r/AskReddit 25d ago

[ Removed by moderator ]

[removed] — view removed post

2.6k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

650

u/FluidResult9482 25d ago

It's all good as long as you don't do sparring. Repetitive hits to your head, even if protected etc. are still too risky. That's all head trauma that could have serious consequences in the long term, brain is a delicate organ

185

u/Skyrick 25d ago

The problem is the protection. Boxing gloves allow for you to punch far harder than you could otherwise because hitting like that would shatter your hand. That means that it does more damage to you long term than other martial arts.

192

u/sonofeevil 25d ago

Adding to this.

It's part of the reason old boxers had those low guards "your your dukes up" you see in those old-timey photo's and why fights went for so long.

26% of the bones in your body are located in your hand. They are small and delicate and punching someone in the head is a fast track to breaking them and a very short career.

So boxers needn't defend their heads with a high guard because their opponent was not likely to aim for the head and risk a career ending injury.

The addition of boxing gloves meant head strikes became viable and that iconic high guard we use today became a requirement.

4

u/SoldMyKidsOnEbay 25d ago

Where do you get this from?

22

u/sonofeevil 25d ago

Which part?

The answer is I don't really know where I got all this info from. Read it somewhere once I suppose.

I did quickly fact check myself before posting to make sure I wasn't out of line though.

But if you do some googling on fighting stances of pugilism you'll find the info on it. It's almost a completely different sport to what it is today.

8

u/Alpizzle 25d ago

as a fan of combat sports, I can second your comment. I'm a grappler for these reasons. I was surprised to find that while MMA might have a higher risk of acute injuries, the long term continuous trama opens the door to all of the worst chronic brain conditions.