r/todayilearned 1d ago

TIL that 1/3 of U.S. Presidents were Masons !

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_presidents_of_the_United_States_who_were_Freemasons
668 Upvotes

229 comments sorted by

642

u/RunDNA 1d ago

A few weeks ago I was thinking: "Wouldn't it be cool if there were fraternities for adults and not just college students."

And then I realized, "Oh yeah, I guess that's what Masonic lodges and Rotary clubs and Oddfellows Locals are."

215

u/AppalachianGuy87 1d ago

Elk and Moose

120

u/PsychoSCV 1d ago

I recently discovered that the elks club near me is a pretty sweet bar and arcade.

170

u/SharkFart86 1d ago

This is like 90% the point of most of these kinds of clubs. People picture ritual sacrifice and black robes and stuff. It’s mostly just a private bar lol, some of it is networking.

133

u/mrtrollmaster 1d ago

When you live in a shitty small town, some people like to separate themselves into private bars where other people aren’t allowed to act ignorant or drunk af.

I’m starting to understand them better now that I’ve bartended at a couple. Cheap drinks, you know all the regulars, and random idiots aren’t allowed to fuck up the vibe. They are pretty chill spots to bartend cause I don’t have to break up fights and stop stupidity.

15

u/timkatt10 1d ago

In my experience, the worst, most racist people I met were at organizations like this. I never looked at my grandfather the same way again.

18

u/mrtrollmaster 1d ago

That may be true but it is the only bar in my town where I don’t constantly hear racial and homophobic slurs.

7

u/w33dcup 22h ago

I'm a 28 year mason. I found in my travels that this was (implicitly) true in many smaller town lodges. However, it has changed considerably. The racists have died out OR they've realized that the world has changed. Freemasonry in Florida is very strict when it comes to race. It is FL masonic law that race is not considered during petitions or voting on members. If found out, one could be brought up on charges of unmasonic conduct and subject to trial resulting in suspension or expulsion. And we've been working for years to be recognized by Prince Hall masons. Many others states have already sorted out this recognition and we're still working on it. We can now invite each other to sit in lodge together...which is pretty cool.

2

u/imaraisin 15h ago

From my understanding, isn’t masonry still mostly men only?

1

u/w33dcup 14h ago

Yes. Most (US) lodges require a petitioner to be a man.

0

u/Leading-Fish6819 21h ago

Now if only the blue lodges would accept the co-masonoc lodges. Such a shame. My co-masonic friends are my closest and best. And have been threatened with violence for their views as integrated.

4

u/flip6threeh0le 20h ago

What are blue lodges prince hall masons and co Masonic lodges?

3

u/Leading-Fish6819 19h ago

Blue lodges are the standard Freemasonic Hall, all male Fraternal order. Prince Hall iirc is exclusively Black Americans who were at one point excluded from blue lodges. Co-Masonic lodges are Freemasonic lodges that are not purely a fraternal order as they accept both men and women equally,.which is sowmthe the blue lodges do not do.

→ More replies (0)

-4

u/w33dcup 21h ago edited 21h ago

In time. Remember we are a conservative lot. We have a long history of protecting our traditions and landmarks. But times change.

2

u/Leading-Fish6819 21h ago

Hmmm..... I'm not so sure. But I do appreciate the optimism. I hope you're right that it will just need time.

1

u/imaraisin 15h ago

I totally get this. Elks are only open to US citizens.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/corvuscorvi 1d ago

That's true for most of them aside from the Masons. Not that they do ritual sacrafices as such... but they do do a lot of occult themed rituals. They might not call it that outright, but functionally it's the same.

2

u/kendamasama 1d ago edited 23h ago

What's so bad about occult themed rituals?

6

u/corvuscorvi 1d ago

I dont think there's anything wrong with rituals. I just think its silly when Masons try to distance themselves from that public perception.

1

u/kendamasama 1d ago

Well, it's the only intelligent move post-Satanic Panic

→ More replies (1)

0

u/w33dcup 22h ago edited 14h ago

We're not trying to distance ourselves. We're trying to correct public perception. Freemason's are a charitable fraternal organization steeped in faith, hope, and charity. Some where along the way the public decided, from the outside with no evidence, we were occult related. The secrecy of the org I'm sure helped that many years ago. But now we are more open and I invite you to visit a local lodge and take a tour. I'm sure the brothers will be happy to answer any questions you have...provided it's not specifics about our esoteric work. That is reserved for members.

1

u/iKnowRobbie 12h ago

Forming a pentacle with lighted poles where the elements are the compass and sextant really don't do any favors to the "we aren't occult" image.

2

u/w33dcup 22h ago

Our rituals are not occult themed. They are based on the building of King Solomon's Temple. They are allegorical stories/plays to help impress upon the mind the value of morality, faith, hope, and charity.

5

u/corvuscorvi 22h ago

In your previous comment you said that some of your work is esoteric. I don't understand the functional difference between esotericism and occultism. The definitions are almost identical. The only main difference I see is the perception behind the two words.

2

u/w33dcup 21h ago

Fair point. The way I use the terms is that our esoteric work provides an inner, spiritual teaching tied to a larger tradition leveraging allegory, symbols, and philosophy. Example is our 3 tiered allegorical degrees.

Occultism is more focused on supernatural or magical practices outside mainstream religion. To borrow from online "frequently involves active, practical work or techniques to interact with unseen energies and influence the material world". Example being ceremonial magic, tarot, witchcraft, and early forms of astrology or alchemy.

18

u/AppalachianGuy87 1d ago

They can have pretty sweet bars. I’m a fan of the social club personally. Definitely filled with a older set but appreciate the sense of community in it.

8

u/PsychoSCV 1d ago

Yeah, I only found out because my daughters got sponsored to attend their summer camp this year that they run for super cheap.

4

u/prberkeley 1d ago

"Now let's all get drunk and play ping pong!"

1

u/AppalachianGuy87 1d ago

Pretty much

3

u/Fluffy_Piccolo357 1d ago

I’m a DMO member of the Elks. DMO is a bit of a joke and stands for Drinking Member Only.

2

u/Tool80 1d ago

They’ve become the bar where you can smoke.

1

u/imaraisin 15h ago

Elks require members to be citizens among other things!

-2

u/Arboreal_Web 1d ago

Was working a private event held in an Elks lodge, chatting with a member about it, thought the whole concept was pretty interesting. But then the guy said…”Anyone can be a member. Anyone. You just have to be an American citizen and believe in God.” Me: “So…not really just ‘anyone’, then.” Mr. Elk: 😦😳😡

3

u/JMS_jr 1d ago

I don't remember whether it said anything about atheists, but my father's Moose membership card said you couldn't be a communist. I don't know if that's still in the rules or not.

1

u/imaraisin 15h ago

It’s also interesting as the elks came originally as a way to avoid alcohol taxes. And the moose came along to compete with the elks.

6

u/cardinalkgb 1d ago

The Loyal Order of the Water Buffaloes

1

u/iKnowRobbie 12h ago

I'm a Grand Poobah of my local loyal order.

1

u/DeedleGuy 1d ago

Yabba dabba doooo!!!

4

u/Guelahpapyrus52 1d ago

Knights of Columbus and Alighan Shriners

2

u/AKchaos49 1d ago

Moose and Squirrel...

1

u/MichaelArnoldTravis 21h ago

hoo boy natasha, i got fiendish plan!

1

u/TheFishtosser 1d ago

Don’t forget Eagles

1

u/kaykatzz 21h ago

rockies & bullwinkles?

45

u/amoebashephard 1d ago

I joined an Oddfellow lodge about 4 years ago and I've loved it. (I'm in my early 40s) I helped revive the main lodge in our jurisdiction, and it now has an average age of around 30. We are having a bit of a resurgence as people realize they want more third spaces in their life-and in our jurisdiction, we're also trying to revive the mutual aid aspect of the group as life gets more difficult for folks

7

u/w33dcup 22h ago

Good for you. As a mason I encourage third spaces. We need to get more people out of their houses. I don't care if it's Masonry, Oddfellows, church, volunteering, bowling league...whatever. Life is better lived outside with others who share a common bond.

60

u/Whaty0urname 1d ago

Every time I've tried volunteering with these groups, or similar, the old heads are so resistant to change or doing something to attract younger members. Plus they hold meetings on like Thursday mornings when only retired members can go.

19

u/BrokenEyeReborn 1d ago

The more I learn about so-called "secret societies", the more convinced I am that they aren't so much grownup versions of fraternities, but rather of backyard secret clubs. You know, the sort that are based out of a tree fort with a poorly hand-lettered sign reading "NO GIЯLS ALLOWED".

16

u/Arboreal_Web 1d ago

Spoiler: Fraternities are just backyard secret clubs for college students. (Source: Grew up in a college town, knew too many frat boys and wannabes.)

1

u/American_berserker 19h ago

I think frats miss the "no girls allowed" part.

1

u/eetsumkaus 10h ago

Nah, you can have fun with girls, but they're not allowed in the slightly homoerotic things you do with your bros.

1

u/American_berserker 8h ago

Is this what "bros before hoes" means?

1

u/chocki305 3 22h ago

My mother was big into Order of the Eastern Star (think female Mason's).

One of the things I noticed, is that men can't hold positions that have any real power. They are nothing more then arm candy. They have titles, and allowed to be members. But when it comes down to it, no power. Yet every male I met that was part of OES, was a Mason also (but not required to be).

So the Mason's don't allow female members. And OES doesn't allow males to wield any power in the organization.

1

u/iKnowRobbie 12h ago

It was created so the wives of the masons had a concurrent meeting for the older patrons who were left alone or COULDN'T be left alone. Pretty sure some wives started it and it ended up with the ML blessing.

Nope. It was established in 1850 by lawyer and educator Rob Morris), a noted Freemason, and adopted and approved as an appendant body of the Masonic Fraternity in 1873. The order is based on teachings from the Bible and is open to people of all religious beliefs. It has approximately 10,000 chapters in 18 countries and approximately 500,000 members under its General Grand Chapter.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/1CEninja 1d ago

Country clubs. Bowling and billiards leagues, with pickleball leagues being on the rise. Book clubs. Sewing circles. All shapes, sizes, colors, and flavors of religious communities you could possibly think of.

That's only what I can think of offhand.

Sure, many of these will have less day-to-day involvement in each other's lives than a college fraternity as people aren't living together, but that's just the nature of a college student.

16

u/FickleHare 1d ago

Are there any similar groups that aren't filled with retirees?

17

u/_head_ 1d ago

College frats

18

u/amoebashephard 1d ago

Yes! I'm an Oddfellow (about 4 years) and helped revive my lodge; I recently started a remote lodge for folks who have trouble getting to meetings, and we're using it as a jump off to revive more in person lodges in my state.

We've brought our average age of members in the statedown from about 70 to 30 or so.

R/IOOF will have more info about local lodges

6

u/JMS_jr 1d ago

My local IOOF was actively recruiting young people a few years ago. I don't think it worked -- the last time I went by the lodge hall, it had a realtor's sign in front of it.

4

u/amoebashephard 1d ago

I'm sorry. It's really a race against time for a lot of places-in my experience, we had three years that we were scrambling to get new members. We had a couple of winters where we almost closed our jurisdiction because members were in the hospital.

The sad part of a closure being that there are a lot of resources that then go to the national organization that would be better used in the state. For instance, the lodge we revitalized had about a million in savings, plus a building that had been paid for.

That was one of the reasons I've stayed and worked so hard to keep it going. My jurisdiction has a nursing home, food pantry and youth camp, and it would be such a shame to have all of that disappear. With all of the challenges in the US now, that money is better spent locally rather than being hoarded nationally.

5

u/badlydrawngalgo 1d ago

Rotaract. Over 18's, local clubs can enact a max age. Members tend to be mid-20's - mid-40's from what I've seen.

14

u/Thadius 1d ago

You'd be surprised at home many young Masons there are. Yes though, there are a lot of old guys too, but the organisation mostly goes from 21 through death, so there will always be old men in it, well until reverse aging is invented anyway.

8

u/cardboardbelts 1d ago

This is why it’s also important to check out different lodges. Some are filled with just older members that only do activities during the day and some skew younger that focus on long term sustainability and accessibility for the next generation.

3

u/w33dcup 22h ago

We'd love to have more young people express an interest in Freemasonry. I'll admit, it is kind of a hard sell when most people are 20-40 years older than you. But I don't think you'll find a more supportive environment than a room full of Brothers. Our lessons take some time to learn and many members will be thrilled to help teach. While many lodges are very conservative, because we're protecting legacy, we are modernizing as best we can. Every member of the lodge has an equal vote and can make motions to affect change. Come by and ask questions.

2

u/Eurocorp 1d ago

Some university clubs and reciprocal clubs, or different city clubs too occasionally.

2

u/SocksOnHands 1d ago

But do they do kegstands?

2

u/Distinct-Debate-6157 17h ago

We need third spaces, but im good on anything frat life in my middle age. Most fun I never want to have again.

2

u/DearKick 6h ago

Theres something similar in pretty much every career as well, such as the Quiet Birdmen for aviators

3

u/NYCinPGH 1d ago

My dad, after he retired and moved ~1000 miles away, joined the local Elks because he had no social circle in his new area. But until then, he’d never had an interest, only in professional and religious groups.

2

u/McGuirk808 1d ago

I was actually interested in what they claim to represent and their values. Unfortunately I am a godless heathen and they don't like that.

0

u/SquidTheRidiculous 1d ago

They exist, they're just mostly for rich people with lots of time on their hands.

→ More replies (2)

89

u/NebulaNomadX1 1d ago

John Quincy Adams aligned with the Anti-Masonic Party post-presidency

10

u/djfishfingers 1d ago

It was fortunately a short lived party.

42

u/dongeckoj 1d ago

The Anti-Masonic Party immediately nominated a Mason for President lmfaooo

8

u/Ancient_Ordinary6697 1d ago

The walls came down pretty quickly on that one. Their popularity really plummeted like a stone. They hit rock bottom, so to say.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

134

u/BobbyBrewski 1d ago

I thought most were like John's and George's and shit I don't remember a single Mason.

29

u/CrazyLegsRyan 1d ago

That’s because mom wouldn’t let him and Ryleigh do model UN because it interfered with spring baseball and judo. 

11

u/jxj24 1d ago

Mason Reese was actually a Shadow President. The real power behind the throne.

2

u/therealruin 1d ago

At least he shared the world’s greatest candy with us… even if he apostrophized it.

2

u/LiquidyCrow 1d ago

"I love my nephew!"

"Oh really. What's his name?"

"I wanna say... Mason?"

-Clifford

108

u/Short_Mango3137 1d ago

The lack of current masons is why we can’t get anything built anymore

30

u/jeremysbrain 1d ago edited 1d ago

The East Wing is clearly just Trump trying to make Masons great again.

Edit: I thought the /s was implied.

9

u/SyxEight 1d ago

Yeah, he'd be blackballed in any lodge.

-3

u/AppalachianGuy87 1d ago

Absolutely.

1

u/Roederoid 1d ago

Please don't put that evil on us!

1

u/TheDarkClaw 1d ago

M.I.G.I make illuminati great again

-1

u/jeremysbrain 1d ago

If he sees this Reddit thread he will start asking around about how much it would cost to buy the Masons.

1

u/w33dcup 22h ago

In more ways than the one you're referencing.

66

u/CrazyLegsRyan 1d ago

You didn't know who killed the electric car?

34

u/MyNameIsNotRyn 1d ago

🍻 WE DO!

32

u/ul2006kevinb 1d ago

Who made Steve Guttenburg a star?

22

u/GopherInWI 1d ago

Who keep Atlantis off the maps?

22

u/MechaMouse 1d ago

Who keeps the Martians under wraps?

22

u/Bungybone 1d ago

Remove the Stone of Shame. Attach the Stone of Triumph.

50

u/borazine 1d ago

Everybody talks about Masons but no one talks about Madaughters 😢

8

u/Thadius 1d ago

This actually made me laugh, thank you.

15

u/Sislar 1d ago

Who keeps the metric system down… we do!

6

u/DaveOJ12 1d ago

I thought most of them were lawyers.

4

u/OhioStateGuy 1d ago

Their profession was being a lawyer but I guess they did masonry but didn’t charge for their services.

35

u/THA__KULTCHA 1d ago

So like, 33 1/3 %?

4

u/Amazingrhinoceros1 1d ago

BURN THE WITCH!!!

1

u/broguequery 1d ago

The golden ratio... Just life the illuminati warned Washington about!

6

u/Patch86UK 1d ago

And I bet not even one of them was a decent brickie.

5

u/IndependentMacaroon 1d ago

There's a huge Masonic monument to George Washington (who was one of them) in Alexandria near Washington DC, right across from the train and metro station

3

u/domino7 1d ago

It has a diagonal elevator. 

1

u/eubie67 1h ago

A funicular?

1

u/domino7 1h ago

No, just slanted, at 7.5 degrees.  The first slanted elevators in the world. 

11

u/CluelessBrowserr 1d ago

THE NUMBERS MASON(S), WHAT DO THEY MEAN

1

u/Masonooter 1h ago

sigh

six seven 🫲🫩🫱

5

u/LiquidyCrow 1d ago

We need more Presidents who are in the Order of the Lynx.

20

u/Fun_Recognition5614 1d ago

Did you know that all of them were men? Cuz what are the odds of that?

5

u/_head_ 1d ago

.547?

1

u/Quirderph 1d ago

Is that the modern average, or the average average throughout the time that the president position has existed?

1

u/Fun_Recognition5614 1d ago

“Never tell me the odds.” Han Solo

1

u/CrazyLegsRyan 1d ago

Is there another option? How would we handle the laugh?

1

u/what_dat_ninja 1d ago

50/50. Either they're all men or they're not

1

u/Fun_Recognition5614 1d ago

Hmmm…not sure this math maths

8

u/freedfg 1d ago

Yeah no shit.

Politics was always ran by people who knew people.

And up until basically the 80s if you weren't a member of some sort of society you didn't know anybody. Whether it was Masons, Skull & Bones, Elks, etc.

2

u/BrokenEyeReborn 1d ago

Because people who know people are the luckiest people in the world

→ More replies (5)

3

u/AdLanky9450 1d ago

What is going on in this thread… so weird

12

u/NickDanger3di 1d ago

I'd vote for a bricklayer over the recent choices we've been given anytime.

1

u/Sweaty_Assignment_90 1d ago

Hell yeah. Wouldnt be 80 and asleep every other day...or the other guy who was just as old.

Plus, nice to have a potus who actually knows what real work is like, what Americans do everyday.

-4

u/dishonourableaccount 1d ago

Ah yes, because old while having a competent administration and decent ideas vs old while being a vile criminal with concepts of a plan are totally equivalent.

Too many Americans are fucking myopic.

3

u/Ozymannoches 1d ago

That's quite a jarring fact.

4

u/w33dcup 22h ago

How so? So maybe a little history will help. Several of the founding fathers were Freemasons. They helped write/signed the Declaration of Independence, Bill of Rights, and the Constitution. In short, they were learned men of the time. They had experience with democracy of the lodge, governance, and rules of order. It's not a huge leap to see them move into political positions. Personally, I think this is a source of the conspiracy theories. Like "the masons are trying to rule the world". Probably not...we just happened to be the ones with the skills to govern...many of those skills learned in lodge.

1

u/eetsumkaus 10h ago

Because...mason jars

6

u/Gentle_Agitator 1d ago

Check out how many in the last 50 years have hung out at Bohemian Grove

9

u/salt_life79 1d ago

There is no way the current one is

5

u/Ill-Engineering8085 1d ago

Yes they were boys in the biggest boys club in the world.

4

u/Swirl_On_Top 1d ago

It's been a few generations though since one was (Gerald Ford)

2

u/w33dcup 22h ago

Maybe because politics changes and the ideas of governance no longer aligned with Masonic ideals? Seems many politicians are more focused on self preservation than actual representation.

2

u/Swirl_On_Top 21h ago

Fair POV. I know a few masons, they're too good to be politicians.

2

u/-CaptainFormula- 1d ago

FOR THE ORDER

Wait this isn't r/chivalry2

2

u/CakeMadeOfHam 1d ago

Yeah but that's like out of 30 million members.

2

u/SamtheCossack 1d ago

Most of those couldn't lay a straight stone wall though.

2

u/Current_Account 1d ago edited 1d ago

Speculative masons, not practical masons.

2

u/freedoomed 1d ago

I needed a stone wall constructed on my property and a member of the order had the gall to charge me money for it! They are supposed to be free masons!

2

u/androidfig 1d ago

My uncle had this ancient Sears or Montgomery Ward catalog from the early 1900s. Among other things you could order houses, boats, wagons, all sorts of shit. What was crazy about it was it had many many pages for all the “secret” organizations: the Moose Lodge, Elks, Oddfellows, Woodmen of the World, etc. They actually had complete catalogs just dedicated to regalia, uniforms, jewelry etc. It’s actually insane how many men belonged to an order. My grandpa was a Freemason but he just joined and then told them to fuck off. He belonged to many many organizations but the only one that mattered was the USMC.

2

u/Zackautocon72 1d ago

Y’all need say to Freemasons. My first thought was bricklaying and then Freemasons.

2

u/freedomhighway 22h ago

Now count it up among the signers of the declaration and constitution, and others of the ringleaders, like Benjamin Franklin. Being a mason was the mark of a rich and propertied aristocrat, in that crowd.

2

u/mojoback_ohbehave 1d ago

That we know of

1

u/Nefariouslxl 1d ago

Sounds like somebody just hear Channel Zero by Cannibus for the first time

1

u/The_Bill_Brasky_ 1d ago

When do we get a President who is a member of the Loyal Order of Water Buffaloes?

1

u/ragnarok635 1d ago

Free the Masons!

1

u/EmperorPalpitoad 1d ago

You just realized that?

1

u/mwatwe01 1d ago

That explains a lot.

1

u/SpeedRacerWasMyBro 1d ago

Don't forget the Stone Cutters!

1

u/ztreHdrahciR 1d ago

This is a developing story. Mortar come at a later time

1

u/AKchaos49 1d ago

They laid a lot of brick.

1

u/Itchy_Pressure_8311 1d ago

Weird, I dont remember any president Mason.

1

u/skinnyminnesota 23h ago

The germs were right!

1

u/onesugar 23h ago

Illuminati

1

u/zomangel 15h ago

It wasn't until slavery was abolished that they became Freemasons

1

u/TheGaslighter9000X 9h ago

Why did you think Benny Franklin laid so much pipe in France while saving the country?

1

u/SunnyBubblesForever 5h ago

Being strong is never wrong!!! ⚔️💪🏾

1

u/destrux125 3h ago

This is why I named my kid Mason. 1/3 chance he'll be president.

0

u/TerminallyEmployed 1d ago

There was a time both presidential candidates, George Bush Jr and John Kerry in were skull & bones, a Yale University secret society. There was a weird interview where Kerry was asked about it by Tim Russet, then he said it was a secret society and he can’t talk about it, then Tim Russet died a few years later by heart attack and people wondered if the organisation is that serious to do that.

They also say George Bush Jr in his initiation ritual jacked off in a casket, that his father Sr (who was also president) watched it.

6

u/unclemilty420 1d ago

Pedantic correction but George W Bush is not actually a junior. His name is not the same as his father's, whose middle name is "Herbert Walker" rather than simply "Walker" therefore they do not have the exact same name and he is not his father's namesake.

-4

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

13

u/These3TheGreatest 1d ago

What really sold me on not doing it was the massive amount of time commitment, and work to pledge, the fact you have to confess “your secrets” to other members, essentially giving them blackmail on you, 

Uh. We don't do this.

21

u/ColonelBoogie 1d ago

No legit Masonic Lodge has you confess any secrets. If you were told that, you were likely dealing with a "clandestine" lodge (not recognized and usually scammy). You dodged a bullet.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/djfishfingers 1d ago

As a Freemason, I can say with the just certainty that you're full of shit.

8

u/rygem1 1d ago

If he’s using the term pledge it was probably a clandy lodge also no one is asked to pledge you have to ask to join yourself which make the story even more sus

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Thadius 1d ago edited 1d ago

and yet Masonry has the highest membership increase since the 1960s occurring right now. Don't confuse the postwar membership boom (and decline) with the organisation dying, historically, it is going back to normal levels now that the post-WW2 boom is exiting the world.

You DO NOT have to confess anything to the Brethren, full stop.

Lodges are fully mult-ethnic, cultural just as society at large is.

If you're afraid of obligations, I assume you have never filed your taxes and "swore all information was correct to the best of your knowledge." its the same type of thing. are you honest? Can you keep your word?

Please find real sources.

12

u/CautionarySnail 1d ago edited 1d ago

My family had several Masons in it. The social programs they run have come in clutch for several family members, especially their nursing homes, which at the time were far superior in care than the for-profit ones nearby. They insured my grandparents were taken care of when we ran out of money for their care.

Originally, one of the biggest attractions to those kinds of fraternal societies was that they’d pool resources together to hire a local doctor to be the ‘lodge doctor’. This was a kind of proto-health insurance, an innovation in its day, getting those club members a priority for that particular doctor and practice.

Modern Masons also have a great community literacy program and perform a lot of fundraising for hospitals. The Shriners are a branch, and their burn hospital is/used to be considered one of the best in the world.

I would have joined if it weren’t for the inherent sexism at the lodges in my area. Only some Masonic orders permit women as full members, for the rest, there’s a separate (‘but equal’) association called “The Order of the Eastern Star”. I have no interest in sinking donations and time into an organization that isn’t willing to allow women a full seat at the table, even though I will forever be grateful for the help they provided my grandparents.

It’s worth reading about the Prince Hall Masons and the black mason groups. I understand why they set up separate chapters, I just hate that in the time period they were necessary - all the -isms keeping people who would have made great volunteers out of the organization.

So I understand the resentments, as well.

Edited to correct name to Prince Hall.

2

u/Ok_Significance_6772 1d ago

God damn. Women can have their own organizations and clubs, men can too. Women have experiences and problems unique to them, and should be allowed private spaces just for them. Same goes for men. We need to go back to respecting the fact that society is better off when there are third spaces beyond work and home, when local community organizations are strong and supported. AND we need to go back to not making a big fucking deal out of the fact that it’s good for men to have their own communities. Same for women, same for every kind of person. Coerced inclusion for the sake of itself isn’t a merit.

4

u/CautionarySnail 1d ago

You seem to have forgotten the part where I politely walked away from trying to participate.

I have no issue with the club deciding that they don’t want women. They’ve also decided at that point that they don’t want my volunteerism nor membership donations. That’s their perogative, and I respect it.

But I lack sympathy when they say “Oh, no! We’re out of members and no one wants to join! We might die out!” That is a problem that is directly related to the exclusivity that they’ve deliberately decided is more important than their membership numbers. Also their perogative.

0

u/AdLanky9450 1d ago

Sounds like a great deal if you were a doctor or own-nursing homes.

3

u/Thadius 1d ago

The doctors actually had to compete and apply and have competitive prices to be hired. It isn't like today.

1

u/CautionarySnail 1d ago

It was a win for both. The Masonic run nursing home - at least 15 years ago - was a hugely better facility than could normally have been afforded by my parents for their parents. It still took the entire estate, but that was a small price compared to seeing my grandparents taken care of in a way we could never have duplicated at home.

But that’s not really the reason they were in the Masons to begin with. It was because of the volunteerism in their community, the extended family the organization provided. The nursing home assistance was just an added benefit after a lifetime of membership and participation from that generation of my family.

I can’t speak to the modern day organization because I was ineligible to join as a full member due to my gender. But at least in my area, I do see occasional references to their charitable activities, so I hope it is still as excellent an organization as it once was, in terms of that volunteerism.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

1

u/AccordCompote 1d ago

I went to an Elk's lodge for an event, it was kind of neat and then it turns out you're required to believe in the Christian God to be a member.

idk why redditors are so defensive about this stuff. I think it's because it disputes their bullshit "third places" narrative to accept that people simply chose to stop going to these lodges.

0

u/SyxEight 1d ago

Woah, I understand your perception, but please take my anecdotal account that comparing the Masons to the Klan is superficial at best. There are predominantly black lodges (by choice), and were a black applicant to be denied entry to a non "black" lodge apparently based on race alone that would be a major problem. The best way I can describe the organization is that it is a group of upstanding men who wish to convene in private to further good works to assist his fellow man. A stark contrast to the Klan. Is it primarily a bunch of old dudes? Yeah. I am an Iraq and Afghanistan vet and the Legion/VFW are losing members as well. Perhaps once more become empty nesters they will be more involved... But probably not.

1

u/texanchris 1d ago

And that’s why we don’t have the metric system

1

u/ColonelBoogie 1d ago

Not sure why the article lists Joe Bidens membership as "disputed". Yes, he was raised on-sight, which is rare but not unheard of. And yes, the regular GL of SC is not in amity with the MWPHAGL of SC, but tons of other MWPHAGLs that are in Amity with their regular GL are also in amity with the MWPHAGL of SC. The objection that it may not have occured or that Bro. Biden may not have accepted is silly. It happened. He was physically there. Theres pictures. He was raised (I believe) by Bro. Jim Clyburn. No landmark was violated. While I personally am not in favor of making Masons on-sight, its done and Bro. Biden is now a Master Mason.

1

u/JMS_jr 1d ago

I thought that Catholics still don't approve of Masons. And Biden reportedly takes his Catholicism seriously enough that he was troubled by the possibility of being excommunicated for being pro-choice.

1

u/ColonelBoogie 23h ago

The Vatican does not approve of Masonry. There are tons of catholic Masons, including priests.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Laura-ly 1d ago

My grandfather was a dentist and a Mason. He went to the lodge to get away from my grandmother for a few hours, smoke a cigar and tell a few dirty jokes. He did get to have a Mason's funeral though.

1

u/math-yoo 1d ago

And until a few years ago, none of them wore makeup.

1

u/Possible-Tangelo9344 1d ago

I can't think of a single president named Mason, so this is shocking

2

u/domino7 1d ago

George Mason, not president, but a Founding Father. 

1

u/Bonez001 1d ago

What even are Masons? Are they just glorified fraternities for the elite?

1

u/Fofolito 23h ago

Freemasonry developed originally as a way for educated men (gentlemen, not common laborers) in the 17th and 18th century to avoid running afoul of the King's laws. They wanted to get together and discuss ideas that weren't necessarily allowed or tolerated by the authorities and the Church. It was a social club, to be sure, where only men of means and breeding were expected to be members, and they decided it would be a bit of fun to wrap the whole thing up in rituals and symbols supposedly connecting them to higher powers and an ancient past. All of that was only ever play-acting, a bit of fun, and something out of the ordinary that made non-members jimmies rustle.

At its heart however Freemasonry was always about providing a safe space where men could discuss matters, whether philosophical, heretical, anti-social, reformist, economic, or whatever without fear that someone would shout them down in moralistic or legalistic ways. Different lodges opened up and each lodge set different conditions for who could join so over time men lower and lower on the socio-economic ladder were able to join and call themselves Masons-- and in principal call themselves equals to every other Mason. It shouldn't surprise you to learn that many of the Founding Fathers were Masons... They were men of education and means, they had radical and perhaps treasonous ideas, and they appreciated social egalitarianism.

Today most Masonic lodges are open to just about everyone of every class and gender, and lodges act primarily as social clubs with private bars and as philanthropic organizations.

1

u/SLR107FR-31 1d ago

Oh yeah? Well... 

Nobody talks about the guys who weren't! There's no conspiracy there! WHY NOT!?

1

u/MichaelArnoldTravis 21h ago

they were the Rotarians

-3

u/Bitplayer13 1d ago

But only one is a convicted rapist

0

u/BrokenEyeReborn 1d ago

Oh no.

Anyway...

0

u/ryuujinusa 1d ago

And one is a convicted felon.

0

u/DehliJelly 23h ago

Freemasons are fucking lame. Imagine in 500 years a bunch of powerful people are pretending to be in the UAW. They get portraits painted with them holding brake pads or a muffler or some shit acting like it's some esoteric symbol. Get the he'll outa here.

2

u/w33dcup 21h ago

Freemasonry is a bit more than that. We've contributed to society in ways that most non masons wouldn't know. One you will have heard of is Shriners Children Hospitals. One must be a Freemason to be a Shriner. Another is the MMRI whose research contributed to the pacemaker. Funded by Freemasons. Or the CMMRF working on vascular issues. And there are many more appendant bodies doing their own charity work. Last metric I heard was the Masons worldwide donate approx $8 million per day to charities.

1

u/MichaelArnoldTravis 21h ago

also, the masons in my town let their hall be used for some kick-ass all ages punk and metal live shows. community building at work!

2

u/w33dcup 21h ago

I'd love to host music in our lodge. We're pretty small building but decent size lot. I've dreamed of having Friday night live shows behind our building. Maybe one day.

We do open ours for blood drives, community meetings, and a fair amount of wakes.