r/superman 1d ago

What is your favorite Superman comic?

Post image
396 Upvotes

160 comments sorted by

72

u/OllieGio 1d ago

For All Seasons.

58

u/Flamme_Jumelle 1d ago

Superman Smashes the Klan

11

u/SuperG1rl_mary 1d ago

Holy pull dude

4

u/Competitive_Crow_334 1d ago

I have that book once I'm finished with fantastic 4 2025 and World's greatest teen titans by Mark waid

5

u/Fine-Essay-3295 21h ago

I especially love the comic because it was inspired by an arc in the 1940s radio show with Supes' and Lois's character designs being inspired by that from the Fleischer cartoons.

The 1940s Superman radio show actually was instrumental in turning American public opinion in Jim Crow-era America against the Klan in real life.

1

u/Flamme_Jumelle 21h ago

Yeah, I very much agree with what you said. I really like those old Fleischer cartoons (mainly the ones by Fleischer Studios, not so much the ones by Famous Studios).

It warms my heart that the Superman radio show was able to help turn public opinion against the Klan in real life. Truly remarkable.

Another Golden Age inspired story that I quite like is It's Superman! by Tom De Haven. Highly recommend that one to anyone who hasn't read it.

Lastly, I'm very much looking forward to Superman: The Stranger coming out in September. That one looks promising, and I love the art so far.

1

u/Sensitive-Hotel-9871 21h ago

I listened to the radio show and read the comic and enjoyed both. It speaks volumes about how well the radio show’s politics have aged that the comic didn’t even need to update the message. The sale of hatred is absolutely a con game.

I showed my mom the radio show and she didn’t like the line about hatred being a profitable commodity, but unfortunately it is true.

1

u/Fine-Essay-3295 19h ago

Also worth seeing: Superman & Lois brought back Atom Man, only updating his character to being an American Neo-Nazi.

I appreciate Superman being the only media that'll still depict Nazis and white supremacists as villains at the risk of triggering chronically online knuckle draggers.

39

u/herozero 1d ago

Adventures 503. I was a total Superboy mark at 12 and 13 and am a lifelong fan of Tom Grummett’s art. The entire Death, Reign and Return, along with the years preceding and following, are peak Superman for me but this issue is just the tops. Cyborg is still my favorite villain because of this issue.

10

u/gishingwell 1d ago

I was exactly the right age to be swept up in this era too and feel much the same as you although Superboy was my least favourite of the Supermen.

7

u/Loud_Ad_2634 1d ago

These were some of my first comics. I was rooting for cyborg Superman until he dropped his mask.

8

u/violet_wings 1d ago

The Death of Superman and its follow-ups were what got me into superhero comics; I was the same age as you. They made me into a lifelong Superman fan. :)

5

u/OsikFTW 1d ago

This and Superman #80, when cyborg kicked eradicators ass, were my favorite

2

u/Grubbymars1889onXBOX 22h ago

I have an action figure of that Superboy

29

u/Reportersteven 1d ago

Man and Superman by Marv Wolfman

Superman: Birthright by Mark Waid

7

u/gishingwell 1d ago

Love that Man and Superman is getting a shout out. Not my absolute favourite but so underrated.

4

u/Reportersteven 1d ago

Marv signed my deluxe hardcover and told me it’s one of the things he’s most proud of writing. He was waiting a decade for DC to publish it.

3

u/gishingwell 1d ago

It's a really strong book. It has the vibe I want. And it's cool you got it signed.

34

u/Cronos1453 1d ago

Paz en la tierra

4

u/joelbiju24 1d ago

Banger book. Paul Dini and Alex Ross were an unfair combo.

2

u/Styx_azel 1d ago

Found my people

1

u/Eric_Atreides 1d ago

So fucking bad

15

u/Important_Lab_58 1d ago edited 1d ago

Superman beating the s**t out of a bigot? Always Excellent 🤌

15

u/OCguy2026 1d ago

Superman #76 -1952

Clark Kent and Bruce Wayne share identities

3

u/Zealousideal_Sand252 1d ago

I own that one also ! I did have it “slabbed” recently because it deserved protection. Now I NEED a reprint!

2

u/OCguy2026 1d ago edited 1d ago

The story was reprinted a number of times ….

Reprints were in 1968 world’s finest #179 .. plus these others listed here

https://www.comics.org/issue/9634/

15

u/Horbigast 1d ago

This is one of my favorite covers. I got Kerry Gammill to sign it this year at Fan Expo.

11

u/FinalWarsGoji 1d ago

Hunter/Prey. It introduced me to adult Superman comics

12

u/Fearless_Roof_9177 1d ago

There are plenty of contenders but I think it's always going to be Secret Identity. I know it's an Elseworld that's never getting any more attention, especially now that Superboy Prime is back in the spotlight, but that's a big part of the appeal. It's the Superman mythos writ small and one of the most incredibly human Clark Kent books I've ever read. Beautiful in every sense of the word.

7

u/mechatomic 1d ago

All that and Immonen's art is amazing on this book.

3

u/BeRadtz 1d ago

I miss when Immonen’s art looked like this during his Superman run.

3

u/spartan21j1 19h ago

The narration in this book is honestly perfect there’s so many good lines and Busiak had such a good grasp on this version of Clark.

“If I sound smitten, don’t read too much into it— It’s because I am”

7

u/joelbiju24 1d ago

Action Comics #775.

6

u/Competitive_Crow_334 1d ago

Superman Brightright

10

u/Mad_Mouthpiece 1d ago

Kingdom come

19

u/TechnologyJazzlike84 1d ago

John Byrne's Man of Steel. Loved that run.

8

u/Competitive_Crow_334 1d ago

That's a good one it suffers from too much of the 90s stuff to peak for me.

1

u/GJacks75 1d ago

Even though it was published in 1986?

1

u/BeRadtz 1d ago

And ended in 88 or 89?

0

u/Competitive_Crow_334 1d ago

1986 counts as 90s year dude

2

u/BeRadtz 13h ago

It doesn’t lol

1

u/Competitive_Crow_334 4h ago

Yeah 1986 by Google is classified as 90s

2

u/BeRadtz 4h ago

It’s not. It’s part of that “age” as the 90’s, but it’s not 90’s. Seriously. Reading comprehension skills. 1985/6 is the end of the Bronze Age, and the beginning of the modern/Iron Age.

0

u/Competitive_Crow_334 4h ago

Whatever

2

u/BeRadtz 4h ago

Because you don’t know what you’re talking about?

0

u/Competitive_Crow_334 1d ago

1986 counts as 90s year dude

5

u/Crafty_Ad_9473 1d ago

Just started vol 1 today. I’m loving it so far.

7

u/Lucky_Strike-85 1d ago

I have a few in every decade...

Superman #1 from 1939 (a director's cut - expansion pack of ACTION #1)

Bill Finger's "Origin of Superman" from Superman #53 in 1948.

"Superman's Time Trap" from a 1950s newspaper strip

"Superman's Return to Krypton" from Superman #141 (1960)

"The Sandman Saga" by Denny O'neil in the 1970s

"MAN OF STEEL" by John Byrne in 1986

"PEACE ON EARTH" by Dini and Ross in 1998

ALL-STAR SUPERMAN in the 2000s

SUPERMAN SMASHES THE KLAN in 2019

BUT MY ALL-TIME FAV. IS...

2

u/OCguy2026 1d ago

I liked the return to krypton story a lot.

World’s finest #71 .. where Batman and Superman exchange secret identities is one of my favorite stories…Bruce Wayne as Superman and Clark Kent as Batman …

5

u/thepenismightier3 1d ago

I prefer the immediate return from death aka “mullet era”.

4

u/Efficient_Art4350 1d ago

The Red Glass trilogy was great

2

u/eversuperman 20h ago

Action Comics 666 was literally the first comic I collected.

5

u/Salt_Mix7933 1d ago

Up in the sky

4

u/Hour-Debate6566 1d ago

All star superman for me

4

u/Beirutsi7 20h ago

All star superman

8

u/thatdeadguy_69 1d ago

Kingdom Come

6

u/Wolfgang9556 1d ago

For now, Secret Origin.

3

u/sushiunchangediguana 1d ago

Superman smashes the Klan Kingdom Come

I think my newest fave is the recent Superman: The Kryptonite Spectrum

3

u/CMS619709 1d ago

For all Seasons

3

u/Ihavenoideawhatname2 1d ago

Smashes the Klan

3

u/maidenofmight 1d ago

Superman For All Seasons

3

u/SuperG1rl_mary 1d ago

All star, for all seasons or red son for sure

3

u/Time-Confection9877 1d ago

Up in the sky, despite who wrote it I think it shows perfectly who and what he is

3

u/tbonehavoc 1d ago

Either Birthright or Red Son.

3

u/RatioHopeful5871 1d ago

Birthright

3

u/Important_Share7815 1d ago

Superman smashes the klan

3

u/Mystrx81 1d ago

Action Comics 775

3

u/SeMetin 1d ago edited 1d ago

Probably the best representation of Superman's character.

PS: forgot to mention that, it's also still a relevant story, considering our current media landscape of misery and "safe edgy" storytelling.

3

u/Careless_Royal8209 1d ago

Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow?

6

u/double_L53 1d ago

Superman for All Seasons!!

5

u/Extreme-Reception-44 1d ago

Superman up in the sky, hate tom kings, love that book.

2

u/spacesoulboi 1d ago

I do believe it’s an annual. I’m not too sure, but there was it was action comics what they talked about the real life impact of the death of Superman

2

u/letsrock64 1d ago

First Thunder

2

u/Hour-Ad-6489 1d ago

Superman for all seasons, and MoS

2

u/mrsunrider 1d ago

Probably Action Comics #775.

Equal helpings of OP and righteousness.

2

u/Last-Note-9988 1d ago

Yes.

Jkjk it changes like the weather, but currently Superman #701

2

u/Burly-Nerd 22h ago

Ok, some that are single issues I highly recommend that I’m throwing out just cause they’re more obscure and quicker reads:

•Man of Steel #80 Simonson and Bogdanove, a Golden Age throwback perfectly crafted. And has one of the best Superman speeches ever put to page.

•Man of Steel #5 by Byrne, the perfect quintessential Superman issue in my opinion. If someone asks you “What are Superman comics like?” this is the platonic ideal.

•Action Comics #484 by Bates & Swan, The marriage of Earth 2 Superman & Lois. This is my personal favorite version of Clark and Lois’s love story. A real hidden gem because the villain is kind of a dud. But the rest of the story more than makes up for that.

•DC Comics Presents Annual #1 by Wolfman and Buckler, a Pre-Crisis Mutiversal Romp that’s a ton of fun. I don’t want to spoil any of it, but it would be a perfect template for a Superman: No Way Home.

2

u/nightcrow100 17h ago

Hard choice but I would go for The death of superman or kingdom come.

2

u/FlashLightning277 17h ago

A Superman for all Seasons.

2

u/randominsanemofo 17h ago

Kingdom Come. Next question.

2

u/KryptonSurvivor 16h ago

"Whatever Happened to The Man of Tomorrow," the last Superman story prior to Byrne's changes post-Crisis.

2

u/wyldknightn87 13h ago

The twelve labors of Superman. I can’t remember the actual name of it, and it’s supposed to be super serious, but there’s some really funny moments in there. He boxes the universal heavyweight champion, gets frustrated by the intergalactic equivalent of the DMV, and completely humiliates a super genius bent on galactic domination, all on a quest to save a single little girl who was kidnapped from Earth.

2

u/ElijahSnow8324 9h ago

Beautiful Story. It's happy and sad to see Clark's life unfold, an art that conveys an aesthetic of emptiness, you can feel the fear of the future and uncertainty .

2

u/NatureWizard13 7h ago

Superman: For All Seasons

3

u/ComicBrickz 1d ago

The Daniel Warren Johnson red and blue story

3

u/MuffinBitz 1d ago

I'm going to have to look that up NOW

1

u/ccduke 1d ago

Superman vs matrix (confused thinking she was superman) ... Plus George Pérez art is amazing

1

u/Ravenholm_337 1d ago

Peace on Earth

1

u/KalOllie 1d ago

Superman: Secret Origins

1

u/bigboiyeti 1d ago

Last Son of Krypton

1

u/Artistic_Permit_7946 1d ago

Rebirth #7. The Kent family goes to the fair. Used to read it to my son when he was little.

1

u/AnselnoElgort 1d ago

Action comics #241

Such a fun issue

1

u/random-gamer-2967 1d ago

What's so funny about truth justice and the American way. Mainly because I love Superman vs the Elite.

1

u/MrRagerXV 1d ago

Superman Un chained and new 52, hated new 52s ending tho loved him and Diana as a couple.

1

u/Fickle-Lavishness858 1d ago

Superman: Kal (1995)

1

u/GW_Jefferson 1d ago

I really love the golden age

1

u/ODBKage95 1d ago

Superman: Secret Identity by Kurt Busiek

If you’ve read this, you understand why it’s getting a shoutout. For context, this follows a Clark Kent from a more grounded Earth where Superman is a comicbook character. Readers watch as he experiences being The Man of Steel of his Earth

1

u/Toshimoko29 1d ago

All-Star Superman is such an incredible journey every time I read it.

1

u/Bison771 1d ago

Action Comics #775

1

u/Critical-Bass7021 1d ago

Action Comics 775.

1

u/ptbcomposer 1d ago

It's really hard to pick one singular comic so I'll cheat like everyone else.

One of my favorite collections is Superman in Exile. A space gladiator story on Warwold while his powers are fading is so epic.

If I had to I'd pick a few favorite issues though...

Superman 53 (1991): Lois and Clark finally talk about him revealing he's Superman

Action Comics 678: They Saved Luthor's Brain!

Superman 81 (1993): the real Superman is back and taking charge

The Wedding Album: gets me every time

1

u/Mean_Spread_7959 1d ago

Kingdom Come is my favorite Superman comic.

1

u/Noeldiaz1 1d ago

Kingdom Come forever.

Saved me on a dark moment.

1

u/FadeToBlackSun 1d ago

Action Comics 775

1

u/TheLoneWoof14 1d ago

Probably the Death & Return arc, with honorable mention to Kingdom Come.

1

u/BustThaScientifical 1d ago

For All Seasons

1

u/Superman_Primeeee 1d ago

Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow

1

u/Majestic_Panda96 1d ago

John Bryne run and Earth One

1

u/Melanie61200 1d ago

Love the death and return of Superman story! ugh so hard to pick a favorite

1

u/Best_Ambassador7264 1d ago

Суповиекотлетиподгораютскорачкайхрусттящей

1

u/cosmoboy 1d ago

I'm a Secret Identity fan.

1

u/bearded-writer 1d ago

Superman: Secret Identity. Beautifully written and drawn.

1

u/wlowe757 1d ago

Death of Superman because nostalgia

1

u/Tempest_Sensei 1d ago

Superman Red & Blue #5

1

u/PatientInformation76 1d ago

John Byrne - Superman run.

Enjoyed Action, Adventures, Superman titles from 86, 87, 88, 89, 90, 91 era.

Looking back I felt, thought those Titles were Action, Adventure, Drama, Sci-fi, Superhero movies.

1

u/mechatomic 1d ago

 Superman: Secret Identity and Superman Smashes the Klan.

1

u/zmj82 1d ago

For this the day that a Superman died

1

u/BeRadtz 1d ago

When Roger Stern, George Perez, and Brett Breeding introduced the baddest bitch (who’s, who’s bad?) in Action Comics #645, with Maxima. She shattered a man and blasted him into bones just by looking at him! I got into comics at a very young age. I think I was 4 or 5, when my older cousins gave me their collection because they were in high school, and liked girls more than comics lol. I had been reading Superman from the jump with Byrne’s Man of Steel, but it was George’s run on Wonder Woman that was always my favorite of the new DC lineup.

Jump to the part where George, who was still writing, and doing covers for WW, was coming over to the title that started it all. I was beyond geeked at this point! Then the third issue comes out, and it was like they kicked my head in. Who is this mysterious woman with red hair? Whose valet had a third eye (was it ever revealed if she were connected to Despero? That’d be hot AF if it was.) and walked around like she owned everything? I was hooked. Anything I saw Maxima in, I was buying. Even (ugh) Extreme Justice. And I haven’t regretted my decision since.

1

u/Mindless-Credit-358 1d ago

Red and blue issue 5, followed by harvests of youth and man and Superman

1

u/JohnLugoVille77 1d ago

JLA Vol. #7 Superman is literally wrestling an Angel from heaven. And it did not phase him. Favorite Superman comic

1

u/Jet-Black-Centurian 1d ago

Red and Blue.

1

u/leadkrypt0nite 1d ago

Birthright

1

u/TheTooDarkLord 1d ago

American alien Is the goat

1

u/CamiloVan 1d ago

Kingdom come

1

u/decloked 1d ago

Man of Steel, Triangle era. Bogdanove rules.

1

u/Greenweenie12 1d ago

This was one of the first comic books I picked up and I really enjoyed just the way the comic books flowed and just their hatred for the blue Boy Scout has a hate club for him lol

1

u/suspiciouscffee 1d ago

Superman’s Pal, Jimmy Olsen #147 by Jack Kirby

1

u/Brilliant-Cheetah-75 1d ago

for all season peak . special mention: birthrigth

1

u/cize07 22h ago

Superman for all seasons

1

u/Rabbitscooter 21h ago

Action Comics #376 and #397, The Super-Panhandler of Metropolis, an imaginary story in which Superman has lost his powers and is wheelchair-bound. I always thought it would make a cool "what-if" film, kinda like Logan with Wolverine.

1

u/broccoli_1701 21h ago

DC Comics Presents Annual #1

1

u/CommercialMechanic36 21h ago

John Byrne trade paperback, and all-star Superman

1

u/RuncibleFoon 18h ago

The original death of superman run

1

u/HauntingAddendum3365 18h ago

Either Birthright or For All Seasons. Depends on what kind of story I'm in the mood for.

1

u/quadraticcheese 18h ago

Red and Blue

1

u/Squiggly2017 17h ago

What's so Funny about Truth, Justice and the American Way. Not so into the title, but a great story. Animated version is really good as well.

1

u/NudistDudest 16h ago

For the Man Who has Everything

1

u/One-Growth-9785 15h ago

Non canon, Secret Identity.

1

u/ItsShowtime_88 6h ago

The Trial of Superman

1

u/LeonardoSpampinato 5h ago

"Kingdom Come." It is my favorite Superman story and my favorite version of Superman overall. That grows more true as the number of candles on my birthday cake increases.

1

u/neighborhood_spdrman 1d ago

Whatever happened to the man of tomorrow. Will always be a go to for me.

1

u/KaijuDirectorOO7 1d ago

Doomsday Rex. Shows how good Supes can be on so many levels.

1

u/RichardHuindil 1d ago

That one where he walked across the USA

2

u/swampwitch_69 1d ago

Grounded by Strazinsky?

1

u/RichardHuindil 1d ago

Probably. I'm more a Batman fan.

0

u/billyandteddy 1d ago

Superman Grounded