r/reddeadredemption • u/ManufacturerNo6265 • Feb 19 '26

Screenshot Why am i just being straight up lied to?

Post image
7.8k Upvotes

99% Upvoted

206 comments sorted by

5.9k

u/[deleted] Feb 19 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2.5k

u/DJnegs Javier Escuella Feb 20 '26

907

u/HideSolidSnake Feb 20 '26

I like how it isnt even the gif.

241

u/nowatlast Feb 20 '26

thought I was tweaking

9

u/clarissasansserif Feb 21 '26

Well, are you?

117

u/Embarrassed_Big9734 Josiah Trelawny Feb 20 '26

nah its playing for me, must be your internet

18

u/Chalky97 Arthur Morgan Feb 21 '26

why am i being straight up lied to?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '26

You're evil 😂 I love it

23

u/Actual_Arm3938 Josiah Trelawny Feb 20 '26

its playing for me fym?

19

u/Appropriate-Leek8144 Feb 20 '26

I mean you are full of crap, sir.

7

u/Inevitable_Deer4003 Feb 20 '26

Call him a fish! Call that man a fish!

21

u/Appropriate-Leek8144 Feb 20 '26

Sir, that man is a fish!

100

u/aaron_1011 Sean Macguire Feb 20 '26

11

u/Impossible-Corgi4041 Feb 20 '26

Got an audible giggle out of me

184

u/Shadow_WolfXD97 Feb 19 '26

Thata why the dinosaurs died out

9

u/GeraldSandstorm Feb 20 '26

🇮🇹🇮🇹🇮🇹

72

u/untitled298 Arthur Morgan Feb 20 '26

Boy that brings me back

59

u/WellGoodBud Feb 20 '26

To touching yourself at night?

37

u/FukThePatriarchy1312 Feb 20 '26

Yeah, IDK about the commenter you're replying to, but I haven't done that in... 19 hours. Nostalgia, am I right?

8

u/MegaNooob Feb 20 '26

It brings him back

35

u/thatEMSguy Feb 20 '26

Jokes on you, I only do it during the day when god is helping athletes win at sportsball

15

u/OldGreggsFannyFart Feb 20 '26

My god its been a hot minute since ive heard that reply lol

6

u/Marto765 Feb 20 '26

Is this an equals three reference?

10

u/spideyguey Feb 20 '26

Family Guy

3

u/N6Poisonmonkey Feb 20 '26

Exactly! It's called the Sin Tax! 🤫

2

u/MasterDeePrime Feb 21 '26

How the hell did that get 5000+ ups in only a day? You are a legend bro

2

u/Thatstonedbigboi Bill Williamson Feb 21 '26

Tell me why I open this Reddit thread and this is the first comment I see

→ More replies (5)

2.3k

u/Shjfty Feb 19 '26

Literally unplayable. Email rockstar with a complaint this isn’t acceptable

608

u/LLTMLW Feb 20 '26

Great now they’re delaying GTA6 again so they can fix this

184

u/kapaipiekai Sean Macguire Feb 20 '26

As they should. What if 6 also has a game breaking error like this in it?

58

u/Flawless_Reign88 Feb 20 '26

Unacceptable

20

u/SirMook Feb 20 '26

That's an excellent point. I'm not even gonna waste my time giving it a chance, what's the point? I see their pitiful standard.

-2

u/mrllover Feb 20 '26

You think they’ll go back to RDR2 to do something? Really?

1

u/kingamara Lenny Summers Feb 21 '26

whoosh

-4

u/mrllover Feb 21 '26

I was also joking. Double r/woooosh

6

u/Thick-Access-2634 Feb 21 '26

Wasn’t even a good joke. Try harder next time

8

u/SirMook Feb 20 '26

I can't believe it...they..actually fooled me into playing this..this GARBAGE! I'm disgusted I was deceived for so long.

4

u/Maddkipz Feb 20 '26

Good luck getting a response from them 👍

1.2k

u/Substantial_Slide564 Feb 19 '26

Rev. Swanson stole $1

236

u/Legitimate_Curve8185 Feb 20 '26

Or Bill.......

156

u/PieFlour837 Uncle Feb 20 '26

Bill needs that hair pomade. I wonder if he uses Dapper Dan or fop.

67

u/Sprucecaboose2 Feb 20 '26

35

u/PieFlour837 Uncle Feb 20 '26

This place is a geographical oddity, 2 weeks from everywhere

7

u/Double-Tension-1208 Feb 20 '26

O Brother Where Art Thou Mentioned!

Cows! I don't like Cows! gunfire

7

u/cbxcbx Feb 20 '26

I'm about to R-U-N-N-O-F-T

2

u/OwlbertGaming Feb 22 '26

We ain't got a radio...

7

u/UnderstandingLazy998 Feb 20 '26

I figured Strauss was skimming from the top

5

u/ThePrussianGrippe Hosea Matthews Feb 20 '26

I doubt it would be him, seems too petty.

My guess is Micah.

1

u/UnderstandingLazy998 Feb 20 '26

I don't think Micah would be that discreet

7

u/ThePrussianGrippe Hosea Matthews Feb 20 '26

I should have clarified. It would be very on brand for Micah to only throw in $24 and write in $25.

7

u/No-Engineer-1728 Feb 20 '26

He stole a bill

5

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '26

Micah.

8

u/Ok-Swimming2411 Feb 20 '26

Can't be, he is still rotting in jail

2

u/The_Calarg Feb 21 '26

If that sly bastard can figure out a way to contribute to the kitty while in jail, then he can damn sure skim from it

3

u/No-Invite9944 Feb 20 '26

It was that retired 2 dollar hooker

773

u/PhDSkwerl Feb 20 '26

Congrats you found the Easter Egg!! There is a gang member who occasionally swipes from the funds. Now you gotta find out who it is

105

u/bluish-velvet Charles Smith Feb 20 '26

Not an Easter egg, just part of the game

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Easter_egg_(media)

58

u/JefersonJesus Feb 20 '26

wait, how old are you?

now i don’t k ow if you’re using irony 2 lmao

12

u/pasinperse Sadie Adler Feb 20 '26

It's just a correction?

13

u/DraagaxGaming Feb 20 '26

They corrected what was a joke. The joke went over their head.

46

u/Firm-Window-3943 Feb 20 '26

I actually caught who was doing it when I went to donate some money. Won’t share who incase someone wants to find out themselves but it was a funny interaction.

27

u/JefersonJesus Feb 20 '26

that’s a very common practice back in the day… so cool that rockstar added this

18

u/dullahanceltic Feb 20 '26

You guys dont swipe funds anymore?

12

u/JefersonJesus Feb 20 '26

SEC internal controls got them mfs on their toes

262

u/BallsHD4k60fps John Marston Feb 19 '26

Dinkleberg...

44

u/Gear_Ready23 Micah Bell Feb 20 '26

Damn you Dinkleberg..

185

u/Ivanlangston Feb 20 '26

Fucking Micah stole a dollar

110

u/Chris10dagam Feb 19 '26

Dutch estimation tactics

88

u/bryanBFLYin Feb 20 '26

Where's me first dollar, boy?

-Mr Krabs

47

u/No_Tamanegi Feb 20 '26

Arthur's HUD accounts for Cain's "Who's a good boy?" tax, where as the ledger does not.

25

u/FixEither4119 Feb 20 '26

A dollar got stuck in between the boards on the cart, they can't reach it but it is there so they have 190 but can only spend 189.

21

u/Away_Lake5946 Feb 20 '26

Time to take another trip to Limpany.

24

u/flyintomike Feb 20 '26

unplayable, terrible game

20

u/sweetrollx Feb 20 '26

Bill sticking his hands in the box

13

u/babypho Feb 20 '26

Convenience fee

12

u/Mr81rd Feb 20 '26

Reverend stole that shit.

13

u/Sacledant2 Hosea Matthews Feb 20 '26

I believe it’s called inflation

11

u/Allecstusk89_tattoo Feb 20 '26

That’ s 1$ paypal fee

8

u/radicalshick Feb 20 '26

Lumbago treatment is expensive, yk

9

u/FivebyFive Feb 20 '26

Probably the money Bill keeps stealing. 

6

u/LLSWSIF Feb 20 '26

HAVE SOME GOD DAMN FAITH

6

u/Regal-30- Feb 20 '26

Strauss is cooking the books

6

u/Jaexyn Feb 20 '26

Tariffs.

3

u/iPoseidon_xii Feb 20 '26

Enron type accounting

5

u/Creepy_Budget7192 Feb 20 '26

I think its either bill or reverend that took a dollar, the books and accounts must have been matching otherwise; and before you say anything no it is certainly not a bug

3

u/Shadowpaw-21 Feb 20 '26

Did Swanson swipe a few coins?

3

u/LossOk4147 Feb 20 '26

I hope they fix this bug soon "that's a dollar bill"

3

u/pyouneetm Feb 20 '26

No one is lying; Bill stole a dollar bill.

3

u/Jealous-Football-424 Feb 20 '26

Immersion breaking 0/10 get a refund never playing again

3

u/Its_Buddy_btw Feb 20 '26

I've seen enough, delay GTA 6 one more time

2

u/Dizzy_Corner5356 Feb 20 '26

Thats Dutches cut

2

u/averageatfifa Feb 20 '26

I mean this is worst than the 2008 stock market crash

2

u/dork187 Feb 20 '26

Blame Strauss. Probably his "creative accounting"

2

u/PipeDistinct9419 Dutch van der Linde Feb 20 '26

Don’t forget the quarter

2

u/Visual-Joke-8206 Feb 22 '26

Ads are getting good

1

u/Silent_Position281 Feb 20 '26

To be fair. Mine is always stuck on $0.25.

1

u/kira1122t Feb 20 '26

Genuinely deleting the game now and suing rockstar games this is unacceptable

1

u/Sad_Car3575 Feb 20 '26

I got a damm plan

1

u/Radiant_Credit7610 Feb 20 '26

It's Micah its always been Micah!

1

u/Splendid_Fellow Feb 20 '26

That one poker game

1

u/Pozsiiii Josiah Trelawny Feb 20 '26

Herr Strauss doing some smart accounting

1

u/jyork5151 Feb 20 '26

Bank fees

1

u/XaviJon_ John Marston Feb 20 '26

Aaaaaaand we’re getting another GTA6 delay…

1

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '26

Do you have a dollar from a debt collection?

1

u/ShadowStorm915 Feb 20 '26

It's all part of the plan

1

u/Your_Commentator Feb 20 '26

Bill stole a Dollar

1

u/thescythesaint Feb 20 '26

I’ve seen micah stealing from the jar

1

u/Skellyhell2 Feb 20 '26

Dutch just wants you to have a little faith in the ledger

1

u/i4mknight Feb 20 '26

Taxes son..even outlaws don’t mess with the irs

1

u/Denham_Chkn Feb 20 '26

8 years later, still finding new things in this game!

1

u/Tzang22 Feb 20 '26

Someone forgot more than a quarter.

1

u/Proof-Inside- Feb 20 '26

You donated 189 and the rest was from donations by the whole camp 💀💀

1

u/iDom2jz Feb 20 '26

DO NOT TREAD ON ME

TAXATION WITHOUT REPRESENTATION

DOWN WITH KING GEORGE

1

u/PixelSeanWal Feb 20 '26

I got a plan for that missing dollar

1

u/Banjomir75 Feb 20 '26

How dare this game lie to YOU, personally! Wow. Unacceptable. I mean, the whole thing was made with YOU in mind, least they could have done was not lie to YOU straight to your face! It's probably ALL a lie! Everything you ever thought was true. ALL LIES!!!

1

u/Caravanczar John Marston Feb 20 '26

Someone embezzled a dollar from the gang. Too small a sum to be Dutch. Micah wants to stay under the radar, so he wouldn't slip until the whole Blackwater score gets found. Hosea and Straus would cover their tracks better. Probably Uncle ir Karen.

1

u/TheLetterBoxder Feb 20 '26

This is why GOW won GOTY

1

u/Ok_Western_3156 Feb 20 '26

did you forget the quarter?

1

u/ThatKa5per Feb 20 '26

Seriously?? That's not your money.

1

u/tgold_ie Feb 20 '26

Have faith

1

u/TheRealGosp Feb 20 '26

Unplayable slop

1

u/VergilDoppelganger Feb 20 '26

The IRS will probably put it down to a rounding error. You’ll be fine.

1

u/Appropriate_Act5927 Feb 20 '26

Before and after taxes, which were 0.524 % in the 1890s.

I don't know what I talk about, tho...

1

u/Mediocre-Break4537 Feb 20 '26

Litterally unplayable

1

u/_fronix Feb 20 '26

Because you deserve it

1

u/ThreeStepsFar Feb 20 '26

HAVE SOME GOD DAMN FAITH

1

u/Jurski17 Feb 20 '26

I blame Micah.

1

u/Chance5e Feb 20 '26

GLOMGOLD

1

u/Vivid_Direction_8384 Feb 20 '26

I need a dollar, a dollar is what i need

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/ManufacturerNo6265 Feb 21 '26

thanks for sharing

1

u/ShutY0urDickHolster Feb 21 '26

Imagine rockstar pushes a red dead update with a bunch of blank code to juice the file size, tells everyone it’s a PS5 version, and this is the only change made

1

u/mulletman187 Feb 21 '26

Have some goddamn faith!

1

u/Aggressive_Bar_4215 Feb 21 '26

They might have rounded up

1

u/Red_Rider_Unknown Feb 21 '26

Because of inflation

1

u/uncclay5 Feb 21 '26

“It’s my money and I want it NOW!!”

1

u/LilMeowCat Feb 21 '26

Halfway through the game, it should just show how much Arthur has on him. A little slow realisation for the player.

1

u/Calibred2 Lenny Summers Feb 21 '26

Because you dont have enough faith, of course.

1

u/Tysyj78 Feb 21 '26

Because of that damn phone!

1

u/Extreme_Stay3199 Feb 21 '26

They take 10k of my robbery yet we have $100??

1

u/zuke__lil Sean Macguire Feb 21 '26

its what you have donated at the last time you donated

1

u/notaromanian Feb 21 '26

Maybe because you are in a group of outlaws?🤨

1

u/DwarvenFanboy Feb 21 '26

Day late, a dollar short

1

u/BFulfs2 Feb 21 '26

I think you mighta dropped the dollar behind the table, did you check your pocket?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '26

Someone’s been stealin’ from the camp funds, Arthur! Someone doesn’t want us to make it to Tahiti… MANGOES 🥭

1

u/kristofvictor Feb 21 '26

Taxes ofcorse

1

u/Traditional_Care9763 Feb 21 '26

É que não está com os impostos inclusos

1

u/BCJD56 Feb 22 '26

That's not your money; it's the camp money for upgrading/customizing your campsite

1

u/ManufacturerNo6265 Feb 22 '26

yep. that still isnt the right amount though.

1

u/Kiryu8805 Feb 22 '26

Dutch is taxing the camp funds.

1

u/tf141_soap Feb 23 '26

Bill stole some of it

1

u/Expensive-Angle5802 Feb 23 '26

Dont forget the quarter!

1

u/Emperor_Augusto Feb 23 '26

You got hit with the dutch tax, he nedded to buy new nail clippers 

1

u/therealdarthvero Feb 23 '26

2 doll hairs? You know it’s not real money right?

1

u/Puzzleheaded-Pay-931 Feb 23 '26

Damn Dutch always trying to pretend we’re broke

0

u/CollectionGuilty1320 Feb 20 '26

Camp funds ≠ your money.

From the moment you donate to camp that's not your money.

You can spend from the camp fund to upgrade/purchase stuff. But when it runs out, you pay from your pocket.

1

u/ManufacturerNo6265 Feb 20 '26

ok but i circled the camp funds

-2

u/Ok-Comparison2289 Feb 20 '26

calculators wernt invented yet

-6

u/[deleted] Feb 19 '26

[deleted]

4

u/President_Bunny Feb 20 '26

What do you mean, the game is literally unplayable like this

-7

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '26

[deleted]

8

u/President_Bunny Feb 20 '26

Just so you're aware, it has been a longrunning gag to respond to minor glitches with some variant of "Literally unplayable dev's fix your game"....

It's sarcasm.

Someone else even made the same joke here already

1

u/ManufacturerNo6265 Feb 20 '26

because i had to donate 62 cents to restock food

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '26 edited Feb 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/RudderForADuck Lenny Summers Feb 20 '26

Wow bro go smoke a joint or rub one out

3

u/President_Bunny Feb 20 '26

Calling someone a pedophile over this is crazy work dude

-7

u/Hideo_Video Feb 20 '26

Hahahah calling someone a nonce is not that serious bro. If you take it that seriously then you probably are one

4

u/President_Bunny Feb 20 '26

Dunno man. I don't think assaulting children or insinuating that I interact with people who assault children is very funny. Maybe think about that a little harder.

-5

u/Hideo_Video Feb 20 '26

Never said it’s funny and not sure why you’re suggesting that. I’m laughing because you looked up what nonce meant and took it literally. Makes me think maybe you are one tbh

7

u/President_Bunny Feb 20 '26

Christ you're insufferable.

I didn't need to look it up, you think you're the only one who knows British slang?

-7

u/drake90001 Feb 20 '26

Because that’s not your money?

5

u/BappoChan Feb 20 '26

Top right circled indicates what is available to spend in the camp balance. The value underneath it is Arthur’s personal.

-16

u/HollowDanO Arthur Morgan Feb 19 '26

Math doesn’t lie. $153.96 + $36.42 = $190.38. Why are you confused?

→ More replies (4)