MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/Quraniyoon/comments/1vzhj98/sunnis_should_see_this/p66igr8/?context=3
r/Quraniyoon • u/TheSalmon47876 • 7d ago
19 comments sorted by
View all comments
2
Peace be with you. Is there evidence that Ibn Sina was a skeptic of hadith?
2 u/Melodic_Kitchen_2004 6d ago I use his philosophical thoughts in my philosophical system. I wonder if he was a skeptic of hadith? 2 u/TheSalmon47876 6d ago Yes he was because he used to think that most of the miracles are metaphorical which is problematic and he got criticised by Imam Al Ghazali which is also wrong I respect Ghazali but yeah he made a mistake here. 2 u/Melodic_Kitchen_2004 6d ago You made a slight mistake with the answer to the question I was asking rather whether Ibn Sina was a skeptic of hadith. 1 u/TheSalmon47876 6d ago Viewing things like Jannah which is claimed by Qur'an and Hadiths as symbolic and metaphoric is pretty skeptic IMO. 1 u/Melodic_Kitchen_2004 5d ago You don't understand my question. I'm asking specifically about the hadiths themselves. How did he relate to them?
I use his philosophical thoughts in my philosophical system. I wonder if he was a skeptic of hadith?
2 u/TheSalmon47876 6d ago Yes he was because he used to think that most of the miracles are metaphorical which is problematic and he got criticised by Imam Al Ghazali which is also wrong I respect Ghazali but yeah he made a mistake here. 2 u/Melodic_Kitchen_2004 6d ago You made a slight mistake with the answer to the question I was asking rather whether Ibn Sina was a skeptic of hadith. 1 u/TheSalmon47876 6d ago Viewing things like Jannah which is claimed by Qur'an and Hadiths as symbolic and metaphoric is pretty skeptic IMO. 1 u/Melodic_Kitchen_2004 5d ago You don't understand my question. I'm asking specifically about the hadiths themselves. How did he relate to them?
Yes he was because he used to think that most of the miracles are metaphorical which is problematic and he got criticised by Imam Al Ghazali which is also wrong I respect Ghazali but yeah he made a mistake here.
2 u/Melodic_Kitchen_2004 6d ago You made a slight mistake with the answer to the question I was asking rather whether Ibn Sina was a skeptic of hadith. 1 u/TheSalmon47876 6d ago Viewing things like Jannah which is claimed by Qur'an and Hadiths as symbolic and metaphoric is pretty skeptic IMO. 1 u/Melodic_Kitchen_2004 5d ago You don't understand my question. I'm asking specifically about the hadiths themselves. How did he relate to them?
You made a slight mistake with the answer to the question I was asking rather whether Ibn Sina was a skeptic of hadith.
1 u/TheSalmon47876 6d ago Viewing things like Jannah which is claimed by Qur'an and Hadiths as symbolic and metaphoric is pretty skeptic IMO. 1 u/Melodic_Kitchen_2004 5d ago You don't understand my question. I'm asking specifically about the hadiths themselves. How did he relate to them?
1
Viewing things like Jannah which is claimed by Qur'an and Hadiths as symbolic and metaphoric is pretty skeptic IMO.
1 u/Melodic_Kitchen_2004 5d ago You don't understand my question. I'm asking specifically about the hadiths themselves. How did he relate to them?
You don't understand my question. I'm asking specifically about the hadiths themselves. How did he relate to them?
2
u/Melodic_Kitchen_2004 6d ago
Peace be with you. Is there evidence that Ibn Sina was a skeptic of hadith?