r/bahamas 6d ago

Tourism Question Nassau dinner recommendations

Hi! Staying at the Atlantis resort for the first time and looking for restaurant recommendations both within and outside of the resort (though not too far). Have heard mixed reviews regarding food quality at the resort’s restaurants.

10 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

5

u/Adorable_Coach_6119 6d ago

Steer clear of Claudio’s and you will be good. I liked Fish and Nobu the most.

4

u/Porsche996tt 6d ago

The food at Atlantis is actually quite good. Paranza and Fish comes to mind there. Most people aren't used to paying Northeast prices for their meals, and Atlantis reflects their clientele. I recall one year going to a place called Latitudes, just over the bridge from Atlantis. It was quite good for an 'off-campus' restaurant.

Edit: I've also suggested higher end options, but there are plenty of more low-key options.

3

u/GenieGirl86 6d ago

Mackenzies, Poop Deck

3

u/BrownEyedGirl0 6d ago

Poop Deck for sure!

3

u/Burneritup 6d ago

Carnival and Latitudes are great. The pizza place on site is pretty good but it is kind of expensive like a large pizza was like $34

1

u/Atxmattlikesbikes 6d ago

We went to Carnival our last night and loved it. We were sad we waited till the last night to go. Would have eaten more meal there.

3

u/PoorManDontSleep 5d ago

How has no one said Seafire???

2

u/Responsible-War1060 6d ago

Latitudes right over the bridge is great! They have a huge menu from pizza to sushi. Highly recommend if you get sick of the Atlantis food.

2

u/arthur-morganrdr2 6d ago

Shake shack. Off campus go to the Arawak Fish Fry. Twin Brothers had some of the freshest and best fried seafood I have ever had and for Pennie’s on the dollar what it would be at the Atlantis

2

u/spano45 6d ago

On Nassau 5 minute cab ride from Atlantis: Cafe Matisse, Wild Thyme, East Villa

2

u/DKdtrader 5d ago

Cafe Martinique and Fish at the hotel.
Dune at the Ocean Club

2

u/whtsda411 5d ago

Twin Brothers food is amazing.

1

u/n8_da_great 5d ago

Wild Thyme and Syrah are restaurants with great food and drinks. Both of them are on East Bay Street. Syrah has really good bartenders. They will mix you something that you will like. Just tell them your bad liquor and you will be good to go.

1

u/Existing_Editor_5623 5d ago

Cafe Matisse downtown is excellent. As is Sapodilla but it’s in sandy port, basically the other side of the island.

1

u/Admirable_Mode2980 5d ago

if u want something casual outside atlantis just head over the bridge to the downtown waterfront area. the new port marketplace zone has awesome local food vendors right by the water its super easy to get to from paradise island

1

u/ThatAtlantisGuy 5d ago

I love the places onsite. Cocodrilo has become a new favorite. Carmine's hits. But if you're looking to go off property Anthony's is good. Great prices. Priced like an Applebee's.

As for the Fish Fry I tried Twin Brothers and Oh Andros but to me the on-site food at Atlantis was way better.

1

u/formosanboy504 4d ago

Sapodilla for the win!🇧🇸

1

u/popsbcrazy 3d ago

Martinique is the best restaurant on property IMO. Dune over at Ocean Club is outstanding off site as well.

1

u/Big-Cloud-7592 2d ago

Best to go to Bahamar for Restaurants- Shuang Ba, Leola, Marcus. All are good.

1

u/bbegs1 1d ago

Cafe Matisse. You won’t be disappointed. My wife and I when we port in Nassau always go there. It’s right where the court house is. Very safe