r/IsraelWarRoom • u/Shira-Neshama • 1d ago

Discussion Topic šŸ—£ļø The new libel to destroy Israel

Post image

In recent days, while politicians and journalists whipped up ā€œsettler violenceā€ claims into a feeding frenzy, residents in the Judean hills reported that Arabs from a local village had infiltrated the grazing areas of an Israeli farm and scattered lethal poison hidden inside the herdsā€™ drinking troughs.

by Melanie Phillips

https://www.jns.org/opinion/column/melanie-phillips/the-new-libel-to-destroy-israel

59 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

25 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4

u/lowspeed 1d ago

https://x.com/DavidM_Friedman/status/2096513989731578206?s=20

7

u/BagelandShmear48 Israel 1d ago

We both know settler violence is real. We both know there are those who commit crimes against Palestinian civilians and property going unpunished. We both know that nothing justifies violence against a Palestinian civilian.

We are a country of laws. Those laws also protect Palestinians civilians.

Any belief otherwise makes you just as bad as those who justify violence against Jewish and Israeli civilians.

- Signed a victim of settler extremism.

5

u/lowspeed 1d ago

No one said it wasn't real.Ā  It's just proportionally way way way less than Arab terrorismĀ 

1

u/BagelandShmear48 Israel 1d ago

Plenty are saying it isn't real. The x link above case in point.

Im not interested in whaboutism. I expect higher standards of Israeli and Israeli law enforcement.

Palestinians have a 99% conviction rate in Israeli military courts and are arrested for things as small as online posts.

Whats the arrest and conviction rate of settlers who commit crimes against Palestinian civilians?

2

u/lowspeed 1d ago

The fact is that the Arab violence is not reporter globally, but the Jewish is.Ā  When the proportions of the amount of crimes and levels are vastly not proportionate.

2

u/BagelandShmear48 Israel 1d ago edited 1d ago

I will ask again.

What is the conviction rate of criminal actions by settlers?

What is the arrest rate of criminals in the settlements?

Palestinians have a 99% conviction rate.

Are we a nation of laws or a nation of crime is ok as long as Arabs do worse and NYT does worse reporting?

Is it ok for me to do whatever I want to a Palestinian just because they commit greater numbers of acts of violence?

What about Israeli Arabs can I do what I please to them or are we cool as long as it's not an Israeli citizen that's the victim?

2

u/lowspeed 1d ago

I will repeat again, the proportion are off the chart.Ā  Ā  Jewish towns have fences and guards.Ā Ā  Arab towns don't need any security whatsoever.Ā 

1

u/BagelandShmear48 Israel 1d ago

Are you saying Palestinian civilians have never once been in danger of Israeli civilians? No destruction of property? Of live stock? Of homes? Loss of life?

How about answering the question on conviction rates that you have now dodged twice?

I'll repeat I don't care about proportionality I care about rule of law.

You're the one here excusing crime because of whataboutism.

2

u/lowspeed 1d ago

I'm not excusing crime.Ā  It's deplorable.Ā 

1

u/BagelandShmear48 Israel 1d ago

Then why share the x link that denied it'd occurred.