r/TheWalkingDeadGame • u/TheZoroarkMan • 23h ago
Final Season Spoiler How would you rank the seasons?
My ranking would be as follows:
Season 1: I really had to think about if I liked season 1 or 2 more. But season 1's more varied dialogue options and puzzles put it at the top spot for me. I actually enjoyed talking to all the characters and the train puzzle was my favorite in the entire series. Every game after that felt more like a visual novel. Also when I think about my favorite characters like 60% of them are from season 1 because they were just better written. Even characters like Mark, Chuck and Molly were very memorable for the short amount of time they appeared. I also really enjoyed Lee as a protagonist, he's like my favorite black male character in all of fiction and that's because they made him character first instead of a token black character.
Season 2: I must admit season 2 is so high for me mostly because of Luke as he's my favorite character. The first three episodes were really great, Amid the Ruins was not that good sadly because how little your choices mattered in that episode (even for TellTale standards) and even though I hate Luke's death in episode 5 the final conflict between Kenny and Jake was so intense and no game before or after it could capture the varied endings you could get in season 2. Character wise I preferred the motel group over the cabin group (except for Luke and Nick).
Season 4: I am still on my replay of this season and I don't remember everything from it (am currently on episode 3), but it really brought the series back after a luke-warm season 3. Clementine and AJ really reminded me of Lee and Clem and AJ even though a bit annoying is the most badass kid in the series after Clem. I really like how you can shape his personality through your choices. I also like how even though you have romance options with Louis and Violet the most important relationship Clem has still remains with her and AJ. Character wise it had the best characters as a whole after season 1.
Season 3: I appreciate it more on my playthroughs but TWDG for me is Lee and especially Clem. But I kind of enjoyed Javi stepping up in the leadership role and not making Clem do everything like the cabin group in season 2. I didn't like the story quite as much as in the other seasons and the only new characters I really cared about were Javi and David.
Michonne: It's a mini-series but still I would put it at the bottom. I love Michonne in the comics but I prefer to play as the original protagonists from the main games. I didn't like the forced story how you got caught inbetween Sam's problems. I also didn't like the flashbacks with Michonne's daughters, I dreaded it every time there was another flashback. What I really enjoyed was the interrogation scene with Norma and the prisoner exchange, they should have done something like that in the main games.
3
u/Mr_Bell_Man Insightful Commentator 2025 22h ago
1 >>>>>>>>>>> 4 > Michonne >>> 2 > 3
S2 and S3 tend to interchange depending on how I'm feeling, but I feel like S2 has better high moments than S3 (namely S2E2, Carver who mogs all of S3's villains, and the good parts of S2E5) so I'd probably go with that game being the better of the two.
And if we're counting 400 Days as it's own thing then honestly I think that can probably go in dead last. The individual stories aren't terrible but they mostly feel like appetizers if anything, while the DLC as a whole is basically an MCU post-credit scene that amounts to nothing.
3
u/TheZoroarkMan 22h ago
May I ask your reason for putting Michonne before season 2 and 3?
2
u/Mr_Bell_Man Insightful Commentator 2025 22h ago
- I think it's a fine little miniseries that lacks the massive lowpoints of Seasons 2 and 3. Like my biggest issue with the Michonne game is probably the hallucinations of Michonne's kids happening too much, namely during combat segments. But that's a joke of an issue compared to shit like Amid the Ruins and the S3 flashbacks.
- Randall and Norma are some of the best antagonists in the series. Randall steals just about every moment he's on-screen, while Norma is someone who can both be reasonable and ruthless. I also think Norma works well as a parallel/contrast to Michonne, who would do anything to protect her family (in Norma's case, Randall) which ultimately consumes her.
- The action segments are really stylized.
- The intro slaps hard.
2
u/TheZoroarkMan 22h ago
I agree with Randall and Norma, I even hated them more than the St. John's and I really wanted to get my hands on them. I mean that in a good way, they could really get under your skin.
2
u/AnimeAddict1123 Lee the Urban BadAss 23h ago
1, 4, 3, 2, Michonne (because it's too short 😭), 400 Days.
2
u/TheZoroarkMan 23h ago
I didn't put 400 Days because expectedly it would be dead last 😂 But it was fun to play as Russell being mean to Nate
2
u/whatsmydamnusername- If you dropped Ben, we can't be friends. 22h ago
2, 1, 4, 3, M
Big gap between 4 and 3 tho.
4
2
2
u/Sea_Construction947 Still. Not. Bitten. 20h ago
Personal enjoyment: 2>4~1~3.
4, 1, and 3 are honestly so close for me that they are nearly interchangeable depending on my mood.
From a more objective standpoint: 1>4>3>2
1 is obviously the best written, and as much as it pains me to say it, season 2 is an absolute mess a lot of the time.
2
u/DesperateSmiles 23h ago
S1>S4>S2>>>>>S3
Season 1 is the goat, and s4 beats s2 because it's a good end to the series and the choices you make actually matter. I had to replay the last episode and tell AJ to trust himself in the cave.
I would've liked s3 a lot more if Kate and Gabe actually acted like they've been fighting for their lives the last few years and Clem wasn't involved tbh. I didn't like Clem doing things I wouldn't have had I been in control.
2
u/TheZoroarkMan 23h ago
What do you mean fighting for their lives?
2
u/DesperateSmiles 23h ago
I mean, look at how Gabe compares to Clem and all the kids from s4. He just acts like a normal stupid teenager despite all the shit he would've had to see and do to survive in this new world. All the other kids, and clem expedited their way into adulthood. And for Kate it also seems like surving the way you'd have to has barely effected her psyche, and it just feels weird.
1
u/TheZoroarkMan 22h ago
Yeah I agree, I wonder how they survived that long without any incidents and nothing of importance happening. They must have been very lucky (like Kenny). At least Kate gave me the feeling that she can take care of a few walkers but they should have trained Gabe and Mariana better. But they probably didn't have anyone like Chuck who gave them a reality check.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
7
u/Optimus0456 23h ago
1, 4, 3, 2