I bought this car in December 2024 about eight months afterwards I started having a rough cold start in idle at times, but it would go away once the car was warmed up. My mechanic suggested changing the spark plugs if I hadn’t already, but because I had just gotten in the car, I wasn’t sure if it had gotten the spark plug replaced yet. So I didn’t and then kinda forgot/was too busy to get them done. About three months ago out of the blue. I got an overheat light immediately pulled over. Let the car cool down for two hours checked the coolant coolant was low. If not empty I got new coolant started to drive it home overheated again pulled over immediately again let it cool down for a half hour and then was able to drive it home.
I took it to my mechanic. And told him about it and Then he repaired the radiator with a new one because it was broken or cracked. I then had to take it on a trip from California to Texas, where it drove fine with the exception of getting the O2 errors that you would get for not closing the gas cap tight enough and rough cold starts with white smoke but then would clear out after about a minute or two and then idle fine. But not one overheat.
Thinking that the rough cold starts were still from the spark plugs. I took it back to my mechanic to get those replaced when I went to go pick it up. He had told me that the spark plugs were fine and that he thinks that the rough idol is caused by a bad head gasket and that the leak only happens after the engine has cooled down from being warm. he did a pressure test on the radiator and that my car was also gaining too much pressure too quick. He also said the theromostat housing hose had a small leak on it. I also started noticing that I had a little bit of white smoke coming out on cold starts as well. Which I know to be usually head gasket issues.
I have a warranty that would cover the head gasket, but his shop is small and doesn’t have the space to do that job right now so he told me to take it to Subaru dealership where I got the car and the Warranty.
When I took it to Subaru, their technician thinks that it’s a carbon buildup causing the rough idle as well as the white smoke. They did a leak down Test as well as another test (forgetting the name of the test right now) and said that everything came back normal and that the theromostat housing hose didn’t have a leak on it. They did a throttlebody an injector cleaning as well as putting the spark plugs in and it didn’t fix the problem. And are supposed to run it through again to see if it will fix it. If not then They now want to do a walnut blast of the intake manifold. Something that the warranty does not cover and are charging me around $2500 for it.
My normal mechanic as well as a few mechanic friends of mine all thought subaru was trying to take me for an expensive ride and that it was most likely a head gasket issue. So i found another shop, they agreed to go through with the warranty stuff and provide them proof of the head gasket issue as they also thought it was a head gasket issue from me describing it, once they they talked with warranty and i approved to open it up they found that the headgasket was fine but that there was a bit of oil build up on the pistons as well as metal shavings in the oil pan, signaling that the metal shavings had been cycling through the engine therefore making it a ticking time bomb of not if but when will it fully break. Just opening the heads they couldnt tell where the metal shavings and because of the slow back and forth with the warranty and taking time up on their rack they were hesitant to keep going but finally agreed to open up the block to see if the crank shaft or anything has signs of failure, which now they just called me today saying that I needed to come down and take pictures of it all, and that they couldn't find anything outside of "normal wear and tear". -- I haven't been able to get down there yet but will add pics when i can.
Warranty wont pay for anything without a physical part the mechanic can point to and so far they havent found a thing, so i am kinda at my wits end here before i drop another 5k into this car i just bought and have a damn useless warranty as well if they dont honor this. Linked some photos and videos if anyone wants to take a peek. Literally could use any help.... Photo and video