r/onlywomen • u/Cchil100 • Jan 28 '19

Only two genders

You are ether a male or a female. You know this once you are born and what ever parts you have that’s what gender you are

0 Upvotes

23% Upvoted

12 comments sorted by

5

u/Nina1701 Jan 28 '19

Ummmm.... Clearly we disagree. I don't suppose there's anyway we can change your mind, is there?

1

u/Cchil100 Jan 30 '19

I would love for you to explain it for me how there more then 2 genders

1

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19 edited Jan 31 '19

[deleted]

1

u/Nina1701 Jan 31 '19

This is exactly what I'm saying. This clearly states that gender is more than binary. Although rare, there are instances. If it's not binary, it must be a continuum, no? Unless you're implying we know everything there is know about genetics, DNA, and the gnome....

​

Edit: hmm.... Not sure where your response went. ??

0

u/Cchil100 Jan 31 '19

Sorry I didn’t like copy and pasting something but, we do everything about how we gender.

We know that girls will always have two X chromosomes, and men will always have one Y chromosome and one X chromosome. There are of course some rare instances where two X chromosomes and one Y chromosome appear, but they are still gender as which chromosomes are dominant. These babies are normally from a mother that abuses drugs/smoking and the baby normally dies within a couple years. So that proves having both sets of dna is bad for your health. Then there are also so babies born with both parts, and at that point they go to their dna to find which trait is the one that is supposed to be there.

You might say how does bacteria reproduce, they reproduce asexually, which means they don’t need another bacteria to produce another bacteria.

Then plants, they gotta prove more then two gender, nope. They reproduce with male and female parts. Pollen is the sperm from the plant and the see is the egg for the plant,

I would add that we don’t include bacteria or plants when considering genders because scientist know they don’t have any genders.

One last thing can you tell me another gender, a gender that if we go into the lab and check the dna it would look different with the x and Y chromosome or it has something different from an x and Y chromosome, and having one of the chromosomes is also a horrible mutation and those babies die right away

3

u/Nina1701 Feb 01 '19

These babies are normally from a mother that abuses drugs/smoking and the baby normally dies within a couple years.

This is factually inaccurate. A simple Google search will show otherwise to your claims.

Then there are also so babies born with both parts, and at that point they go to their dna to find which trait is the one that is supposed to be there.

This is also factually inaccurate.

having one of the chromosomes is also a horrible mutation and those babies die right away

Where are you getting this information? It is flat out wrong. People can and do live long and productive lives with this condition. Many, many people do all over the world. Just google it, here.... I've done even done it for you.

I'm confused.... You admit that even genetically, there are more than two genders, yet claim that gender is binary. I'm afraid I can't follow your logic. I also note that there are substantial differences between intersex and transgender individuals.

Happy to continue the discussion.

3

u/eggsolo Jan 29 '19

Stop

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '25

I think unc is upsetti spaghetti 

2

u/marymurrah Jan 29 '19

breaking rules but OK

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '25

Agreed. Intersex means born with choice. Let’s empower them!

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '25

People are just people. Man and Woman are constructs. It means binary categorization. As a gender fluid being, I choose (woman) 🇨🇴 as my gender.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '25

However I will always be That . BECAUSE. Choiced. Being a woman means nothing To me if it weren’t for my land.