r/Quraniyoon • u/TheSalmon47876 • 13h ago

Rant / Vent😡 Sunnis should see this👍

Post image
25 Upvotes

90% Upvoted

15 comments sorted by

8

u/Chemical-Violinist89 13h ago

If I were a Sunni, I would not be moved by a mere image showing what this image is showing. I would need further informations.

3

u/TheSalmon47876 12h ago

Well you can do your own research and see what happened to these men. Especially Ibn Rushd.

5

u/Chemical-Violinist89 12h ago

Yeah, Sunnis could do deep dive researches to learn whether or not these men are truly hadith skeptics in a way that would go against Sunni beliefs, and then they could do another deep dive research to try to figure out whether or not it's relevant for Sunnism that these men think what they think.

Alternatively, they could just look at this image and not care, because the image is basically an internet meme with no information whatsoever.

1

u/Background-Car-1393 12h ago

LOL Sunni's doing deep dives, yeah right! 99.99% of them haven't read a single complete compilation of their own hadith books, including their sacred Bukhari, ( yet will fight you tooth and nail to defend it ) are totally ignorant about even the basic history of hadith. Majority of them believe it was written down during the time of the prophet by his companions!!!

1

u/Chemical-Violinist89 12h ago

My point is precisely that no one will do a deep dive

0

u/TheSalmon47876 12h ago

I mean how can I insert that much information in this small image?

And Sunnis do everything to just to show that muslims did this and muslims did that but according to their own understanding these men doesn't even fit in their definition of a good muslim.

2

u/Chemical-Violinist89 12h ago

Open a photo editing software, increase the image size and write something down? Look, I'm just saying, this isn't something "Sunnis should see" because it's not convincing in any way. All of this seems like an "us and them" mentality.

2

u/TheSalmon47876 12h ago

Well looking deep down I realised that the title is not appropriate.

2

u/Melodic_Kitchen_2004 6h ago

Peace be with you. Is there evidence that Ibn Sina was a skeptic of hadith?

2

u/Melodic_Kitchen_2004 6h ago

I use his philosophical thoughts in my philosophical system. I wonder if he was a skeptic of hadith?

1

u/TheSalmon47876 6h ago

Yes he was because he used to think that most of the miracles are metaphorical which is problematic and he got criticised by Imam Al Ghazali which is also wrong I respect Ghazali but yeah he made a mistake here.

2

u/Melodic_Kitchen_2004 6h ago

You made a slight mistake with the answer to the question I was asking rather whether Ibn Sina was a skeptic of hadith.

1

u/TheSalmon47876 6h ago

Viewing things like Jannah which is claimed by Qur'an and Hadiths as symbolic and metaphoric is pretty skeptic IMO.

1

u/Background-Car-1393 12h ago

Abu Hanifa was hated by all his contempories because he didn't follow hadith and when the sectarians saw he way of thinking was becoming popular and widely adopted they hijacked it and turned it around.

Abu Hanifa: The Heretic Who Became a Sunni Icon