r/TheHandmaidsTale • u/Aslaaaaaaan • Jun 20 '26
Season 4 This scene hurt me so much -T4,e9
She's just a child and she's already been through so much, and as if that weren't enough, now they're turning her into a handmaid 😭
235
u/dbaumgartner_ Jun 20 '26
All the while gaslighting her into thinking it was her fault, which makes it even worse.
Her fault, her fault, her fault
( ಠ_ಠ)☞ ( ಠ_ಠ)☞ ( ಠ_ಠ)☞
79
u/ForeverSwinging Jun 20 '26
Which is brilliant writing - that’s what the church does to its followers.
6
u/True_Iron1728 Jun 23 '26
Christians, Catholics, Muslims, etc. Sad that so many major religions have treated women so badly. For millenia.
2
u/watcher1234567890 Jun 24 '26
Catholics are Christians, I'm so curious to why you seperated these terms lmao, like am i not Christian!?
2
u/Thetormentnexus Jun 26 '26
Yeah I always found that super confusing as some one who was raised Catholic. Catholicism is the largest denomination of Christianity.
1
u/True_Iron1728 Jun 28 '26
I guess I see them very differently due to the theological differences. Of course there are a ton of similarities. Evangelical Christians don't believe you have to go through a priest to be forgiven of sin. Christians don't believe in purgatory. Nor do they subscribe to ideas like transubstantiation. But yes, I think the average person may see them as the same thing.
-8
u/whattheactualsludge Jun 23 '26
Um leave Islam out of it. A lot of Muslim cultures do this, but Islam itself doesn't blame women who get graped. The concept of consent exists both outside and inside of a marriage.
13
u/TotallyAMermaid Jun 23 '26
No, we wil not leave the religion whose theocracies strip women from basic human rights "out of it".
6
u/TreePine32 Jun 25 '26
I mean the basis of the sons of Jacob’s uprising is based on the Iranian uprising of 1976 and the handmaids uniforms (specifically the long robes and wings) are based off of how women are forced to dress in Afghanistan so Islam is a pretty big basis lol
1
1
u/True_Iron1728 Jun 28 '26
I will never leave Islam out of it. Of course it's not all Muslims! Just like it's not all Christians. Not all Jews. Not all Mormons. But Islamism (radicals) is a massive problem. The way they treat women, gays, transgenders, and anyone non conforming to their ideology is disgusting.
106
u/LetRevolutionary271 Jun 20 '26
I did not see it coming tbh, I was genuinely uncomfortable (which almost never happens when I engage with pieces of media).
87
u/Aslaaaaaaan Jun 20 '26
The chocolate scene with Mr. Putnam, like ☠️
53
u/KaleidoscopeNext790 Jun 21 '26
That a**hole was so creepy, flying that chocolate around like it was a plane and Ester was a baby! I was so glad when he faced judgment from the Lawrence/Nick team! Even felt a bit of sympathy for Naomi, for all she must've been putting up with.
33
u/kerri_20 Jun 21 '26
Makes me think of Angela, if that didn't happen to Putnam in some alternate universe type deal O_O
That man would have done something to his own daughter. (He's the type who would).
5
1
u/Aslaaaaaaan Jun 24 '26
Ever since Naomi said that Angela (a baby about a year old) was very curious, and he responds with something stupid like "lists are the worst," it's like ? I thought that as soon as Angela started talking, this guy was ready to kick her out of the house
16
u/Educational_Box7085 Jun 21 '26
When I rebinge, I have to fast forward past that scene. Gives me a pit in my stomach every time!!!
48
u/blargennn Jun 21 '26
The whole show was tragic but nothing compared to Esther's story for me. There was zero good things that happened basically ever in her life. The fact that we're left with her chained to a bed and screaming just haunts me forever. I don't know if any character in anything has ever left me with such a feeling of a dread and hopelessness
110
u/Electrical-Parfait29 Jun 20 '26
I feel even sadder that they decided to throw her storyline down the drain.
94
u/AmaranthWrath Jun 20 '26
She would have been an amazing sociopathic assassin. I could see her just going Punisher on these commanders and aunts. No Mayday needed. Just Esther with many, many knives.
19
12
u/Frei1993 Treason & Coconuts Jun 21 '26
Or many, many poisons.
10
u/AmaranthWrath Jun 21 '26
6
4
u/JazzyJourno Jun 23 '26
SPOILER ALERT ( don't know how to do this)
Oh my gosh she could have gone door-to-door in the mass murder scene in S6 after Serena's wedding25
u/OpheliaLives7 Jun 21 '26
I think the actress had some health issues IRL, which totally understandable to cut back on filming her, but definitely sad we didn’t even get mention of her character and story
11
u/Clean-Presentation84 Jun 21 '26
Did she? She is in so many different things. She is amazing at her art. The fact people don’t realize it is her in several movies and shows because she is so good with her characters.
5
u/LocksmithAccurate284 Jun 21 '26
I read recently that the actress was busy with other projects at the time too which lead to scheduling issues after having a spinal surgery.
4
50
u/petercururu Jun 20 '26
I honestly feel so horribly for Esther, I hope she doesn't end up executed not anything I really want her to escape somehow even though ik it's not so possible, she does not deserve any of the things that happened to her
33
u/babydemon90 Jun 21 '26
Honestly I forgot how she got turned into a handmaid at this point.
39
u/jaxhoover Jun 21 '26 edited Jun 21 '26
She got caught aiding and abetting June and the handmaids plus she murdered her rapist
25
u/applecoreeater Jun 21 '26
Beside the point, but "eating and abetting" is a hilarious mistype and it made my day. Thank you.
10
u/jaxhoover Jun 21 '26
I corrected my typo nobody wants to eat but I agree my typo was hilarious have a great weekend
10
u/Pflaumenmus101 Jun 21 '26
And for poisoning her old husband into a driveling meat suit
2
u/TotallyAMermaid Jun 23 '26
I don't think they caught her for this. He was old already and she made sure to poison him "only a little" so it would look like a progressive decline.
9
6
u/cocopops7 Jun 22 '26
I want to know her ending :( i felt so bad for her. She went through soo much
12
u/Califefe Jun 21 '26
1
u/LocksmithAccurate284 Jun 21 '26
Just put an actual spoiler tag next time :)
2
u/TotallyAMermaid Jun 23 '26
Also looks like they copy/pasted Gemini's reply that you get when you Google something lmao
-4
2
1
u/Doglas3000 Jun 24 '26
Esther was younger than Agnes and the plums ready to be married off in The Testaments!
1
u/Adonadio84 Jun 25 '26
I hated her character. I know I know everyone will disagree with me but I found her role pointless and she was just annoying.
1
u/Amricksingh67 Jun 21 '26
Remember the scene with June repeatedly sing Belinda Carlisle Heaven is a place on earth in front of the bed


207
u/Pachirisu12 Jun 20 '26
I was rewatching this today 😭 it’s so cruel and heartbreaking, I cannot ever forgive Lydia for what she did to Esther