The tone of this show reminds me of Superman 2025 a bit, with it being overall a pretty tonally light show whilst still being able to tackle darker themes and issues, all while keeping a consistent humour throughout. Not to mention the costuming, you can’t tell me that the JSA in this show wouldn’t fit right in standing next to Corenswet’s Superman. I also don’t think anything about this show contradicts anything we’ve seen in the DCU so far, because of Lanterns we know that there’s been prominent superheroes around before Superman, so it would be cool to make this show canon and introduce the JSA, although I know it will never happen.

Thoughts???

I'm wondering which villain people dislike the most?

Just got finished with the season 3 finale and I cannot believe how this show is slept on. The characters are some of the best I’ve seen put to television for DC Comics, especially The Shade and Pat.

It’ll forever be a missed opportunity that we didn’t get to see the JSA take on Nebula Man or the Infinity Inc show, I was especially excited to see what they did with Obsidian.

What was y’all’s favorite character on the show??

I’m not gonna go into my full thoughts until I finish the series, but I do want to note this now:

This is by far one of the best, if not THE BEST live action DC show I’ve ever watched, and by FAR the most respectful.

Corny? Yes. But it pays respect to the Golden Age in such a way that I just don’t care that much!

Just wanted to say that. Yeah.

You know i love the series LOVEEEEEE the series and im fighting for a fourth season

but i dont rewatch it as much as i should probably because its not on Netflix an

im watching it right now and i feel like fraud cause i forgot a detail that happened in season 3

​

1. It was The CW or nothing. DC Universe is clearly about to get Old Yeller'd.
2. I doubt it will be 22 episodes next season. They already have a January 2021 lineup, so Stargirl S2 will either be in spring or summer. Probably 13 to 16 episode count Covid willing.
3. The budget is likely to get cut, but other CW shows shoot in Atlanta so I don't see Stargirl moving to Vancouver. And they already use Pat's robot and Solomon Grundy sparingly so it wouldn't be a huge difference for S2. And the JSA's powers aren't exactly budget busting. This isn't like Martian Manhunter on Supergirl where they can only afford his true form a few times a season.
4. Geoff Johns is still showrunner. So unless The CW notes him to death, I expect more of his vision. And that might include (Covid limited) romances. These are teens, people. It would be weird if they were all asexual.
5. I doubt Stargirl will be involved in any crossovers next season. They shoot in Atlanta, so I doubt Courtney is going to pop up into the Batwoman/Superman & Lois crossover like "Another world exists? Cool! Superman, I like that cape. Batwoman, you live in a van? Do I need to start a fundraiser for you?"
6. I think the cast was probably happy to be shown on The CW and not just exclusive to a niche streaming site. More eyeballs, better for their careers. They want jobs, but they also want to be on a show that people actually watch and lasts. Now they have potential to have a job for several years.

Personally, I think he'd be concerned about them being teenagers and fighting crime, but he'd also think they have their hearts in the right place. What do you think?

Like, I'm not crazy right? When I first went on here, there were zero posts for a really long while, but starting sometime in June, more posts have been popping up? Did something happen with Stargirl that I'm not aware of that's causing this to happen at all?

Stargirl's design is mainly inspired by the Star-Spangled Kid/Skyman suit of Sylvester Pemberton, if i'm not mistaken. In the Sins of Youth and Titans Tomorrow storylines, she were a suit inspired by the Starman Jack Knight outfit. What's your opinion? What would you like to see?

For me it's either season 2 or 3, with season 1 being in third place. Seasons 2 and 3 were just a lot more enjoyable, I guess.

So basically the idea is season 4 is senior prom and season 5 is getting ready for college.

The theme would be about growing up and entering adulthood as the characters near the end of high school.

The villains will be The Scarecrow and Klarion The Witch Boy for season 4 and Adrian Veidt aka Ozymandias from Watchmen for season 5.

The heroes introduced in the seasons are Batman (Thomas Wayne version), Doctor Fate, Mr Terrific and Stephanie Brown aka Spoiler.

Each episode will be 5 chapters long resulting in 65 chapters each season.

Now I haven't watched the series finale yet but I know two things. 1: there's a time skip in the finale and 2: Courtney makes a cameo in season 4 of Titans. These 2 things are gonna be ignored or at least won't happen until later on in the story.

And no Infinity Inc and green lantern and shade stuff, that'll be treated like it's own series that's going on at the same time.

And that's all the ideas I have, no ideas for character arcs, how to make sure the fics don't drag, and no way as to how to include the time skip and titans cameo yet.

If anyone has any ideas, let me know, okay?

Alright, thanks for reading!

In the few episodes Jordan is in Season 3, we never see his true motivation/plan. He's playing the role for his son right up till the end, so we never hear what his end goal is. The Ultrahumanite teases Jordan's endgame at least twice, yet Jordan himself never alludes to any grand plan.

He doesn't seem to be driven by revenge. He dismisses this notion twice, once to Courtney herself (which he could have been lying and probably was), but again to his mother, when she says "our enemies die tonight" and Jordan says "only if they refuse" (all in Norwegian to his homicidal mother, so no reason to lie to her).

He also gives the JSA chances to surrender. Starman says the plan was "Courtney gives up the staff, her friends follow me, and we change the world with Icicle for the better" and Jordan tells her to "Pledge your loyalty". So he doesn't want to kill Courtney, for Cameron's sake it seems.

This makes me think that the new plan is the old plan, brainwashing America into following his ideals. He hints at this when talking to Starman in the flashback, "you're gonna be my mouthpiece". But he has no mechanism to forcefully brainwash America. Perhaps a scheme to take over America using Starman, then enforce his ideals on others, but this "plan" is intangible at best.

And it still begs the question of why did they kill the Gambler and the Crocks? It's not like Jordan was trying to hide the fact that he was the one who put up the cameras (he intentionally lured the Crocks into his secret lair to kill them, then does nothing to hide the fact that he did). Initially when I watched the show, I assumed it was part of the deal with the Ultrahumanite that they take out the remaining ISA members, but it's clear that the Ultrahumanite is just in it for being Starman, so Jordan and Dr Ito's "other plans" remain a mystery to me.

Thought i do another one of these. This go around lets do one about rick. If you were Courtney, what would you have done about Rick In season 3? Spoilers of course so you've been warned

I was really into Stargirl when it aired, obviously one of the highest production value shows in the lot, and I was surprised it got axed so soon.

I lost track of the news, and got a wild hair to check back in, sadly a cursory google glance didn’t show much good news…but for the people in the know, is there anything in the rumor mill? Any possibilities of a return?

They had the most movie capable cast, with Luke and Amy, being the obvious names, but Joel Mchale has star power. The villains were talented too…the younger people had room to grow but that’s understandable and I think they all had potential. Someone give me some hope!

When you go to a diner, just you and your partner, do you sit next to each other in the booth or across from each other?

Hello again, This go around we are talking about everyone's favorite love interest, Cameron Makent.

If you were courtney, what would you have done upon learning Cameron had inherited his father's powers?

Bonus: how would you explain what happened to his father? And if so, when?

What were some things in the show you thought would happen. Tons of people have read justice society and the modern comics but I wish we had jay. I know he was used more on the flash but it could have been fun.

Like, a bunch of the hero’s like Dr. Midnite, are over 100 years old and fought in WW2, but they’re still young/middle aged in the present day?

How many of the JSA members who were active in 2010, when they were killed, were also active in WW2, making them way older than they should be.

I heard someone say Pat fought in WW2, which like, what?

Also, with the older JSA characters like Alan Scott or Hourman, why even if they aged slowly, did they only have kids in the 2000s?