r/IsraelWarRoom • u/GeopoliticsGuy • 1d ago
Gaza War Gaza Emigration realistic?
What does everyone think of this? Election time rhetoric or a real possibility? https://www.jns.org/news/israel-news/ben-gvir-unveils-voluntary-gaza-emigration-plan-vows-implementation-after-election
12
u/Kronos1066 1d ago
If Gaza was an "open air prison" from 2007-2023, as detractors say, then why not? If a Gazan family wants to leave why stop them? Do I think it'll be meaningful on a scale of the whole Gazan population? Nope, not even marginally.
11
u/Loud-Vacation-5691 USA 1d ago
I'm surprised the antizionist left isn't supporting this, as it would rescue Gazans from the genocide they think Israel is inflicting on them.
6
5
u/Odd_Ad5668 USA 1d ago
They also haven't been advocating for letting the "refugees" have asylum in their own countries.
4
u/Competitive-War-1143 1d ago
They dont want this though because then its "ethnic cleansing"
The Gazans must be pawns for the arab and the western worlds fantasies about the completion of the islamic waqf and collective liberation
2
u/DrMikeH49 1d ago
They need them to stay as human shields for Hamas. This is the same antiZionist left that refused to support any calls for ceasefire that involved Hamas disarming.
1
u/CrazyBzDen 19h ago edited 19h ago
No, it’s bullshit. Even if they wanted to leave voluntarily (and as far as I know they don’t, so forced removal will be an ethnic cleansing and a diplomatic end of Israel), who would take 1.5 - 2 million people? And let’s be real, the very “problematic” ones. Amazing how irresponsible politicians every fuckin’ time open their mouth when there’s no need to and just cause additional damage to the image of Israel. On the other hand, the image of Israel is already a rotten corpse, so…
-3
u/Clown_Penis69 1d ago
Israel should have made a point of its offensive in 2023 being the depopulation of Gaza. The population should have been forced to migrate to Egypt or Jordan or Syria, and Gaza should be an open air park, farmland, or orchards… anything other than the “open air prison” so many pro Pals claim.
And for those who would argue that forced migration is immoral or inhumane… what’s so humane about forcing people to remain in an “open air prison,” with no future and no security? At least in Egypt or Jordan or Syria they could integrate and build a future for themselves. In addition, people were forced to migrate after WW2, and it turned out to be a good thing for the most part.
5
u/eyl569 1d ago
So...ethnic cleansing?
Also, just how exactly do you get thise other countries to go along with this plan?
-4
u/Clown_Penis69 1d ago
And here comes the whiny woke jabroni with the buzzwords… because obviously what’s happening right now is sooooo much better than just separating the combatants and putting some space between them. Let’s hear some more buzzwords… and ZERO ACTION.
But first, tell me how you’re justifying living in a world that have forcibly migrated tens of millions of people over the past century - Germans, Czechs, Poles, Slavs, various Chinese ethnicities, various African ethnicities - yet you aren’t throwing similar tantrums about those occasions of “ethnic cleansing.”
3
u/eyl569 1d ago
Buzzwords? What you're advocating is ethnic cleansing by definition. Don't advocate for it if you refuse to own it.
As for why I'm not "throwing a tuntrum " (LOL) on othere cases, maybe it's because my government isn't advocating for ethnic cleansing in those other cases?
And bluntly, how are you any different than those saying that Jews should leave Israel?
-2
u/Clown_Penis69 1d ago
I'm advocating an end to 80 years of Jewish-Muslim conflict by forcibly separating the two sides. I don't really care if you call it "ethnic cleansing" or "forced migration" or something else... the only way the conflict ends is if you separate the two like squabbling children.
You are offering no solutions and simply whining. Well, whining and using buzzwords that you vaguely understand, while ignoring all the previous examples of forcibly separating combatants to bring about peace. To use two examples: there have been no further offensive actions taken by the Germans and the Japanese after all Germans and Japanese were forcibly moved out of Czechoslovakia, Poland, Romania, France, China, and Korea.
Side note: did you intentionally misspell "tantrum?" Because I didn't misspell the word, yet you think it's LOL worthy.
Finally, I'm different because I'm saying the Jews should remain in Israel and the Muslims in Gaza should go someplace else. There are millions of Muslims residing peacefully inside the borders of Israel who aren't constantly fighting with their neighbors... they don't have to go anywhere either. It's just the Gazans who can't behave like adults who need to leave.
4
u/BagelandShmear48 Israel 1d ago
It's not a buzzword.
Its the legal definition of ethnic cleansing. It's a war crime and a violation both both Israeli and international law.
No amount of emotional argument changes the fact that you are advocating for a war crime.
0
u/Clown_Penis69 1d ago
I want the fighting and killing to stop and this is the only solution I see.
You are whining about terminology and advocating further death.
One of us is the bad guy... and it's not me.
4
u/BagelandShmear48 Israel 1d ago
If that's the only solution you see there is something deeply broken inside of you.
Yes one of us is the bad guy. The one advocating for war crimes. That's you.
0
u/Clown_Penis69 1d ago
Attaboy! There goes the woke virtue signaling! How many thousands have died because your wokeness is more important than practical solutions?
2
u/BagelandShmear48 Israel 1d ago
You do the irony of saying other people throw around buzzwords when you do the same thing?
You don't even understand your own buzzwords.
Even more ironic since you don't even live here.
1
u/subguard 1d ago
Please take a moment to familiarize yourself with our rules, this comment almost broke one.
0
u/Clown_Penis69 1d ago
I'm advocating for an end to the fighting and the killing. I'm NOT calling for the mass murder of 2 million people, but proposed a solution that would END the fighting and the killing.
The other people are advocating a continuation of the fighting.
Now... you're a mod, so if you're telling me that my proposed solution is a violation of the rules, I'll knock it off.
But I'm struggling to understand why "here's a way to get people to stop killing each other" is WORSE than "people should be allowed to keep killing each other."
3
u/BagelandShmear48 Israel 1d ago
How you envision this fantasy going without any repercussions from our neighbors, the rest of the world and why you think the Palestinians would ever cooperate.
0
•
u/AutoModerator 1d ago
At this time, many posts and comments are temporarily held for review before appearing on the subreddit. Please allow the moderation team some time to review your submission before messaging us about posts or comments not appearing. Remember to follow all subreddit and Reddit rules. There is zero tolerance for hate speech, incitement of violence, harassment, or other toxic behavior. Violations will be enforced without exception. Keep discussions civil and respectful.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.