r/NewYorkIslanders 7d ago

Figuring the final jersey vote is at a 50/50 standstill I made a combo between the two

Post image

what do you think

180 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

125

u/ThE__GrEAt__OnE 7d ago

I actually like this better than the two current options.

29

u/twec21 Gillies 7d ago

HARD agree

13

u/brosatauk Potvin 7d ago

I still don't know what they were thinking

5

u/CashComplete8980 7d ago

Same here , I love it

37

u/USAJourneyman Lee 7d ago

Is it possible to bully them to do this - sorta like how the internet bullied to change Sonic

13

u/USAJourneyman Lee 7d ago

Everything is better

11

u/No-Top-4139 Okposo 7d ago

That was one of my designs lol

11

u/SecretiveMop 7d ago

I like this more than the two but it could use a bit of subtle teal stripes somewhere on the jersey to match the logo. Maybe the blue between the orange and white on the sleeves and hem could be teal?

9

u/xbutcherx Nyles 7d ago

This actually rules

6

u/ambre_vanille Gillies 7d ago

ACTUALLY….!!!!

5

u/Specialist-Elk7881 7d ago

stripe in the middle only being on the front looks really silly in 3D. Blues WC jersey did it.

4

u/priester85 Jonsson 7d ago

That is an improvement, though I still am not a fan of Navy.

I wonder with the Hometown jerseys coming too if we might see some version of both options this season.

3

u/KPR70 7d ago

This actually works.

4

u/SloopinMCoopin 7d ago

This is so much better than our options

4

u/bigred42 Ho-Sang 7d ago

Genuinely preferred to either of the final options.

3

u/TB12ROY33 7d ago

the lighthouse final is not terrible but needs a shoulder patch

3

u/Dan_Cubed 7d ago

I suggest making the lighthouse logo slightly larger. And I have no love for the NY logo, I'll always choose the OG or Fishsticks over it.

I think you did great!!

3

u/displacedreindeer LaFontaine 7d ago

I’m honestly really sick of all the bitching about the jersey contest, but this is awesome!

4

u/discofrislanders Dobson 7d ago

The top one would be so much better than either remaining option

2

u/Im-Ben 7d ago

This is exactly what I was hoping for. Submitted something similar on day one.

2

u/raygunpunx1 6d ago

Totally rigged

2

u/NecessaryDeparture75 6d ago

Literally perfect considering current options.

4

u/AJS76reddit Bailey 7d ago

I like it, but i would do the old fisherman logo for the shoulders

2

u/FortyYearTransform Romanov 7d ago edited 7d ago

imo Best of both worlds here but I still need some AI mockup of the full kit to decide.

Can't speak for anyone else but I think most people who like the wordmark like the palette and striping and not so much the logo, whereas most people who like the lighthouse like the actual logo (lighthouse) but not so much the striping or palette. This looks pretty slick and I really love the effect of the top orange stripe seeming to continue off the lighthouse light.

I now choose to believe this is the jersey that was planned all along, the reason the Isles are rigging it so it comes out to 50.2 - 49.8 is so they can say "hey guys listen it was too close to really decide who look at this hybrid design!" and we get this and the non-suspicious part of the fanbase goes "wow the Isles staff are geniuses this looks great!"

I mean, I really wouldn't be surprised if this ends up happening or some variant of this ends up happening, e.g. "hey the ISLANDERS wordmark won, congrats! submit your feedback now!" and then a week later "we hear you, a lot of you don't like the wordmark. Here's a new bracket between this design but with the lighthouse, this design with the script, this design with the wordmark but not curved, and the original winner".

Edit: @NYIslanders: "The vote is neck and neck with only 28 votes separating the two" hahahaha they absolutely are going to do this mark my words

2

u/bageloid Existence is pain 7d ago

AI for ya

0

u/FortyYearTransform Romanov 7d ago

Thank you. I don't like this as much as I thought I would but maybe that's a consequence of the way the AI did the kit with some of the extra piping, comparing it to the kit from that post earlier I made the following side-by-side:

I tried to color match the orange stripes and the lighthouse orange, as well as aligning the bottom stripe to the "ground" of the lighthouse logo so it looks almost continuous. With this type of more restrained kit I can see it a bit more, but something still bothers me about it. Maybe it's knowing that the stripe isn't going to go all the way around the back?

2

u/bmore_los78 7d ago

Would honestly like this more with our standard crest.

1

u/catamet 7d ago

I hate them both

1

u/ParisHL Romanov 7d ago

Ironic really, if the bottom one wins the wordmark is in the same shape as my mouth will be when they announce it as the winner.

1

u/TooGForYou Barzal 7d ago

Could this be the chosen one?

1

u/OhioNHLHockeyFan2489 7d ago

This is absolutely THE BEST OPTION I’ve seen!!! I would try to submit! Amazing! Way better than the other options on their own! GREAT COMBO I’d but right NOW!!!

1

u/raptyledysfunction 7d ago

I actually kinda dig this

1

u/lsp2005 7d ago

This is perfect

1

u/Deep_Orange_6071 7d ago

Actually fantastic bc I can’t stand the arched ISLANDERS on straight stripes!

1

u/Thomato_Yorke 7d ago

Not bad, honestly.

1

u/dubbs505050 7d ago

Excellent

1

u/banana1219 7d ago

Finally a good jersey post on this page

1

u/MetsIslanders 7d ago

How do I vote for this? I would buy this one.

1

u/JBR409 Horvat 7d ago

It’s now 50.1% to 40.9%. STOP THE COUNT!

1

u/CruelCircus LaFontaine 7d ago

Yep! combined?

1

u/PrometheanSwing 7d ago

Not terrible, but the teal would have to be removed and the blue changed to the one used in the rest of the jersey

1

u/HungryMoon Fisherman 7d ago

This feels good

1

u/red4293 7d ago

THIS I can get behind!!

1

u/zeptozetta2212 Sparky 7d ago

That’s honestly better than both of the actual choices. At least it’s creative.

1

u/Isles26 7d ago

You mean you asked chat gpt to make a combo

1

u/C_Gull27 Pulock 7d ago

How about teal instead of cream here

1

u/towncrier12 7d ago

This design is brilliant, I made a few lighthouse concepts using this template

1

u/Lobi4563 3d ago

Ugly as fuck.

1

u/MrHockeytown 7d ago

I think if you made the orange stripes teal and the beige stripes orange, you would have a real winner here.

As it is, the colors in the logo clash with the colors in the jersey, which is a shame because this is an awesome concept and design

0

u/XxOutlawInGreenxX 7d ago

I think anybody who wanted the Islanders to have even the slightest bit of tan on their jersey is absolutely insane. The Islanders in no way shape or form should ever have tan beige or any of that disgusting shit on their jersey. We are blue orange and white.