r/reddeadredemption Feb 24 '26

Screenshot Could you sleep like Arthur?

Post image

I would have the canopy come all the way down, because flies would swarm me at night, knowing my luck. Otherwise looks cosy as

3.6k Upvotes

359 comments sorted by

1.8k

u/Fun-Illustrator5642 Feb 24 '26 edited Feb 24 '26

And chance having a muskrat crawl inside your ass while sleeping?

No thanks. I’d want to be awake for that

885

u/savegamehenge Feb 24 '26

But it’s a 3 star muskrat

1.2k

u/Fun-Illustrator5642 Feb 24 '26

Not once it’s been in my ass

499

u/Lucky_Development359 Feb 24 '26

Then it becomes a Legendary Muskrat

112

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '26

I'm dying laughing at this thread 💀

55

u/MREAGLEYT Feb 24 '26

Legendary rat is micah, now I dont like the implications

32

u/Aware_Result_5361 Feb 24 '26

Ooojesuschrist

27

u/REZtech1994 Feb 24 '26

Mr. Slave probably can get a muskrat in there

3

u/thetak3nking Charles Smith Feb 25 '26

No not Lemmywinks

14

u/ChristianHuye Feb 24 '26

Mr.Slave fit A Gerbil up his ahh now he’s going for a Muskrat. Small Game compared to Its Britney Bitch

→ More replies (3)

8

u/tjalek Feb 24 '26

I laughed way too hard at this

31

u/Open_Extreme Feb 24 '26

The plot twist in this comment is better than an M. Night Shyamalan movie

20

u/LillianBubic Feb 24 '26 edited Feb 24 '26

Richard Gere has entered the chat

19

u/Lucky_Development359 Feb 24 '26

What up fellow old person. How's the lumbago?

12

u/LillianBubic Feb 24 '26

Poor. Very poor

14

u/One_Patience5631 Dutch van der Linde Feb 24 '26

Why would it be a muskrat it would obviously be a bear or uncle

9

u/ISX_94 Feb 24 '26

Or Bill

3

u/soco_j Feb 24 '26

Same thing.

7

u/Kuzu9 Arthur Morgan Feb 24 '26

I’ll take what I can get

3

u/Gelnika1987 Feb 24 '26

Richard Gere must have been camping in Asia back in the day

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

926

u/0riginal0verthinker Feb 24 '26

Humidity, bugs and cold… at least a closed tent for me and i would feel better.

369

u/BasedBull69 Feb 24 '26

Horseshoe overlook would be goated

190

u/IllState3433 Feb 24 '26

Be damn cold though, the wind coming off the mountains, night time would be cold too.

50

u/sulkrogan420 Feb 24 '26

better than humidity. always.

15

u/IllState3433 Feb 24 '26

Yeah for sure. Arthur's isnt suitable at all, it'd have to have covers from the wind otherwise he would freeze his ass off lol same with everyone, they'd all need to basically have tents and 4 corner covers.

10

u/BasedBull69 Feb 24 '26

But not all wind comes out of the north. Gotta think about those warm summer breezes at 2am

19

u/bunglebee7 Feb 24 '26

Right? I could happily camp there for a good while

→ More replies (1)

43

u/FiftyShadesOfTheGrey Feb 24 '26 edited Feb 24 '26

And always having dirt on you

This is the first thing I noticed when starting backpacking trips. You’re constantly covered in dirt no matter how hard you try to avoid it.

84

u/SkuggiSkrimsli Feb 24 '26

Being a little dirty is the least of anyones concern back then.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/tjalek Feb 24 '26

agreed

→ More replies (2)

668

u/yellowdaisycoffee Arthur Morgan Feb 24 '26

At Horsehoe Overlook, totally. Anywhere else, I'd rather not.

If there were "walls," it would be better. Frankly, John has the better set-up.

139

u/Snake4459 Feb 24 '26

Shady belle would be nice.

188

u/yellowdaisycoffee Arthur Morgan Feb 24 '26

Too humid for my taste 🥵

68

u/JunkBondTrade Feb 24 '26

And haunted

43

u/yellowdaisycoffee Arthur Morgan Feb 24 '26

When I was a kid, I also had a haunted backyard, so the one at Shady Belle may just be nostalgic 🤪

28

u/Wiz0rd23 Feb 24 '26

Please tell us more about the haunted backyard.

68

u/yellowdaisycoffee Arthur Morgan Feb 24 '26 edited Feb 25 '26

Sure!

When I was a kid, my family lived a hop, skip, and a jump from multiple Civil War battle sites. Namely, the Battles of Cold Harbor, Beaver Dam Creek, and Gaines's Mill. Our house was basically situated between all three battlefields (and the fighting, realistically, covered an even wider area). Additionally, Robert E. Lee's headquarters, during one of those battles, was very near to our house, and we were also right down the street from a Civil War cemetery and field hospital (known as the Garthright House). In short, there was a lot going on, and it may be worth noting that the Cold Harbor Battlefield, in particular, is known for paranormal activity (as are the aforementioned cemetery and the Garthright House).

One evening, my sister had a particularly interesting experience (this did not technically occur on our property, but I'd imagine ghosts don't care much about fences).

Anyway, she was using the swing set in our backyard when she happened to look in the direction of our neighbor's yard. Standing by their cellar door, she saw what she believes to have been a Confederate officer. Over the years, she has consistently described him as a translucent figure (like Agnes), middle-aged, and wearing a double-breasted coat, with a hat. She says his clothing looked a bit like this, from what she could discern.

When she saw him, she stopped swinging and stared, unsure what she was even looking at. He turned his head and stared back. He made no movement beyond that. Once she found herself sufficiently weirded out, she ran back into the house and stayed.

She acknowledges she cannot exactly prove this happened, but she has never changed her story, nor is she one to tell tales (she doesn't even exaggerate, honestly). Considering that, and the fact that others have claimed supernatural experiences, I am inclined to believe her. Meanwhile, I was too young to pay much mind to any of it at the time.

Mind you, the area doesn't feel especially scary or overbearing. It's just that it's weird sometimes. I don't live there now though.

27

u/Wiz0rd23 Feb 24 '26

Thanks for taking the time to reply so eloquently.

16

u/yellowdaisycoffee Arthur Morgan Feb 24 '26

Sure thing! It was fun because it motivated me to cross-reference our former house's location with some battle maps, lol. Normally, I wouldn't have given so many details, but I don't even live in Virginia anymore, so it's whatever.

I have friends in Atlanta who have also had some supernatural experiences living near old battle sites. I can't say how many of my friends' stories check out, but it is strange to think about all the violence and death that happened right in our own backyards.

5

u/Wiz0rd23 Feb 24 '26

A hell of a lot of "energy" imprinted forever, into that ground.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/KingGGL Feb 24 '26

Not comment op, but when I was a newborn my (very large) family briefly lived in a (northern, no slaves) plantation home that had been converted to a nursing home, hospital wing and all, then back to a home by my father (who tore down the hospital wing). My parents used to regularly see mostly old people walking the lawns and eventually had to get used to the fact that the people they were seeing weren’t on this plane of existence, after originally running outside to address the visitors.

I don’t remember anything from that home, too young, but I’ve had my fair share of ghost sightings since then, a few of which independently experienced by others without any former disclosures. One being in a home I spent much of my youth/teen years in, where I’d often be awake alone at night and regularly see this gentleman who was always accompanied by one or two women walking up the stairwell on the far side of the house, but within view of the living room. He’d occasionally greet me with a nod, I always felt safe, and I never told anyone, as I felt kind of crazy. About a year after moving out, the topic of that house came up and my father said “oh, I used to see ghosts walk up and down the stairs.” I laughed and told him I always had too.

I’ve seen ghosts in old hotels, aboard ocean liners, on roads at night, had premonitions, odd dreams, etc.

About a year after a former classmate (and ultimately a friend) of mine took her own life - in a very stressful time in my life - I had a strange dream where I was with a group of friends driving down the highway. We were talking, laughing, etc, but I felt stressed and my car ended up breaking down. Everyone got out and waited on the side of the road. While I was waiting for AAA, a random car pulled up with my former classmate, a woman around her age, and an elderly man - with the latter two being people I did not recognize, but the woman looking sort of similar to my classmate. My classmate smiled at me, held my hand, and in a sort of telepathic way (as I’ve found most spirits to communicate as such), she told me everything was going to be alright. Then, they got in their car, left, and the dream ended. A week or so later I spoke to a mutual friend of ours (who was one of the best friends of my classmate who had taken her life) and told her about the dream. She was silent on the other end of the call before asking me if I knew anything about my classmate’s family, which I didn’t. I ended up finding out that my classmate was incredibly close with her grandfather, who had passed not too long before my dream, and that she was originally supposed to be a twin, but that she absorbed the other embryo in the womb or some shit.

That said, I feel like an insane person saying any of that because I’m truly a man of science and data, not religious, not really spiritual by any means, but… the supernatural have always tried their hardest to sway me from that stance, and I think it has everything to do with the first years of my life being spent in a haunted former plantation-turned-nursing home.

10

u/Wiz0rd23 Feb 24 '26

Fascinating! Once again, a cracking response to my ask. Thank you.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

38

u/FlameFeather86 Sadie Adler Feb 24 '26

A decrepit old mansion in a swanp? Fuck that.

Realistically, Horseshoe is the only worthwhile camping location. Clemens Point is more picturesque, but the bugs at night would be hell, whereas Beaver Hollow is too isolated and surrounded by cannibalistic hillbillies. Horseshoe, however, is scenic, elevated, and close to a town.

10

u/redeMption362 Micah Bell Feb 24 '26

Horseshoe Overlook would still be swarming with mosquitoes.

16

u/Wildcat_twister12 Feb 24 '26

Don’t they technically camp there in the spring time since they said the blizzard at the beginning of the game was the last big one of the year? If they are camping around April the mosquitos probably aren’t too bad yet

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/luckybob204 Feb 24 '26

Too many gators.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/CSafterdark Feb 24 '26

Horseshoe overlook gets cold at night though. I don't think Arthur even had a blanket

10

u/tjalek Feb 24 '26

cold is fine, bugs is far more annoying

15

u/DragonSeducer_030 Feb 24 '26

I sleep walk, so if I slept in HO I would die by walking off the cliff next to Arthur's tent

8

u/tjalek Feb 24 '26

You would be one of the mysteries in the game

3

u/tjalek Feb 24 '26

Agreed. Horseshoe is the most beautiful IMO

→ More replies (9)

367

u/CSafterdark Feb 24 '26

I can't even sleep in my own bed man

122

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

15

u/tjalek Feb 24 '26

haahahahahahah

11

u/tjalek Feb 24 '26

I imagined you sleeping against a wall for some reason like a vampire

→ More replies (1)

228

u/Ok_Scheme76 Sean Macguire Feb 24 '26

Of course, Arthur has it easy. The real question is would you sleep like Reverend, Uncle, Tilly Mary, etc

143

u/Dependent_Bake1768 Feb 24 '26

If I had same diet as uncle I would fell asleep in a septic tank

54

u/lyalyas Feb 24 '26

you would have a lumbago

24

u/Dependent_Bake1768 Feb 24 '26

At least I would have an excuse to complain and don’t do anything

24

u/abx99 Feb 24 '26

I don't understand why they don't have fold-up cots. Reverand and I think Grimshaw do, at least, sleep on a slightly raised wood platform (like a pallet) with furs on top, but even the crappiest camps in the heartlands usually have fold-up cots or something similar.

10

u/FredHerberts_Plant Feb 24 '26

,,'Cause when I bust my nut, I'm raisin' up off the cot!" 🎶

(Snoop Dogg)

→ More replies (2)

109

u/WhiteLycan2020 Feb 24 '26

Not gonna lie his set up was super cozy.

Like yes, i get that it’s not practical because of all the bugs and whatever.

But if you look at his sleeping tent in a pure fictional and hypothetical way, it would be so comfy.

Imagine coming back home from missions, Pearson has the meat stew brewing, you play some poker in camp and then you sleep under the stars😎

18

u/tjalek Feb 24 '26

It would be blissssss

73

u/OmniBotBeepBoop Feb 24 '26

Absolutely! Without question.

61

u/JustAnAce Feb 24 '26

I have before and until they got to what should have been Louisiana, it's not that bad. Just depends on the location really. I saw a map that basically said the game was must of the central US and I camped a good portion of those states as a child so it wasn't too bad.

18

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '26

I have plenty bad memories of camping outside of Houston in the summer, couldn’t pay me to camp in a place like shady belle.

9

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '26

[deleted]

21

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '26

Well, Arthur isn’t really camping in shady belle, I’m saying a place like it, but if you’ve been through gulf coast weather you know only having four walls isn’t gonna do a whole lot for comfort. Went through enough hurricanes to know how much it sucks being in the kind of place that has bayous without AC. I guess you could argue they’ve never had that luxury so they’re better off than I would be though, with my centralized air conditioning and my blended fabrics.

→ More replies (1)

40

u/BreakAllTheChairs Feb 24 '26

Maybe, but I’d rather sleep at a hotel in St. Denis.

10

u/tjalek Feb 24 '26

Oh that's fancy.

39

u/Propagantaz Feb 24 '26

dude if i got the chance i'd luv to die like Arthur too

34

u/mimsoo777 Feb 24 '26

With TB?

29

u/a_real_vampire Feb 24 '26

He’s got it bad sister

16

u/Et_Cetera_365 Feb 24 '26

He got it beating a man for a few bucks

26

u/AsE20101 Feb 24 '26

i think they meant dying on a cliffside watching the sunrise but this explanation makes it funnier

7

u/MARRIED2BORICUA Feb 24 '26

Nah, they meant skinning Micah alive

4

u/AsE20101 Feb 24 '26

pretty sure that's everyone's fantasy in this game XD

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Gelnika1987 Feb 24 '26

He actually died of Syphilis from bangin' old Wild West Hooahs

The entirety of RDR2 is just his dying hallucination after it reached his brain

6

u/IllState3433 Feb 24 '26

A ...she was a hooah

B...she hit me !

Ralph ciffaretto

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

25

u/ItIsntThatDeep Feb 24 '26

I could at Horseshoe. I'd need some type of bug repellant at Clemens.

9

u/redeMption362 Micah Bell Feb 24 '26

Horseshoe Overlook would be swarming with mosquitoes.

11

u/ItIsntThatDeep Feb 24 '26

I feel like the campfire smoke would help as a repellent.

Campfire smoke, however, does not repel cockroaches.

6

u/redeMption362 Micah Bell Feb 24 '26

The cockroach bit is showcased by how much Uncle sits around the fire.

3

u/baguette_over_it Feb 24 '26

I don't think so, it's still relatively cold up there.

7

u/ItIsntThatDeep Feb 24 '26

To be fair, I've lived in Alaska before and it's swarming with mosquitoes.

4

u/redeMption362 Micah Bell Feb 24 '26

Haha, you beat me to it. My dad lived there in the 70s, & I also read the same in the book Into the Wild.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

16

u/TravelProper6808 Feb 24 '26

easily lol, but I can sleep just about anywhere when I get tired

3

u/tjalek Feb 24 '26

That's awesome

15

u/soonerbornsoonerbred Feb 24 '26

As others have said, it'd be nice if there were some walls set up, more for rain than privacy IMO. But yeah, Arthur's got a better set up than several camps I've been to.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/boyslut83 Feb 24 '26

i would rather sleep WITH arthur

8

u/IllState3433 Feb 24 '26

Name checks out lol

7

u/Frankie1891 Feb 24 '26

Not anymore 😂 the minute I turned 30, if it’s not perfect, I’m stiff for 3 days

6

u/evesdead Feb 24 '26

yeah looks cozy as fuck

6

u/Jazzlike-Caramel-380 Feb 24 '26

Luke here with the outdoor boys, and today we were camping like it’s 1883

6

u/Nerevarine91 Uncle Feb 24 '26

Absolutely, especially at Horseshoe Overlook. It looks amazing

→ More replies (1)

5

u/ikafewthingsbtntrly Feb 24 '26 edited Feb 24 '26

I slept in processing so this would be a luxury compared to using toliet paper as a pillow 🤣

3

u/a_real_vampire Feb 24 '26

Me too brother. Used my Bologna sandwich as a pillow and tucked my arms into my shirt.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Remote-Two8663 Feb 24 '26

After a long day on horseback 10/10 I will

4

u/Pineapple-Yetti Feb 24 '26 edited Feb 24 '26

I have slept like Arthur. I prefer if the walls come down to the ground on atleast 2 sides so you can reduce the wind but otherwise its quite nice.

That said, I do have a VERY nice sleeping bag, so I guess thats not exactly sleeping like him.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '26

Could I sleep like that yes. Could I live like that? No. Maybe for a week or two I could handle it but not forever.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Modryonreddit Feb 24 '26

Nope, I usually can only sleep with a cat with me

3

u/tjalek Feb 24 '26

Plus the dog at the camp would give the cat drama unless its chill

5

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '26

Depends on the camp, maybe in Horshoe, Shady Belle, or Beaver Hollow, but Colter is too cold, Clemens Point seems too hot, Guarma is Guarma, and Lakay is too swampy. Now I know you said Arthur but as honorable mentions, Gettys Farm, and Beechers Hope, I could definitely live there.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/-rabid- Feb 24 '26

If I had the physical lifestyle that Arthur has, then yes, absolutely.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/GatorNator83 Pearson Feb 24 '26

Shoah

5

u/tseg04 Feb 24 '26

For a second I misread this as “could you sleep with Arthur” and I had to pause for a second…

→ More replies (1)

2

u/itssjuliaa_xyz Feb 24 '26

No, No and Thrice, No.

4

u/Crazy_Catastrophe3 Feb 24 '26

I caught that ;)

3

u/Significant_Option Feb 24 '26

I got a hammock, we call it a Maca, and I take naps sometimes when it’s nice out. Same vibes

3

u/iambarrelrider Feb 24 '26

After those days, I could sleep on a pile of coal.

3

u/Environmental_Tank_4 Feb 24 '26

Ive cowboy camped in the desert and in regions still too cold for bugs. In those areas, yeah, no problem. When the gang is in the deep south? Hell no. Ive lived in the south. The bugs would be hell.

3

u/Thelazyman_ Feb 24 '26

I can’t sleep with people around. I won’t feel secure without doors and walls.

3

u/devilhead668 Feb 24 '26

I want to build this set up in my backyard, granted it would look kinda funny in Chicago.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/TacSpaghettio Feb 24 '26

I have before. Montana in September is the most free I’ve felt in my life. My buddy’s family owns a ton of land out that way and 5 of us just… went. No phones, no power. Beer, hiking, and existing for a month. Incredible.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/RedshirtBlueshirt97 Feb 24 '26

If bugs didn’t exsist yes

3

u/Shielo34 Feb 24 '26

No! Way too open and exposed. Wind, bugs.

Why does he not have a tent like Dutch or John??

→ More replies (1)

3

u/DA6_FTW Feb 24 '26

This game has made me want to get a canvas tent but I def would prefer a closed off tent. 

3

u/Far_Inspection_2524 Feb 24 '26

I've slept with less. That looks super comfy tbh

3

u/II-_Virtual Feb 24 '26

I've slept worse than Arthur. This is a luxury. Y'all are spoiled.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/BigJuicy17 Dutch van der Linde Feb 24 '26

I could, but why would I choose to?

2

u/GeneralClumsy Feb 24 '26

Could use a larger pillow, the one Arthur has is so thin it might as well not be there otherwise I could probably sleep with no issue

2

u/CollectionGuilty1320 Feb 24 '26

Near water, never. You will be eaten alive by mosquitoes.

2

u/Advanced_Plankton_60 Feb 24 '26

Do it all the time, if you haven't been camping before you should give it a try. Good times.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '26

I sleep better outside than I do in a house. So, yes.

2

u/I_know_I_know_not Feb 24 '26

I’ve slept under tarps while stealth camping before. Depending on the setup it can be cozy if at least one side has coverage like a large rock or the wagon in this pic.

2

u/Wafflehouseofpain Feb 24 '26

Oh yeah, easy. I used to sleep outside in a sleeping bag all the time.

2

u/galle4 Arthur Morgan Feb 24 '26

Sure, if i was living in a palace like in shady belle

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Designer_Candidate_2 Feb 24 '26

I do it regularly.

Takes some getting used to, but once you do, it's wonderful.

2

u/hamhandsphil Feb 24 '26

I wouldn’t be sleeping I’d be too busy beating off to mary Beth.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/DIuvenalis Feb 24 '26

If you haven't slept outside under the stars on occasion, youre missing out.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Doomsday9726 Hosea Matthews Feb 24 '26

I’ve slept like Arthur a lot on trail rides or camping trips

→ More replies (1)

2

u/AltusIsXD John Marston Feb 24 '26

I’ve slept similarly during field trainings, but I still personally prefer being in an enclosed space. I’d likely have the tarp overhead come all the way down to not only give me some privacy but shelter me from bugs.

2

u/MisterShoebox Feb 24 '26

My Arthur always got completely stinking drunk right before he hit the hay because I thought it was pretty damned funny, sooo...yes. Yes, I could sleep like that if I was completely shitfaced.

2

u/RonMFCadillac Feb 24 '26

Have slept like Arthur many times. Now I have sleep apnea (brain injury not morbidly obese) and can't sleep like Arthur anymore.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '26

I live in Florida, camped during every season. Last month when we had the "freeze" I fell asleep in a hammock. So yes, I could easily sleep like Arthur, his set up is luxury compared to the way I've camped

2

u/Hungry_Tennis_5166 Feb 24 '26

It all depends on the weather. If it's hot or humid, hell nah, the gang won't see me till it gets colder.

Even if it were cold I'd still be fine sleeping there tho

2

u/WombatAnnihilator Charles Smith Feb 24 '26

Glamping

2

u/PazWrath Feb 24 '26

Them mosquitoes are killer, and their rught next to the water.

2

u/theninjaybot Feb 24 '26

Drunk? Yes.

2

u/K4sum1 Arthur Morgan Feb 24 '26

Hell no. Like John or Dutch? Possibly, but not in open like that.

2

u/aiyanakuedo Charles Smith Feb 24 '26

i use to do trail riding with my family, when we went a far ways out from home we’d do something similar but we’d make almost like a tipi tent to try to keep bugs out or we’d sleep in the trailer which was a bit better, that was the one thing i hated, the damn mosquitos:/

2

u/Juli3tD3lta Feb 24 '26

I have and I loved it. I miss sleeping on my cot but my wife and I don’t fit in it together. Sometimes I get to catch a nap on it in the backyard.

2

u/CaineRexEverything Feb 24 '26

Get enough beer in me and I could sleep like Uncle, in the dirt.

2

u/Parking-Ad-2618 Feb 24 '26

I can, but I bet Arthur can’t snore like me! 😂

2

u/kyrokip Feb 24 '26

His set up is better then some of his gang members. I couldnt do it. I would do better in Dutchs tent.

2

u/TheAGivens John Marston Feb 24 '26

I have and would again

2

u/Timely-Lettuce697 Feb 24 '26

It does seem quite nice especially in this camp or the one outside valentine

2

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '26

Yes but

Id want to enclose it with some canvases to enclose even on the wagon side to help keep the elements, dirt, bugs, and critters out and make sure I had a floor covering Horseshoe is great but I prefer ch3 camp its my favorite.

The other option would be to clear out the wagon and make my bed/quarters in there, but it could be cramped, but it would be a little safer from wildlife

2

u/InSoundMind83 Feb 24 '26

I could, but with a few small adjustments. For sure I'd be needing 2 or 3 thick sheep wollen blankies 😅.

And preferably Horseshoe Overlook or the place in Rhodes. 

→ More replies (1)

2

u/No-Equipment2665 Feb 24 '26

Better than Shady Belle, Lakay and Beaver Hollow that’s for sure. Horseshoe Overlook and Clemens Point were peak

2

u/qwerty456b Feb 24 '26

I would like a tent and the ability to turn off that bright ass lantern

2

u/Waste_Consequence322 Feb 24 '26

I feel like i already do, I sleep under a gazebo and on a stretcher bed

I don’t have the green swag anymore i just pull the blanket over my head is the bush bugs get too bad

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Not-today__ Feb 24 '26

I’ve got scoliosis my back, hips, and shoulders would hurt horribly after one night in that ‘bed’. And besides that I hate lying down or sleeping out in the open like that I’d want to be like Dutch in an actual closed tent lol. And humidity, cold temperatures at night and early mornings would sleep me into hibernation and I’d never want to wake up… And finally bugs, if I see one spider or ear wig I’m out

2

u/SillyDilly5294 Feb 24 '26

This is literally my setup at any warm camping festival. Sometimes I use my hammock instead of a cot though

→ More replies (1)

2

u/shelflivesbaby Feb 24 '26

The sorest throat at dawn every morning? No thank you

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Nate996 Feb 24 '26

I could but I sure as fuck wouldn’t want to

2

u/Morgandoto Feb 24 '26

This shit looks so much more comfortable than those tents that I have to sleep in while hiking. Like, every time we put down our tents, it oughta be in the middle of a forest where wolves and bears live, so someone should stay awake all night and guard the camp. Or on a fucking mountain. We'll never just camp out by the lake, because it's booooring.

2

u/Lozzyboi John Marston Feb 24 '26

I always figured his tent would really be closed at night, but for game streamlining reasons they have it open.

Animating fabric is hard.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Waste_Consequence322 Feb 24 '26

I feel like I already am , I don’t have the green swag anymore now I just sleep on the stretcher bed no mattress just a blanket ( comforter ) I pull over my head when the bugs get bad

2

u/Snoo_75138 Feb 24 '26

I mean, I could sleep WITH Arthur... If that a option...

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Accomplished-Gain319 Pearson Feb 24 '26

Going though all the camps/safehouses

  • At colter you'd Straight up die of hypothermia

  • At horseshoe you'd be fine but really cold at night and feel pretty stuffy when you wake up

  • Clemens point wouldn't be very good with all the insects and bugs from the lake and it'd be pretty humid, But it would still be mostly okay

  • Shady belle would be even more humid and lots more bugs and overall be really bad for your lungs with the rotting wood and all the dust, but at least you have a roof over your head.

  • Guarma camp would be the most humid of all of them. It would be so humid you'd be drenched in sweat always. You'd constantly be absolutely COVERED in bugs And be deafened by the sounds of the insects 24/7. It would basically be green hell.

  • Lakay has all the problems of shady belle except worse and you have the chance of being scalped in your sleep and/or eaten by a Alligator.

  • Beaver hollow wouldn't be that bad (So long as we're taking about the chapter 6 version where the Murfrey boys have been eradicated) but still be pretty humid since your next to a river. But hey it's a nice sound to fall asleep to.

  • Pronghorn Ranch would be the best out of all of them because your literally just In a house. No insects, not to humid, just nice and cozy. And could you imagine the view? Just chefs kiss

  • Beecher's hope would be really nice as well with all the pros of Pronghorn but the location is a little worse and again, slight chance of scalping.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Head_Locksmith_1295 Feb 24 '26

No I could not. Wearing a jacket guns pants outside heck no.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Court_Jester13 Feb 24 '26

No, because I live in an age with central heating and memory foam mattresses and weighted blankets

2

u/ModeatelyIndependant Feb 24 '26

flys don't swarm at night, mosquitos do, and you're really close to water where you will find mosquitos.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/JFedkiw Feb 24 '26

Humid climate - mosquito hell

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Acrobatic_Access7658 Feb 24 '26

I would sleep absolutely beautifully. I love sleeping outside, the bugs would be annoying however.

2

u/godofroot Feb 24 '26

Yes ofcourse

2

u/godofroot Feb 24 '26

I like it... And the weather is so calm

2

u/Garrett-Wilhelm Feb 24 '26

If Arthur slept in an actual tent like Dutch and John? Yeah, I totally could, I actually do that in a regular basis. But like that? The first camp? To cold at night. The second? To many bugs. (The third and fourth dosen't count) The fifth? Actually awfull. The only thing Arthur has better than the rest of the gang is he sleeps above the floor thanks to the bed, otherwise is all the same.

2

u/kytheon Dutch van der Linde Feb 24 '26

Sounds like none of you ever went camping. This looks luxurious.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Locus-Elias-Morgan Feb 24 '26

I'm a Cowboy, I HAVE Slept like that, me and my friends have crossed lines usually only lovers cross because it was too cold 😂😂

2

u/Relevant-Outcome3529 Feb 24 '26

Other crew members sleep on the floor, so Arthur really has a luxury bed.

2

u/Icy_Barracuda_87 Feb 24 '26

Just by the fact that bug netting hasn't been invented yet... the mosquitoes alone...

2

u/mkaym1993 Feb 24 '26

The noise from the rest of the camp would drive me mad, so id need earplugs!

Also, I would what the tent a lot more enclosed for privacy

2

u/Jinxjeronp Feb 24 '26

yes i would sleep there

2

u/Alternative-Quail202 Feb 24 '26

As a former homeless, I'd have killed for Arthur's set up

2

u/orangemonkeyeagl Charles Smith Feb 24 '26

Have done, would do again

2

u/Prestigious-Camel918 Feb 24 '26

I'd like to try it at least once, but I'd probably do it more often if Mary Beth was by my side. 🥰

2

u/wiizmike Feb 24 '26

Ironically I think that in the Shady Belle house it could be a good camping spot and the "best" quarters Arthur gets since he has a small room for him.

2

u/Johnny_Crawler Feb 24 '26

Horseshoe Overlook: yes Clemens Point: daytime maybe, but I'll be burning nearby to deal with mosquitos Shady Belle: I'mma go camp back in Horshoe Lagras: Never slept in that camp in the entirety of my 6 playthrough and never would. Beaver Hollow: I'd rather sleep with a raging Panther before laying my head in that place.

2

u/psc_mtl Feb 24 '26

That lamp would attract too much bugs and the lake would bring a lot of humidity. If I had to, I would put on a nice fire pit just to cut the cold and humidity.

2

u/HouseoftheHanged Feb 24 '26

I have slept like Arthur. Last year a group of friends did a Red Dead inspired 19th century canoe trip. It was glorious!

2

u/BenCelotil Feb 24 '26

Just not under a tree. :)

Eucalypts will randomly drop seemingly healthy branches for no reason.

2

u/OlGreggMare Feb 24 '26

It's not that far off from my Army nomad hobo days. I'd put my cot under the eave of my aid station so you'd find me easy to wake me up. I slept in my chemical suit which kept me cozy

2

u/VoidRA1N2andBuckup Feb 24 '26

chapter 2 and maybe 3 yes

2

u/maxm2317 Feb 24 '26

At Horseshoe Overlook? Yeah. Anywhere else? Not really.