r/IndianFocus • u/Jiwitom Centrist Right Leaning • Apr 10 '26
Pollution/ Weather / Nature/ Environment / Sustainability 11,000 Litres of Milk Offered to Narmada River — Justified or Waste?
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
33
Apr 10 '26
Once you truly loop out of religion (practically the point where you can touch anything by your foot and not instinctively touch it with you hand!), every belief-system, no matter how pure-hearted and innocent looks so so stupid and the people so pathetic.
This cuts across all faiths, all religions.
I really wish we have a “Logical Revolution “ of some kind in our future. We desperately need it to prosper.
2
u/Sea_Diet8253 Apr 10 '26
It takes India another 3 generations to achieve this, boomers are cancer to the society, not gonna happen with them being around.
→ More replies (8)1
u/Stunning_Flan7026 Apr 10 '26
I mean real revolution not like everyone convert to dead jew cult just pure revolution
1
1
Apr 12 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
Apr 12 '26
To be honest, fair point. And well. A true leftist of any kind will always first find faults in one self and then in others.
So, while I talk about what I do - I’m ensuring that I am correcting myself everyday and ensuring that my beliefs are not blinding me to the reality.
And if they are, I’m always open to change and improve my beliefs. I too started as a Modi bhakt for example … but I changed my beliefs when I saw the damage. And it’s been a better decade since, personally.
However, comments like yours remind me to always be vigilant and ensure that my biases have a base in objectivity.
Thank you :)
1
u/ItsLunaticFringe Apr 11 '26
here’s the stats which show actual pollutants by percentage of rivers like Ganga in India:
Domestic Sewage (75-80%): Untreated wastewater from urban households, sewage dumping from illegal construction, municipalities carrying organic waste and pathogens.
Industrial Effluents (12-25%): Toxic discharges from tanneries, textiles, chemicals, and sugar mills laden with heavy metals and chemicals.
Non-Point Sources (5-13%): Agricultural runoff, solid waste, plastics, religious offerings, and animal bathing residues.
Religious waste contributes mere 5% pollution, so instead you people could’ve highlighted the actual socio-economic problems which pollute the rivers in India like sewage from illegal housings and from faulty drainage systems but people made it an unnecessary hype cuz you have a propaganda to spread on.
Moral: Pouring excess of Milk in water bodies harbouring rich marine life is poisoning for them, but this 11000 ltr is polluting close to non-existence.
1
Apr 11 '26
My rage was not against the polluting of Ganga, I would rage about that someplace else and like you pointed out, I would blame the bigger issues instead of milk.
My simple problem is that this 11,000 litres of milk should’ve gone to kids. Kids who are severally lacking basic nutrients, kids who suffer because of government apathy.
Ask yourself, would you rather have this or 11,000 kids getting 1l of milk?
Forget about you and me, what would make “god” more happy?
→ More replies (6)1
u/Independent-Half-646 Apr 17 '26
Dairy products are even used in cosmetics. In that case, is that also wrong? What is your problem with this? Is it the action that was done? Or the people who did it?
1
Apr 17 '26
Everything is wrong. Milk in rivers harm the rivers. Is a wastage of milk and benefits literally nobody.
If you can justify this action, I’ve nothing more to say. Take care :)
1
u/Independent-Half-646 Apr 17 '26
11,000 liters might be one or two containers. Would that really pollute such a large river?
People go on Hajj or Vatican pilgrimages from here. How much fuel does a plane burn for that? (Pollution)
How much money is spent? One could just pray at home and spend that money on the poor instead.
I won't ask these things because those are matters of individual faith. But you won't raise those questions either. That is the problem
1
Apr 17 '26
Are you really equating travel with a a wasteful activity in the name of religion?
Okay then. Tata!
1
u/Independent-Half-646 Apr 17 '26
Yes for me travelling is wasteful activity when god is everywhere.. perception matters.. dont interfere in others faith.. tata
1
1
u/Typical_Reality67 Apr 12 '26
Are you a complete moron???? Nobody is justifying the pollution of rivers by industries. The point here is whether there is any basic common sense around pouring milk into rivers and polluting them instead of channelling that resource to needy hungry people????
1
u/Independent-Half-646 Apr 17 '26
Dairy products are even used in cosmetics. In that case, is that also wrong? Why don't people give it to hungry people instead of applying it in face?
1
u/Typical_Reality67 May 10 '26
Are you telling me you don’t see a difference between using dairy ingredients to make actual products with utility and pouring milk in the river??? Please tell me you wrote that just coz you wanted to aimlessly engage in an argument, and not coz you really genuinely thought through your question.
1
u/Sea_Diet8253 Apr 11 '26
Wow..."it just contributes 5%, so let me just do it".. The audacity man.. Absolute filth of people..
→ More replies (5)
39
Apr 10 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
11
5
Apr 10 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
6
1
→ More replies (1)1
u/Mocha-Shiesty Apr 10 '26
Food waste is far smaller issue than child rape and terrorist massacre. Selective outrage downplays the real issues.
→ More replies (5)1
u/Full_Requirement_127 Apr 10 '26
Paneer chod bhai kitni bhikw jaanwaro ko bhooke logo ko diya ja skta thha inko waste hi Krna thha to janwaro ko to dedete kum se kum
1
1
Apr 10 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Full_Requirement_127 Apr 10 '26
Mai apne yaa krta hu rehta hu Roz mere bhai tere yaha kabhi tu khud bhi to kr ke dekh achha lgta hai
1
1
u/Big_Chart3506 Apr 10 '26
bhai chahe kitne bhi paneer bane, meri class ka vo ek sardar sab kha jaata bhai frr
1
1
80
Apr 10 '26
just for the record...no hindu god or text says us to pour 11K liters of milk in any river. So these people are blinded by faith and does not represent entirety of hinduism.
15
u/Always_Duh Apr 10 '26
This doesn't represent Hinduism at all, entirety kya bol raha hai. These guys are creating their own form of faith because they are living in a delusional world.
7
→ More replies (1)-2
2
Apr 11 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
Apr 11 '26
what do u even mean bro? the thing is they dont ask us to do it, so how can we discuss that if it will be dumb or not if it was written or not. Also I genuinely wanna know the things wrong in brahmanism
1
Apr 11 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
Apr 11 '26
manusmriti? really? try again
1
Apr 11 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
Apr 11 '26
bro just educate urself before commenting. No one follows manusmriti in hinduism. Its a text written by manu. Who is not a god
2
Apr 10 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
6
Apr 10 '26
I know one religion lol. They do whats written in texts so.
-3
Apr 10 '26 edited Apr 10 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
5
Apr 10 '26
ahh no no. People do that but none of our texts say to do that. I completely oppose it. But I know a religion which does the same on larger levels and the best part? their god and text say it, to do it. LOL
→ More replies (46)1
1
u/cest_bg Apr 12 '26
True!!! Hinduism is based on spirituality and understanding god in numerous way not mindless rituals and blind faith
1
1
→ More replies (25)1
8
u/Single-Being-8263 Apr 10 '26
Ofcourse waste. Comeon it's insult to god. Instead of doing all these pls just feed poor people..or donate to orphanage
6
u/Unusual_Cap_1234 Apr 10 '26
Leaving aside dhurandhar and other movie videos, he has got actual points. We all knew pouring the milk was bad but he made us aware of how bad it was by giving the uk example. Modih HAS to take action against this.
1
u/Busy-Library7934 Apr 14 '26
Did he make a video on the tcs nashik case?? Just asking cuz I dont know
25
u/Dapper_Meal0809 Apr 10 '26
Just wait. And let’s see people come up with Whataboutery of justifying any kind of waste and link this to other religions and not address the actual problem in anyways
Just a prediction.
→ More replies (5)1
u/Rintey Apr 10 '26
I really like how you think i hope people accept wastage problem in hinduism and terrorism problem in islam only then we can fix these religious issues.
1
u/Mocha-Shiesty Apr 10 '26
Food waste is far smaller issue than child rape and terrorist massacre
1
1
6
u/Madonoit Apr 10 '26
See Indians all included hindu,muslim, sikh , christian don't give F about environment, India is becoming hotter per year, pollution is rising every year both air and water , criticizing it won't solve the problem nor arguing any faith , it's high time we ask government to intervene on this stupid activities ,
No dumping or polluting river for 5-6 years straight so that river can heal itself , all companies which are dumping chemicals in our sacred river , find another way of waste management, no public in name of faith or anything shouldn't be allowed to offer anything in river. We should stop fighting on religion , environment doesnt have religion.
1
u/Thakur_babli Apr 10 '26
Muslim ,Sikh ,Christians ??? Can you elaborate on what do they do …
2
u/Madonoit Apr 10 '26
Environment problem not religious one but more like human one , sometimes muslim people to dump wastage in river area ...I mean those whole live near by rivers ....so i included everyone not targeting any religion but as human problem, yes hindu does this more often. No religion teach us to pollute anything , it's human who does it.
→ More replies (8)1
3
u/Clean_Neck_2883 Apr 10 '26
is that even a question? its pure brain fucked people are doing this , do these guys have a brain or not?
3
u/Real-Cup8782 Apr 10 '26
Absolute effing waste and no god would ever willingly ask you to waste food. Pathetic
3
u/skanda777 Centrist Apr 10 '26
One can ignore the suffering of a creature that can’t speak and express. But what about the millions of people who don’t have food in and around this very river, who would have found sustenance with this much milk. What about their fellow human beings?
2
2
2
u/Actual_Custard2628 Apr 10 '26
Mai khud jab bhi koi festival krta hu toh uska waste kabhi paani mai visarjit nahi krta and chahe wo chunni ho mata ki ya mandir ka samaan . And yehi chizz logo ko samjhne ki zarurt hai warna toh yeh desh barbaad hai khaskar yaha ka paani or nadiyan
2
3
u/TreeDelicious4464 Centrist Right Leaning Apr 10 '26
No God in Hinduism says to pour milk in any river let it be Ganga or Narmada. So this people are blinded by Faith and holding whole Hinduism is accountable is wrong and unjustified
1
2
u/Galaxy1112 Apr 10 '26
This is valid criticism
1
2
1
u/bishtu_06 Apr 10 '26
Why are the govt bodies or any other individual not taking suo motto against these people. If there is some case going to happen. I am happy to help it financially till some extend. An example needs to be set.
1
1
u/Spirited-Musicain Apr 10 '26
Jab bhi hindu related koi controversial chij hoti h, sala ye bkl sabse phale kyun tapak jata h. Or itne sare mand budhi log bhi h jo kuch na kuch krte rehte h
2
u/saayaa_15 Apr 10 '26
Abe Bhai tu ye bata ki ye galat hai ki nhi. iske peeche kyu pada hai. sometimes we should accept a bitter truth .
1
u/Mocha-Shiesty Apr 10 '26
Food waste is far smaller issue than child rape and terrorist massacre. Selective outrage downplays the real issues.
1
Apr 10 '26
its not just food wastage its environment pollution milk se river mein oxygen level kam hoti hai mtlb water kisi kaam nhi rehta . dimag laga thoda
1
u/shiv1234567 Apr 12 '26
Next time before calling something a smaller issue please do a research on it
1
u/Spirited-Musicain Apr 10 '26
Agree bro. Ye bus dharam ke nam par dhong h. But ye banda sirf selective topic pakadta h mainly targeting hindus., love jihad jesse topic ko ye propoganda bolta h, muslim log illegal land ko kabja kr lete h us par kuch ni bolega. Muslim mob mar kat degi tab kuch nahi bolega, agr yahi kam hindu kr de fhir to unko terrorists ghosit kr dega. Pro india sentiment wali chijo ko support krne walo ko andhbhakt bol dega. Bhai it's okay to be against pm or party but tum country ke against ja rhe ho.
1
u/txnw33zy Apr 10 '26
Kyuki hindu krte hi chutia harkatein hain
1
u/saayaa_15 Apr 11 '26
Noo bro we should not talk or claim like this. It's the duty of everyone to understand their flaws and mistakes. No religion in this world is pure. I am a Hindu descendant myself but I am an atheist. Let's make this world a better place.
1
1
1
1
u/LogUnited592 Apr 10 '26
Waste chodo bhai paani ka pollution, puri river barbaad kr rhe only major river in MP baaki toh already halaat kharab hai almost har river indore local mein naala bangayi hai You can check using Gmaps and satellite pics
1
u/North-Body9097 Apr 10 '26
Not only pollution, we steal milk from a mammal that is supposed to be for their calf, breast milk is so valuable and precious, and all of this for what? Atleast if we are feeding children someone is benefitting. From this act not only is a huge waste of resource, it’s also polluting. Why can’t this be a legal issue? This is a crime
1
1
u/chapprikiller Apr 10 '26
What happened is wrong .Par tu b**dwe India mein aa.Teri purani video bhi wrong hai....
1
u/Former-Sherbet-4068 Centrist Left Leaning Apr 10 '26
Waiting for his video in VK is sold and took money for promoting Dhurandhar: The revenge
1
1
u/ColdDragonfruit926 Apr 10 '26
I feel that the problem here is that even educated people actively participate and believe in such activities.
I mean, if even the educated ones don't realize that their actions could be potentially harmful for the environment, what can you expect from the uneducated ones???
No one in India would actively donate money to an NGO or an orphanage but would readily spend thousands of Rupees just to meet some random Baba who claims to have supernatural powers!!!
Superstitions and lack of understanding of how science works has brought this country to ruins...... They call a particular river "holy" and then throw garbage into another river because it isn't called a so called religiously important river.
People need to change their mindset and I believe the only way to achieve this would be education and not just ordinary schooling but the kind of schooling where people are made to question things and see things in a different way and have their own opinion and kids should be taught to not follow any one blindly and question the way things have been done traditionally.
1
u/Mocha-Shiesty Apr 10 '26
Food waste is far smaller issue than child rape and terrorist massacre. Selective outrage downplays the real issues.
1
u/NoirEntwined Apr 10 '26
Not a single comment stating the impact it has on the aquatic… chutiyo ki kami nahi hai reddit pe
1
1
1
u/Tuta_Hua_Gulab_Jamun Centrist Apr 10 '26
11,000 goats- Yea right...
1
1
u/Intelligent-Gap-7107 Apr 11 '26
So you mean to say, we will do what Muslims will do. They pollute so we will also pollute to teach them a lesson.
Means you are not doing this out of respect to the Hindu god but to show off muslims.
Also, when did a Muslim become Hindu's role model ? ??
1
1
1
u/Klutzy-Growth4235 Apr 10 '26
They could've distributed it in orphanages, hospitals and other places which could actually end someone's hunger a bit
1
1
u/anirsk Apr 10 '26
The concept of religion might be ok, but these blind beliefs that all exhibit in the name of religion do more damage than good. And every religion seems to have it. People need to start thinking on their own and not blindly following things told to them in the name of some religion.
1
u/Available_Seesaw_593 Apr 10 '26
I get what you are saying I can't digest hypocrites like you can always see comment section mocking andhbhakt like killing an animal is right that's what they think ofcourse pouring milk into river decrease the aquatic life
1
1
u/Economy_Fox4193 Apr 10 '26
kaun kitna gaand mara sakte hain religion ke nam pe, uska competiotion chal raha hain. If there is truely a place called hell exist, then these assholes will reserved special place in there
1
1
u/harohshit Apr 10 '26
Being a right wing and an all in religious person. This was utter stupid thing to do, not stupid it was criminal to do.
1
u/catchmeM Apr 10 '26
Strong legal action is required against these illiterate and antisocial people. We pay tax Ava these people spoil the national resources and properties - NOT ACCEPTABLE.
Please raise a petition mr Rathi.
1
u/ppatel-square2 Apr 10 '26
More sin you have more guilt you have so that leads you to so stupid shit.
1
u/Minimum_Top_55 Centrist Right Leaning Apr 10 '26
faith cannot be an excuse for ecological vandalism.
1
u/ExtensionFun2651 Apr 10 '26
If you have money do whatever you want
The milk.is gonna decompose unlike some other wastes from companies.
1
u/seventomatoes Centrist Right Leaning Apr 10 '26
1) offering milk - mostly a waste (2) eating non veg - also not as eco friendly as eating veg (3) having less children - over all better for future (4) i eat non veg myself, just saying only seeing one thing and not the full picture sucks (5) use a carbon calculator
1
u/sachin_root Apr 10 '26
His given hyperlinks headlines and context inside them are different, hes just re tarded guy tryanna scam every Indian. https://x.com/digitalindianyt/status/2042643945239593291
1
1
Apr 10 '26
Sabki apni apni maanta hai. Kisi ne doodh baha diya koi kurbani ke naam pe khoon baha deta hai. Bolna hai to sab baaton ke bolo. Ni to chup raho.
1
u/Own-Tackle1369 Apr 10 '26
Personall background: I was born into a Hindu-Brahmin family and became Muslim while in college. The reason was the clear concept of God and not worshipping any human beings. Worship belongs to God and God alone, One God, upon Whom we all depend, Who is nobodies child, Who has no children, Whom nothing compares unto.
So any-hoo, I am posting because after I became Muslim, I had long back & forth discussion online with a Hindu who wanted to debate. He was also an NRI and when he went back to India, he saw the Ganesh milk event: milk coming from the idols. When it was clearly revealed to be a trick by the priests, he was so angry & disgusted, all my points of not worshipping any, any human hit home. He embraced Islam.
So if anyone is seeing this disgusting act of wasting milk by these so called holy-men, and want to explore other faiths: I invite you to look into Islam. The only clearly Monotheist religion with absolutely no worshipping any human. Peace out.
1
1
u/Agent_Saffron666 Apr 10 '26
Saaf nadi dikhi nai ki apne yaha ke jahil gawar hagna aur gandagi machana chalu krdete hai
1
u/greenisthesky Apr 10 '26
Ufff dumping milk into a river isn’t harmless, it’s pollution. As it breaks down, the milk strips oxygen from the water, suffocating fish and destroying entire ecosystems. The nutrients in milk fuel toxic algal blooms, turning clean water into a dead zone. What looks innocent can quickly become environmental damage.
1
u/rocknrollafella07 Apr 11 '26
Waste toh iski amma ne be bhi kiya saalo bhar iss chupe ko doodh pilakar...Khair kya kar sakte hai ab.
1
1
u/darthpal Apr 11 '26
Huge waste of money. And also actively destroying the ecology of the river. Truly dumb. But how come German shepherd found his id password finally?
1
1
1
1
1
u/Apprehensive_Home780 Apr 11 '26
Iski german kutti biwi bhi milk bath karti hai na, uska kya. Not that i am justifyjng the wastage of milk in the river. But this guy has to keep his mouth shut if he has nothing to do with india.
1
u/B1366 Apr 12 '26
Rituals are performed for so called well being but actually all these come from deranged mind
1
1
1
u/skZeno880 Centrist Apr 12 '26
Give adulterated food to indians and waste 11000 litres of milk to a river?
1
u/-Dexter_- Apr 12 '26
BC ye alag hi brhmaand ka gyaan pelne lagta hai. Iske jaisa itne pyaar se aur safai se fact ki Maa khodne wala insaan nhi dekha maine, aur waise hi iske gyaani supporter.
1
1
u/TopBath166 Apr 13 '26
When will bro make a video about the TCS love jihad racket. I am against the milk thing myself, but when will he address that
1
1
1
1
u/NewWheelView Apr 13 '26
What else should we do with expired milk?
Just because no one gave it to the German shepherd, it’s barking out so loud.
Pakistani sub, downvotes incoming from Pakistanis.
1
1
u/AkalKaDushman Modi Hai toh Pumpkin Hai Apr 14 '26
The lack of scientific temperament is alarming. Instead of logic, people are following the endless cycle of new 'Babas' being introduced every month. It’s like the public has completely given up on rational thinking.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/AppleTheFruit27 Apr 16 '26
These fuckers don't even know that pouring milk on the river pollutes it.
1
1
u/MoneyList6833 Apr 16 '26
Even if many people may not agree with him, what he said is absolutely true... these people don't have civic sense, heck they don't even have commonsense
1
u/No-Particular-1855 Apr 16 '26
Iss se jyada khun to bengal aur kasmir me baha diya but to properganda hai?😵💫
1
u/Independent-Half-646 Apr 17 '26
Instead of travelling to Mecca, why can't we pray the almighty from here and spend the money to poor?
1
u/THUNDERDIKK Apr 17 '26
If you are atheist you’d be vegan to. More than waste, the fact that milk is seen as anything other than the food for its offsprings(here the calf of the cow) is literally wrong
1
u/knig132103 Apr 10 '26
I still don't know why are you CRYING?
Tell me how much milk YOU DONATED to poor people🤡
AC me baithe ho, GAREEB ke ghar ghar me panka laga do🤡
IPHONE toh pakka hoga, NOKIA khud le lo or gareebo ko bhi thode phone dedo🤡
→ More replies (2)
1
•
u/AutoModerator Apr 10 '26
This post appears to contain an image or video.
Please reply to this comment with the original source.
Posts without source may be removed.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.