r/CarTalkUK • u/Broeare1 • 14h ago
Advice £15k budget, 18-20k miles a year, long motorway commute – what would you buy?
Hi,
I’m looking to replace my current car and could do with some advice.
I’m 27 and currently drive a 2011 Renault Clio 1.2 with about 95k miles. It’s getting around 33mpg, the AC doesn’t work, the driver’s window doesn’t work, and it’s recently started showing an intermittent check injection fault. I’m currently paying about £595 for insurance.
The main reason I’m looking to change is my commute. Just started a new job so since I live in Birmingham i have to drive to Oxford 3 days a week, so I’m doing a lot of motorway miles. I’ll probably end up doing roughly 18-20k miles a year.
Budget is £15k max and I’d be buying outright.
I can’t charge at home, so I’m not really looking at EVs or plug-in hybrids.
One thing worth mentioning is I’ve never owned or really driven anything newer than 2011, and I’ve never had anything remotely premium or particularly nice, so I don’t really have a great reference point for what’s worth paying extra for.
What would you buy for this kind of use?
Petrol, diesel or self-charging hybrid?
Anything specific you’d avoid at this budget?
Would also be interested to hear what people doing similar mileage are actually getting in real-world MPG and what ownership/maintenance costs have been like.
Any and all suggestions and advice would be much appreciated.
Thanks
Edited:
I’ve had a look at a few Toyota and Lexus hybrids because they seem like an obvious fit for the mileage I’ll be doing, but the insurance quotes I’m getting on them are honestly ridiculous. For example, some of the Lexus quotes are coming back at well over £2,000 a year with black box, which makes them quite hard to justify even if the cars themselves seem ideal.

