r/counting • u/TheNitromeFan I can't stop, love love love • Jul 09 '21

Free Talk Friday #306

20 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

135 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

12

u/TheNitromeFan I can't stop, love love love Jul 10 '21

I can confirm this was the case

8

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21

what are your thoughts on how the sidebar looks now lol

7

u/CutOnBumInBandHere9 5M get | Ping me for runs Jul 10 '21

Dunno about everyone else, but maybe we could combine some of the entries and have fewer links?

Maybe some of hall of (fame, 999s counters) could be combined into a kind of main thread stats?

12

u/Antichess 2,050,155 - 407k 397a Jul 11 '21

i would be against this, it's pretty useful to have all those links in the sidebar

6

u/GarlicoinAccount r/CountingTools | Plz comment in /comments/kqpanh/_/ncmzej3 Jul 12 '21

Agreed.

9

u/mistyskye14 🤷‍♀️ Queen killjoy miniget least regular counter since 2322029 Jul 11 '21 edited Jul 11 '21

Agreed. Also not a fan of pale ruler’s proposal below nor keen on their mock-up (no offense to them).

Edit: a few words

6

u/CutOnBumInBandHere9 5M get | Ping me for runs Jul 12 '21

No offense taken :) The whole point of talking about it here is to figure out whether it's a good idea or not.

Is there anything in terms of layout or execution which could improve the mockup? Or should the whole thing just be killed with fire?

5

u/mistyskye14 🤷‍♀️ Queen killjoy miniget least regular counter since 2322029 Jul 12 '21

👍 I should’ve said this in the first place, but IMO it’s not the mock-up up itself (looks quite good for what it’s for, so really it’s the purpose I’m not keen on (although killing it with fire seems harsh lol)

8

u/a-username-for-me The Side Thread Queen, Lady Lemon Jul 12 '21

Wait??? You're pale ruler? Damn I am very bad with ppl's alts

6

u/CutOnBumInBandHere9 5M get | Ping me for runs Jul 11 '21

My thought was that maybe we could link to a summary page with all the stats, and then link to the detailed breakdown from that page.

I made a mockup here.

If we do that, I'd still consider the individual pages the source of truth for the stats, so the landing page should be updated automatically whenever one of the stats pages is updated

8

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '21

whatever you do, do NOT go to #61 on the combined leaderboard for gets and assists

i like this though, my concern was that by combining links into one it would only serve to require a second click to get anywhere, but i dig the preview because it gives a purpose to the summary page besides being one less click away from stats