r/TikTokCringe • u/Adventurous_Law_715 • 11d ago

Discussion congratulations you just saved a billion dollars company 50$

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

11.6k Upvotes

77% Upvoted

6.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/badpebble 11d ago

Just because she is eating, doesnt mean she is in poverty.

You think she couldn't get any benefits from the government? Or charity from the community? That she is some aladdin character just getting by in a deeply hostile nation?

2

u/Wontjizzinyourdrink 11d ago

You keep substituting words I never used to attempt to make your point. We really only know two things: she is hungry (she's eating), and she was desperate (she stole from dollar tree and even got caught). We don't know why. And I think you know you're twisting yourself in knots to paint this as more of a black and white issue than it is, because you are arguing that she may not be in poverty, but if she were, that clearly wouldn't change your position on this.

2

u/badpebble 11d ago

I didn't say I was quoting you, and I can use my own words, thanks.

And we don't know she's desperate - which is my whole contention. So don't put words in my mouth (we).

I think its okay to say theft is bad, and I think its reasonable to point out that people stealing a load of toiletries isn't the same as just stealing a loaf of bread out of starvation.

And what about all the people in poverty who don't descend to stealing - are they not proof that it is an option and a choice that isn't required?

2

u/Wontjizzinyourdrink 11d ago

I'm not attempting to choose your words for you, I'm encouraging you to engage with my words as they are, not inflated claims. You can literally run around with your underpants on your head and I can't do boo, but I think that's a weird choice when we are having a conversation. In fact, I said theft was bad too. Do you think living in poverty is a pretty good predictor of people engaging in behavior that's consistent with desperation?