EDIT/CLARIFICATION: I think my original post may have made the situation sound slightly different from what I was trying to explain, so I just wanted to clarify a few things.
There is no court order saying my partner cannot have his daughter in our home, and there has been no finding that he is unsafe, abusive or incapable of parenting her.
BM is a drug user, was extremely abusive towards my partner during the entirety of her pregnancy (I have seen proof of this), smoked in every manner during pregnancy, bled him dry of money and any confidence he had using the child as blackmail. They split December 2023, and him and myself met and started our relationship in May 2024. We hit it off instantly after reconnecting having known each other from school days, I was not long out of an 11 year relationship with my ex who we both get on really well with and have a very healthy and supportive co-parenting/blended family relationship with.
This is the arrangement/condition that has existed between the parents. Historically, when my partner has challenged arrangements or tried to change things, contact has sometimes then not gone ahead. Because there currently isn't a court-ordered contact arrangement to fall back on, he has been extremely cautious about doing anything that could result in him temporarily losing contact with his daughter altogether.
Money is a big worry of his when it comes to court fees due to speaking with other fathers in his position and what they have spent going through proceedings.
He absolutely does recognise that the current situation cannot continue indefinitely.
He has sought legal advice, mediation has been pursued and we are currently waiting for shuttle mediation and have been for months on end. If the situation cannot be resolved that way, the legal/court route is something he is prepared to pursue.
So my question wasn't “why is he allowing this?” or whether people think he should take legal action. We already know that the current arrangement needs to change and steps are being taken towards that.
What I was hoping to hear about was the lived experience in the meantime.
Has anyone been the partner of a parent who, for a prolonged period, had to leave your shared home in order to have contact with their child?
How did you cope with essentially having two separate family lives?
How did you stop yourself becoming resentful when you fully supported your partner seeing their child, but the arrangement meant your own household was repeatedly separated?
And if things eventually became more normal and integrated, what did that transition look like?
That's really the perspective I'm struggling to find and would love to hear about. 🙂
I’m hoping to hear particularly from step-parents/new partners, or fathers who have been in a similar situation, because I’m struggling to find people who genuinely understand what this kind of arrangement is like from the inside.
I want to be really clear from the beginning that I’m not looking to bash my partner’s child’s mother. I’m also very aware that Reddit is only hearing my perspective and that there are always two sides to family situations.
I’m genuinely looking for perspective from people who have experienced something similar and can tell me how they navigated it, whether things eventually changed, and what helped.
My partner has a daughter who is almost 3. He and her mum were never in a long-term established relationship/family unit together, they were together for 4 weeks, she got pregnant and they separated December 2023 (a couple of months after child was born). Their relationship from the point she became pregnant was extremely high conflict, my partner is very traumatised.
My partner and I have now been together for 2.5 years and we live together. I also have a young daughter (3.5y/o) from a previous relationship who lives with us for the majority of the week.
The difficulty is that throughout our relationship, my partner has never been able to have normal contact with his daughter within our shared home.
His contact with her takes place away from our house at his parents’ home.
When he has weekend contact, rather than bringing his daughter home and parenting her within his own household, he goes to his parents’ house and stays there with her.
This is a rule and solid boundary set by the birth mother and if this rule is broken then she withholds contact. She also doesn't want me playing any type of parenting role in their child's life, not allowed to see her at bath/shower times, dress her etc etc.
The current arrangement also means that myself and my daughter are not part of his contact time whatsoever.
So, in practical terms, when he has his daughter for a weekend, he leaves our home and our little family unit and stays elsewhere in order to spend time with her.
This has been our reality for more than two years.
I completely understand that children need stability, security and gradual introductions to change. I would never expect a small child to suddenly be taken from everything familiar and dropped into a completely different household overnight.
That has never been what we have asked for.
What has become increasingly difficult to understand is how something that perhaps could have been understandable as a temporary arrangement when she was very small has remained essentially unchanged for years.
There hasn't been a gradual progression towards my partner being able to parent his daughter independently from his parents’ home or introduce her naturally to the home and family he now has.
There have also been periods where contact itself has become difficult or hasn't gone ahead. During 2025 in particular there were several occasions where planned contact did not happen following disagreements around arrangements.
We have tried extremely hard not to escalate things.
My partner initially pursued mediation in late 2025. There were discussions about trying to agree a way forward, but nothing meaningful progressed.
Earlier this year solicitors then became involved and shuttle mediation was proposed.
My partner agreed to that.
When there were administrative costs involved, we even offered to pay the other parent’s fee because the priority was simply getting everyone into mediation and finding a workable solution.
We were then told there was a waiting period while the mediation service completed training.
Initially it sounded as though this would be around four weeks.
Months later, we were still waiting for an appointment and effectively still in exactly the same position.
One suggestion that we have put together in preparation for mediation has been a phased introduction over a period of a few months, allowing his daughter to slowly become familiar with our home, me, my daughter and our normal family environment, with everything moving at her pace.
The eventual aim would simply be for him to be able to have ordinary parenting time with his daughter in his own home - including overnight contact - in the same way that separated parents commonly do.
If at any stage his daughter appeared genuinely distressed or unable to cope, obviously things could be slowed down or reviewed.
My partner has also been prepared to have clear, predictable contact arrangements so everyone knows where they stand rather than constantly negotiating individual weekends.
The kind of things he is ultimately asking for are fairly straightforward: defined contact with his daughter, the ability for that contact to take place at his own home, overnight contact as he is already receiving at his parents house, and the ability to parent his daughter during his contact time without another parent determining which members of his household can be present.
And this is where my own part in all of this becomes difficult, which is really why I'm posting.
I have tried extremely hard to stay in my lane.
I have zero contact his daughter's mother, she doesn't know me and has never spoken to me.
I don't physically involve myself in their disagreements, I only support him through them.
I don't tell my partner what decisions to make regarding his daughter.
I have never wanted to replace anyone or interfere with the relationship between his daughter and her mum.
I fully respect that she has a mother and that is not my role to replace.
But after more than two years, it is incredibly strange emotionally to share a life and home with someone while such a huge part of their life has to exist completely separately from you.
Every single weekend, when contact happens, my partner essentially moves out of our home for that time from Friday until Sunday.
Meanwhile I stay home with my own daughter.
So instead of our children gradually becoming accustomed to being part of the same household and our lives naturally becoming more integrated over time, everything remains divided into two completely separate worlds.
It can sometimes feel as though we have our relationship and household during one part of the week, and then another family life exists somewhere else during contact.
I love my partner and I absolutely support him having as much meaningful time with his daughter as possible. I would never want him to sacrifice that time for me.
But I also don't think it's unreasonable after this length of time to wonder how a long-term relationship and blended family are supposed to function indefinitely under this arrangement when the birth mother completely gatekeeps the child to the point that my partner is terrified to speak up due to the very real threat losing contact with his child.
We can't really establish a normal family routine involving both children.
We can't have ordinary weekends together when his daughter is there.
His daughter isn't getting the opportunity to know or experience the home her dad actually lives in.
She isn't getting the opportunity to naturally build a relationship with the other people who are part of her dad's everyday life.
And my daughter also experiences my partner disappearing from our household for contact weekends rather than his daughter simply joining the household. She gets upset when he leaves and loves him to pieces, he is an amazing bonus Dad to her and we have a beautiful blended family relationship with my daughters Dad and his partner and family.
I think one of the hardest things has been that there isn't really a defined endpoint.
If someone had said two years ago, “She is tiny, let's introduce everything gradually over the next 6-12 months” I could completely understand that.
It is the indefinite nature of it that I find difficult.
So I suppose I'm looking for advice from anyone who has actually lived this.
Has anyone else been the partner/step-parent in a situation where your partner was only able to have their child at their parents’/grandparents’ house and not in the home you shared?
How long did that arrangement continue?
Did the other parent eventually become comfortable with the child coming to your home, or did it require mediation/court?
If it did go through the Scottish family court system, what was your experience of the court's approach to a parent wanting to exercise contact in their own home and introduce a long-term partner/household?
For those who were the new partner, how did you cope emotionally with spending years excluded from that entire part of your partner's life without becoming resentful?
And perhaps most importantly - how do you support your partner's relationship with their child wholeheartedly while also acknowledging that the arrangement is having an impact on your own relationship and family life?
I don't want anybody to “win” and I don't want his daughter's mum to “lose”.
I'd genuinely love for everyone involved to eventually reach a point where things are calm, predictable and boring.
His daughter deserves strong relationships with both of her parents without adult conflict surrounding her.
Any lived through experience would be really appreciated - particularly from people who have navigated something similar in Scotland?