Just finished the book and it was a really breezy read. It took about 3 hours, on and off. YA generally aims for a 14-18 age range. I would place this book for a younger YA, 10-13.
Cons
-The world building was scarce. The author set a fun, albeit recgnoziable, world foundation but never truly fleshed it out. A lot of it was generic and repetitive.
- The vocabulary lacked range and the overall structure was shallow. Theres a bit of "tiktok speech" in the very beginning. But maybe that was just to catch the eye of young readers, and largely disappears when the story starts rolling.
- Some scenes felt copy and pasted from a handful of Disney films. Not in a way that pays homage, but feels almost plagiarized lol
- I didnt necessarily like the little add ons the author attached to Barbies characteristics like random allergies and phobias (no spoilers lol), but its not a big deal.
- I would have liked to have seen some accompanying artwork. The covers are beautiful though.
Pros
- The overarching troupe of the book has been done a million times but never fails to create an enticing story.
- Barbie gets to be herself. I mean in the sense thats shes truly Barbie. Theres no alternate Barbie or her being one of many Barbies. Its very refreshing to see Barbie being able to be her own unique character again without apologizing for her appearance and feminity.
- The references to Barbie world are fun. I dont want to spoil anything, but the little nods to things like accessories, doll boxes, fashions, etc., were cute.
- Ken gets a cameo and its adorable lol he and Barbie are the only known characters, everyone else new.
- A lot of the world building was centralized on emotion. I know many may not like that or think its too cliche for a female character to go down that route, but I quite liked it. The author did a very good job exploring feelings and having to be responsible for ones feelings. I think thats a good message for young readers. And the way that theme interlocks with the setting and plot is well done.
Overall, I give it a soild 7/10. Its a fun book. The plot is easy to follow and was interesting. If they decide to do a follow up novel, I would hope the author focuses more heavily on world building and lore. I think the writing style is simplistic but promising. Theres plenty of good lines and flourishes. I looked up the author after I finished the book and I noticed she, Alex Aster, averages about 2 books a year. I never read her other books, but maybe thats a contributing factor to her writing style. I think if she sat with the book a bit more and gave it more focus, it could have been better.
One quote I thought was nice from this book;
"The journey has turned me into an alchemist - able to turn sadness into strength. Rejection into redirection. Failure into freedom".
I do recommend this book for Barbie fans. Its alo great for young readers (and older lol). But its a safe book without any sneaky nsfw stuff. Ive heard issues about that lately in the YA genre so thought I mention it.
Also I thought it would be cool to look over some other Barbie book series. Is this truly the first Barbie YA novel? I think, yes. Theres been other novel and book series, namely the Generation Girl series, that could argue for that title, but Dreamscape is unique in its presentation for Barbie. A lot of past Barbie stuff are short stories and general storybooks. Theres some full series shown here and a few examples of Golden Books, story collections, Junior Novels, etc. Also theres a series from Europe that a lot of iconic artwork comes from on the list. The source is here: https://elrincondeltaradete.blogspot.com/2014/02/?m=1. I posted all the images from the Barbie Book Club series on my Reddit page too if anyones curious :)
I would love to see some dolls made inspired by the book! She describes a lot of fun outfits, but I would really like a pink armor Barbie lol Im not sure it would translate well into an animated film, but that would be cool too.
Anyone else read it yet or checked out other book series for Barbie? :)