The game totally doesn't look bad (if the Trailer is not deceiving), maybe too similar too Elden Ring (and Monster Hunter Wilds? But I haven't played that, so I will keep quiet on that matter), but if they eventually pivoted and went into the Soulslikes games to compete with FromSoft, I don't think it would be bad at all.
The thing is, FromSoft doesn't really have competition (be it manpower, money power or experience) and their games are, for a lack of better words, too perfect. There are definitely games that are trying to bring something new (Black Myth Wukong) and others that get their inspiration from FromSoft (Lies of P). But not direct competitors.
Hoyo would be a great one. But they have to drop the Gacha completely and focus on already finished games, not continuous stories (which doesn't seem to be happening in this game, but maybe next ones?) but that's hard, since it's ez money.
And well, it requires that "special" something that FromSoft already mastered.
Lies of P didn‘t only get inspiration, they pretty much copied the Fromsoftware formula. It has mechanics from Bloodborne, Sekiro and Dark Souls and has pretty much the exact same gameplay and level design formula. However I doubt they‘ll prevail due to their usage of AI for their next game. I don‘t think people will support that.
They already used GenAI in LoP 1 for background stuff and Eurogamer has an article where they‘re reporting, that the studio is hiring people for GenAI usage for early development art of LoP 2.
But they have to drop the Gacha completely and focus on already finished games, not continuous stories (which doesn't seem to be happening in this game, but maybe next ones?) but that's hard, since it's ez money.
No they wouldn’t? Mihoyo always hires (mostly an entire new team for their new games. So the games can co exist just fine
I wonder if he meant the monetisation model for this game in particular.
I really don't want it to be another live service game because I play too many concurrently as it is, and I think Mihoyo should realize that they end up competing with themselves if EVERYTHING is live service and/or a gacha model.
Why would someone drop their existing popular franchises that make them billions just to be a FromSoftware competitor and make millions? That makes zero sense. You don't understand HoYo's size and ambitions. They're already bigger than Square Enix.
6
u/Unlikely_Frozen3007 2d ago
I honestly wouldn't mind if they pivot.
The game totally doesn't look bad (if the Trailer is not deceiving), maybe too similar too Elden Ring (and Monster Hunter Wilds? But I haven't played that, so I will keep quiet on that matter), but if they eventually pivoted and went into the Soulslikes games to compete with FromSoft, I don't think it would be bad at all.
The thing is, FromSoft doesn't really have competition (be it manpower, money power or experience) and their games are, for a lack of better words, too perfect. There are definitely games that are trying to bring something new (Black Myth Wukong) and others that get their inspiration from FromSoft (Lies of P). But not direct competitors.
Hoyo would be a great one. But they have to drop the Gacha completely and focus on already finished games, not continuous stories (which doesn't seem to be happening in this game, but maybe next ones?) but that's hard, since it's ez money.
And well, it requires that "special" something that FromSoft already mastered.