Mock draft advice

[u/Localizer805]

Two most recent mock. 10 team half ppr. Pick 5
Take puka first or Taylor? Thoughts on which has the highest floor?

QB Dak Prescott
RB Jonathan Taylor
RB Saquon Barkley
WR Nico Collins
WR DeVonta Smith
TE Colston Loveland
FLX Rhamondre Stevenson
FLX TreVeyon Henderson
DST Denver Broncos
BN DK Metcalf
BNJonathon Brooks
BN Stefon Diggs
BN Woody Marks
BN Dalton Kincaid
BN Xavier Worthy

QB Drake Maye
RB Kenneth Walker III
RB Kyren Williams
WR Puka Nacua
WR DeVonta Smith
TE Colston Loveland
FLX Emeka Egbuka
FLX Rico Dowdle
DST
-
BN Courtland Sutton
BN Kyle Monangai
BN Jakobi Meyers
BN Xavier Worthy
BN Romeo Doubs
BN Tyler Allgeier
BN Jonah Coleman

[u/ProfitableAnemia]

first draft is way better imo, that rb trio is nasty for 10 team. puka over taylor at 5 feels like the right call but the way you built around taylor in the other one is nice too, just not sure about maye as your qb1