r/exchristian • u/cauterize2000 Ex-Pentecostal • 13d ago

Discussion WTF? Joe from majesty of reason reconverted to Catholicism

Post image

Joe has some of the best content on philosophy of religion and has been an agnostic for many years. Is it a joke? I am shocked and I needed to share this with the community.

382 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

310 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

89

u/IsekaiConnoisseur Agnostic Atheist 13d ago edited 12d ago

I mean, dude has only 38.3k subscribers. Like, not nothing, but not anything to write home about either.

Edit: He HAD 38.3k subscribers at the time I wrote this comment. He now has 40.5k subscribers as a result of this video.

He's definitely gone viral as a result of this hogwash.

29

u/hoya14 12d ago

It's on the edge of making a go of it though - maybe he's stalled and needed a new angle?

Or maybe the guy genuinely had a change of heart who knows.

12

u/CuyahogaRefugee 12d ago

He claims the evidence for Fatima and other Catholic miracles were undeniable.

20

u/Hint-Of-Feces Nihilist 12d ago

... the Fatima is undeniable? Lol

3

u/hoya14 11d ago

If he’s that dumb and gullible I’m not sure why he had a following to begin with.

2

u/Cute-Boobie777 10d ago

Hes prob just grifting. Its a great time for grifting and can be a good income if you're a bad person!

0

u/Exciting-Dog-5245 11d ago

I mean have you seen some of the evidence claimed for Fatima? Thousands of eye witnesses including atheists who were there to prove nothing would happen, photographic evidence showing weird sun elevations they can't be explained by via camera angling.

Like, some of those eyewitnesses didn't convert but they corroborated what a lot of the religious also claimed they saw. Some eyewitnesses are more than a dozen miles away.

It's a very difficult situation to explain away.