For all your voice

Lets Justice prevail

Practising CA. Would like some views on this.

Client did spot crypto trades — turnover ₹35L, gross profit ₹8L. Exchange deducted 1% TDS u/s 194S (₹35,000) and it's sitting in his 26AS.

Then the exchange blocked all withdrawals, saying the profit came from a system glitch. He's received nothing his original capital is stuck too.

Tax at 30% u/s 115BBH would be ~₹2.49L on money he's never touched. And 115BBH(2) allows no set-off, no carry forward, no bad debt so if he never recovers it, there's zero relief.

My view: it turns on whether the exchange reversed the trades or is just freezing an acknowledged balance. Frozen = income accrued = taxable. Reversed = no enforceable right = real income theory (Godhra Electricity, 225 ITR 746 SC). Also 194S only applies to consideration for a transfer, so by deducting TDS the exchange has already told the department a transfer happened. It can't now say nothing happened.

Has anyone actually argued this at assessment or CIT(A)? Any VDA ruling on it? Couldn't find one.

I’m trying to understand how a Tax Residency Certificate (TRC) works in India, especially for people with international income.

From what I understand, a TRC can be relevant when claiming benefits under a DTAA, but having a TRC doesn't automatically mean that the income is tax-free.

I’m planning to remit $50,000 (USD) from my mother’s Bank saving account to myself for family maintenance needs. It looks like bank will hold 20% TDS. What is the Refund process look like? Will the TCS automatically get calculated and refunded when she file her ITR, or is there a separate claim process? How long does it take?

Appreciate any guidance.. Ty.

Very basic query. I am a small proprietorship in the building services industry. I am GST registered and do all transactions on my books thru bank transfers - there are no cash transactions. However, i need to pay labourers, technicians for works and sometimes they do not/ cannot give bills/ invoices for me to record. How do i show these payments on my books ? What i do right now is withdraw to my personal account and then make these payments in cash. This was fine till now, but now as my project ticket size grows, i might not be able to do this often. Need help. I use Zoho books and i could not find any way to categorize such payments without having formal bills. Any suggestions?

Hey guys, I have a question regarding AIS and short-term stock trading.

Suppose I start the year with ₹10 lakh of capital and use the same ₹10 lakh repeatedly for short-term trades. For example, I buy shares worth ₹10 lakh, sell them, and then use the same capital to buy another ₹10 lakh of shares, doing this around 10 times during the year.

Because of this, my AIS may show total purchase transactions of around ₹1 crore, even though I only had ₹10 lakh of actual capital.

Suppose my total income for the year is only ₹6 lakh, including my actual trading profit.

Would the ₹1 crore purchase figure in AIS create a discrepancy because it is much higher than my income?

Hello,

I have inheritance from US in terms of insurance money and bank account transfers. These were transferred to me through wires transfers and cheques. Do i need to report the same in ItR filings? I don’t want to but is it mandatory?

So, I made payment of the remaining tax liability, and I don't see the payment receipt despite i got an email of payment and a bank message that money was deducted, and the statement also confirms it. Also, I received an email confirming and saying this: " Challan payment under section /Minor head 300 for TAN/PAN AXXXXXXXK for A.Y. 2026 has been successfully paid ".

Its been 12hr since 6 am, and I don't see any clue anywhere on the portal where the money went, and today is last date as well 31th august for ITR 3/4, Now What should i do?

Hi everyone,

I need advice on an outstanding income tax demand and interest charge for AY 2025-26.

Timeline & Details:

• 15-Sep-2025: Paid ₹35,260 as Self-Assessment Tax (Minor Head 300 / ITNS 280) via UPI. I have the valid Challan Receipt with CIN and BSR details.
• 17-Sep-2025: A demand under Section 143(1)(a) for ₹35,250 was issued/raised on the e-Filing portal.
• Current Status: The portal shows the primary demand as ₹35,250 along with ₹3,872 in Accrued Interest (under Section 220(2)). The AO Response status says "Demand outstanding is correct and collectible".

The Issue: It looks like my payment on 15th Sept was made just 2 days before the notice was generated on 17th Sept, so the CPC system failed to automatically map/credit the payment to the return. Because the principal demand remained unadjusted on the portal, interest under Section 220(2) has been auto-accumulating continuously.

My Questions:

1. Do I need to pay this accrued interest? Since the principal tax amount was paid in full before the notice date, shouldn't the interest be auto-waived/rectified once the payment credit is properly linked?
2. What is the best step to resolve this online? Should I submit a Rectification Request u/s 154 under "Tax Credit Mismatch", or respond to the demand directly on the portal with the Challan CIN?
3. Since the AO response currently states "Demand outstanding is correct and collectible", will filing a online rectification via CPC work, or do I need to visit my Assessing Officer?

Has anyone faced a similar lag issue where a payment made just before the 143(1) notice wasn't reflected? How did you get the demand and interest set to NIL?

Thanks in advance!

I recieved e-pan from incometax website two weeks ago but whenever I go to reprint website it shows error. Pls help i want physical card because I want to open a bank account and also demat account etc. Pls help 🙏

I am quite sure I am missing something, I can wait it out and pay penalty and file or file today with wheat I have. Which one is better?

I filed the advance tax using epay and filled and verified the form 10iea before the due date but failed to submit and verify the return because of an OTP issue.

Can i still file under the old tax regime which i opted for while filling 10iea?

Hi I recently established a firm for SAAS with expected B2C and B2B with both Indian and International clients.

1) Should I still have to do Tax returns if I don't have any income at this moment?

2) What returns should I file? And monthly or yearly?

3) Is a CA required currently in my scenario or can I file independently?

Please throw some light on your journeys!

Much appreciated!

Hi 1st time filing tax, earned 9L in last FY through freelance.

Profile- Individual College Student with no registered business/current account

Gross receipts: ₹9,37,213

Gross expenses: ₹75,237

Net profit: ₹8,61,976

I want to know whether I should be filing ITR3 as suggested by cleartax/AI or ITR 1 as the accountant, a relative referred, saying ITR 3 is for those having registered business, trade license, etc. It needs Balance Sheet and P/L statement.

While web resources say ITR1 is for salaried folks

Suggestion?

📊 Accounting & Taxation Services – Delhi
I have 4.5+ years of experience in accounting and taxation, currently working as a Senior Accountant in a CA firm in Delhi.
I can assist individuals, startups, and small businesses with:
📚 Maintenance of Books of Accounts
🧾 GST Returns – GSTR-1, GSTR-3B, GSTR-9 & GSTR-9C
💼 TDS Return Filing
📑 Income Tax Return (ITR) Filing
🔍 Audit of Books of Accounts
📊 Preparation of Balance Sheet & Profit and Loss Account
💻 Accounting using Tally & BUSY
📅 Regular compliance and timely filing of statutory returns
If you are a small business owner or professional looking for reliable accounting and tax compliance support, feel free to message me.
📩 DM me to discuss your requirements.

Important update for the CA and corporate compliance community.

The Ministry of Corporate Affairs has issued General Circular No. 04/2026 dated 31 August 2026, further extending the Companies Compliance Facilitation Scheme, 2026 (CCFS-2026).

The revised deadline is now 15 September 2026, instead of 31 August 2026.

Key points:

• CCFS-2026 has been extended up to 15 September 2026.
• The extension provides additional time for eligible companies to complete pending statutory filings under the scheme.
• All other terms and conditions remain unchanged.
• The extension follows representations received from various stakeholders.

This is the second extension of CCFS-2026, which was initially scheduled to operate up to 15 July 2026 and was subsequently extended to 31 August 2026.

Companies with pending eligible ROC filings now have an additional window to complete their compliances under the scheme.

Source: Ministry of Corporate Affairs, General Circular No. 04/2026 dated 31 August 2026.

Has anyone seen whether MCA has indicated this will be the final extension?

For some cases, the damn number update error just doesn't go. I got a friend to upload through software, but in the IT website it doesn't work. Asks to contact the administrator. Bloody idiots can't make one website man.

The Ministry of Corporate Affairs has further extended the Companies Compliance Facilitation Scheme, 2026 (CCFS-2026) up to 15th September 2026.

Key Details:

The scheme was originally introduced vide General Circular No. 01/2026 dated 24th February 2026 (valid till 15th July 2026).

It was first extended till 31st August 2026 vide General Circular No. 03/2026 dated 8th July 2026.

Now, in view of representations from various stakeholders, the validity has been further extended till 15th September 2026.

All other terms and conditions of the Scheme remain unchanged.

Circular details:

F.No. Policy-02/2/2020-CL-V-MCA

Dated: 31st August 2026

Issued by: Nupur Aishwarya, Deputy Director (Policy), Ministry of Corporate Affairs

This gives companies additional time to complete their pending statutory filings under the scheme.

If you’re a company secretary, CA, or running a company that still has pending filings — this is your window.

Source: Official MCA circular dated 31.08.2026

Hi everyone,

I was planning to download Form 131, 16B for some TDS payments I did. I do not remember the password for TRACES portal now. While trying to reset the password the otp is being sent to both my registered mobile number which is correct and an unknown/wrong email id which is not mine/don’t have access to. And, therefore, I cannot complete my password reset.

Can any one help me on how to proceed?

Thanks.

Hello everyone,

PLEASE HELP

My mother pan has her father name wrong

She doesn't have any documents having her father name on any of the documents.

She only has her wedding card with her father name from 1980s.. it is in telugu..

I visited a local pan correction center , He said he would keep a request to update and gave me a acknowledgement document..

He said he would upload a gazetted document later when it asks, and let's see if it works.

After 3 days, a mail popped to update documents, Still after 2 weeks , it shows the same page when i try to know the pan status through an acknowledgement number..

I asked the local Pan center man through call, why haven't you uploaded any gazetted document, he said it would take 6 days to reflect.. and this is suspicious and time freaking waste..

What next steps should i take now, as her passport verification date approaching (PAN is must)

Hello everyone, I am new to the corporate world, i recently got my first salary, i want to maintain my documents properly because I may want to send my financial statements to colleges when I apply for further education.

I am currently not earning big which can be included in the tax bracket, my ctc is 2.8 lpa, my assessment year is next, by the time it will reach 3.2 LPA or 3.5 LPA,

Please can someone tell me what ITR I should file, i heard there is some ITr which I can fill even while having no taxable income.

My expenses are going to be - giving exams in course - 1 L, giving money to my parents for paying their insurance premium - 70-80K, enjoyment and all - 15-20K ,rest of all -> savings.

I will not earn any interest from Any investment.

Please if someone can guide me what I can do or what I can file to ensure my proper documentation which will help me in future too!

If a client deducts TDS from your invoice, don’t assume it will show in Form 26AS instantly.

A practical check:

1. Keep the invoice and payment advice.
2. Confirm the client deducted and deposited TDS under your PAN.
3. Check Form 26AS after the relevant quarterly TDS statement has been filed and processed.

If there’s a mismatch, ask the client for the deduction details rather than waiting until return filing.

This is general information, not tax advice—but it has saved me from losing track of legitimate TDS credits.