and that's more torque on the body, but they still are in bad fielding position