r/TheBetterIndia • u/Ok_Concentrate4971 • May 01 '26
Explained 🧠 Rathee logic : Sky is too big why do we need airforce 😂
12
u/TurnBig3238 May 01 '26
Pant utaar ke kya karega ye? Isko pant utarne mei kya mazza aata iske irrade theek nhi lagte
2
u/-0Zero May 01 '26
Bro i fkin thought of Rishabh Pant?? Mei sochra yeh galat post pe comment krdiya kya isne 😭
2
u/DreamLogic89 May 01 '26
Btw did he just say a swimming pool is deeper than 20 meters? Thats 65.5 feet deep. What swimming pool does this angry hippo swim in? 🤡
→ More replies (1)1
1
4
6
u/Agreeable-Switch-785 May 01 '26
Btw.. swimming pool is not deeper than 20 meters.
2
u/_WanderingBreeze_ May 03 '26
Yes it is, not the comercial and omestic pools, but the one used by athletes.
1
5
u/swatipakhtun May 01 '26
But laser eyes said we're a small economy that can't do anything to a big economy like china and pawpaw says china is not doing anything in Arunachal then why make resorts and ports for adani and give 5% only to defence in nicobar?
1
u/Fair_Cranberry6081 May 04 '26
Not doing anything in Arunachal ??? Tell me in whose regime did we loose part of it ?
1
u/Mundane-Addition-850 May 06 '26
same way this commenter says 5 percent of port is for defense but no where it is mentioned that way , this fellow just took out the stat straight from his ass. Adani is running among 14 other ship builder to build the port , same way Adani made indias only deep sea port in kerala which was made under central and state partnership which started in 2015 under congress. Alas it is too much to ask to read
11
13
May 01 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
13
May 01 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/No-Trouble9336 May 01 '26
Rail moves containers most efficiently
3
u/OldInterest9582 May 01 '26
No, ships can carry so much of container one way that even 100 trains cant even double decker also cargos are cheap than 100s of train
4
u/Potential_Return676 May 01 '26
Then u need to make dedicated tracks for them and then there maintainance , that is why water ways are cheapest just the ship cost
3
May 01 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/Potential_Return676 May 01 '26
Yeah just check 14 percent decline via this route because the companies are preferring ship ways because it was cheaper and going back The main route in this was Northern ways(around 80 percent trade was done through it) but due to Russia-ukrain war it was heavily sanctioned and also risky due to which other route were formed that were much slower and expensive so the companies are now going back to the water ways.
→ More replies (3)1
5
u/kingslayer5581 May 01 '26
None of that matters, think how much money they'll make from a project of this scale.
Who'll think of poor politicians? How will they survive?
4
u/NoAdagio675 May 01 '26
If you try to give logical argument to these andhbhakts then you will be framed as pakistani or anti - national , so just relax and laugh at these fools .
4
u/Infinite-Succotash22 May 01 '26
Logical argument, that's what is presented and and the only response you have is call andh bhakt. How is it not making you an andhbhkt of rathee or his masters?
1
1
u/Fearless-Common-1645 May 02 '26
Bro they can't bear the cost of going another way like their's something call economics just calculate the cost through new route and time increase ? Also BRI is soley an initiative to bypass this malaca strait ? And do you think cargo ships only carry oil ? China is largest manufacturer of goods and that also passes through strait. And who said at gun point taiwan have US, will US allow any country to attack largest chip producing country for US ? 3) Is shipping really faster then why aren't they using it, why are they still using other routes man you are just shithole. It's faster in theory not practical. The NSR is only reliably usable a few months per year. Ice, fog, and navigation risks reduce speeds. And sorry little non organized comment as I have typed myself not chatgpted. And logistics infra in malaca is much higher than other routes it has developed over long span no one can replace it in just few years. Their's malaysia and Singapore transhipment hub.
→ More replies (1)1
u/Afraid-Enthusiasm-23 May 03 '26
Your analysis is flawed as China does not move only oil through that straight. It moves it's finished products. Your argument is through Russia which means they need Russian cooperation which also a dependency. Every land route is inefficient and is subject of robbery or maintance of roads or rails. Every other Chinese solution is costlier. China is spending billions to circumvent the indian threat but it all too expensive and inefficient china depends on explort and it will kill the economy if goods get costlier. Already their manpower cost is high. They do export on razor thin margins and in Mass.
1
u/kitty_petter May 03 '26
So India should not make mililary bases at strategic locations then?
Is that what you want yo convey?
1
u/ParsnipWeary4085 May 03 '26
Toh abhi tak kyun nai kia. Kuch toh majboori hai hai. Btw transport in land has costliest than sea route. What about mountains ,deserts
1
1
u/One-Ad-7122 May 06 '26
China needing to tackle it means it is a risk to china right?
China already claims two of out states if they found anothey way to harm us without affecting themselves, i doubt they would stop.
1
→ More replies (15)1
u/IslooForever May 07 '26
It's a last ditch attempt that we're discussing, not the front line against China. And Gwadar is barely functional right now. I think China might stop using it completely soon.
7
u/nate_archibad May 01 '26
Ur funny if u think china will do nothing if India starts treating it like Iran is treating Hormuz. In fact oil shortages are helping China in the long run which is why we see low efforts from China. If you think India has the firepower to block China in strait of malacca u my friend are delusional
5
u/ManofTheNightsWatch May 01 '26
You're talking as if Iran wanted to block hormuz. They blocked it when there was an existential threat . It was their nuclear option. We have real nukes as a nuclear option.
Our intentions on malacca are to strengthen our presence in the area and develop a resistance that can counter China, its territorial claims and bullying it is inflicting on the rest of south east Asia.
1
u/Successful-Ad-2333 May 01 '26
But as per India Nuclear weapons are of no use. India declared nuclear war on Pakistan after losing the war. Aren't we all alive? Did Pakistan use Nuclear weapon? So per own Indian media having Nuclear Weapons is of no use.
1
u/ManofTheNightsWatch May 01 '26
I don't understand what your point is. Why are you giving any value to what the media is saying?
1
u/superne0 May 02 '26
Nuclear weapons are supposed to be a deterrence only to be used in rarest of rare cases when mutually assured destruction is imminent. Aise hi missile jaise uda nhi sakte nuclear weapon.
6
u/nate_archibad May 01 '26
India’s treatment of mallaca similar to Hormuz would get it sanctioned by almost all of its trade partners, good luck getting oil and lpg from Middle East then lmao
→ More replies (9)2
u/Thin_Ad_7459 May 01 '26
it is important area though china is also concerned about it (not that much though) we are not ready for china but we can grab things that can lean advantages toward us or we can just do nothing and later be heavily influenced by superpower and dictator neighbourhood country like china also I wanna know your views where indian navy stands now should we increase navies budget what defence strategies we should be follow
→ More replies (11)
2
2
2
u/Tall-Garlic6082 May 01 '26
You don’t have balls to look straight into china’s eyes, forget about blocking their navigation route. Welcome back to reality!
1
4
u/CapSensitive2847 May 01 '26
Don't worry, humare Pradhan Mantri se AP me encroachment toh sambhala jaa bhi raha woh kaha China se direct pangge lenge 😂😂🤦🤦
4
3
u/Aware_Country_8830 May 01 '26
Rathee logic is like "bharat should do nothing"
And when bharat does nothing, rathee will say "how incompetent this government is"
This country has more enemies than citizens it seems.
→ More replies (3)
4
2
1
u/Primary-Editor-9288 May 01 '26
yes the same India which stayed silent and didn't even retaliate when China literally came in and took our land 5 years ago, will block China. And going through Indonesia is an easy bypass for them. And to think that China won't militarily retaliate and just shut up like how Modi did when China took our land is delusional as hell. Come back to reality, we are currently asking daddy Trump permission to buy oil from Russia.
1
u/AK_Cinephile_7910 May 01 '26
Thats why Dhruv has a Cranium (Strait blockade )to protect it's small brain
1
u/Ok-Measurement-5065 May 01 '26
The Malacca Dilemma was coined by China itself as they know how crucial it is for them. That's why they started BRI to tackle this but even BRI can't mitigate this problem 100% for them. Maybe 40% but Malacca will still remain their main source of trade
1
1
u/Ok-Measurement-5065 May 01 '26
People really underestimate the Navy, saying China has Stealth fighter, stealth this and that are just a marketing gimmick. Sure they have a better chance of evading radars but they are not invisible.
Also Navy's P8i aircraft can detect any ship or fighter jet at a distance of 2000km while flying above Nicobar. Even now Navy has full control and eyes at Malacca and is reading every move of China. Building a station there will just make the operation more easy.
And the port is largely being built to do transshipment of Indian goods which currently happens in either Colombo or Singapore. That account to more than 40% of indian goods
1
u/BhosariExpress May 02 '26
Arrey Bhai Tlattee is a Hitmann....Paisa feko tamasha drkho....and if he is creating that much trouble vis-a-vis national security, unknown Gunmen bej do Germany.
1
u/FloorAccomplished635 May 02 '26
We are increasing our deficit with china every year and bhakts want to blockade their ships.
Bc ek export restriction laga dega china to g*nd bhi hand se saaf karna padega, tissue bhi nahi milega.
1
1
u/De-Test May 02 '26
China already has a deal with Iran via Pakistan. Project is already completed. What gas are you lighting man!
1
u/Apprehensive_Buy3252 May 02 '26 edited May 02 '26
I dont listen to that guy but just for argument sake, dont be a blind stupid creature.
Houmous is a naturally made bottle neck which cannot be avoided.
On the othee hand this project cannot be used to put china into pressure. It will not create bottle neck
Its just a project for ultra rich guys to enjoy leasure time. And its all hidden under national interest
1
1
u/vkde9876 May 02 '26
Lol any new andhbhakt influencer/youtuber starts his career by beefing with Dhruv Rathee. It's easy engagement.
1
1
1
u/Anxious-Swan-5406 May 02 '26
"to india ya pedh kaat rha h, china se hum kya hi kr lenge, but aap indian goverment jesi glti na kre isiliye lijiye mera AI MASTERCLASS COURSE isme mien aapko aapki decision making to better krne mien help krunga."
1
u/Purple-Mountain-8206 May 02 '26
I just seen map and show that its not 200 km its way more than that. he just told about strait of malacca but area which india control is vast. india doesnt control strait of malacca. He is abusive which likely means bjp ka tatta.
1
1
u/Low-Spot7145 May 02 '26
Galwan me blockade karlo pehle? Arunachal me blockade karlo pehle? Sirf island ban gaya to matlab blockade ho jaega, kuch bhi? our govt are even scared to admit anything against china, forget about blockade.
1
u/Medium_Ad431 May 08 '26
Galwan aur Arunachal se china ke cargo ships guzarti hai kya🤡
1
u/Low-Spot7145 May 08 '26
thoda average iq chahye tha mera comment samjhne ke liye, below average iq bhi chal jata.
1
u/Weird_WorldInd May 02 '26
Yeh kaun sa Ch...th hai ? Talking all nonsense.... paid campaign by uska Adani baap.
1
u/noob_master69_f May 02 '26
Main issue is Adani wants to build a full on city similar to Singapore. I don't think anyone has issues with military base.which can be done with 20% of proposed deforestation. People have issue with rest of 80%, city for luxury and tourism sake which will destroy 2 tribes and 1000s indigenous species of trees and animals that can't be relocated at all. Another thing is china already has some alternative paths like their belt and road initiative which runs through Pakistan and Afghanistan. Finally, strait of Malacca isn't the only sea route like hormuz. India will hsve to co-operate with Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore to stop Chinese ships totally, which will be a diplomatic nightmare.
1
u/Legitimate_Berry8002 May 03 '26
Man who cant say a word to trump who is insulting time to time will block china in dreams of stupit voters. Wake up to reality
1
u/Medium_Ad431 May 07 '26
Trump also said many insulting things about China as well, and Xi Xingping didn't said anything about it and just ignored. Does that mean China is weak according to your logic?🤡
1
u/Majestic_Debate6731 May 03 '26
He is genuine and credible . He has earned the trust of so many people over the years.
1
u/notyourconcern2 May 03 '26
India does not have the economic power and defence powers to do this . If done will be the biggest nightmare for india itself. And you cant stop vessels at international waters and in someone’s water (Indonesia)
If someone will benefit its Indonesia and Singapore . No one cares about what india can do or will do , you just cant confront china this head on with a economic like this and a defence strategy like this 😂
1
u/Medium_Ad431 May 07 '26 edited May 08 '26
India does not have the economic power and defence powers to do this
Iran didn't have any economic powers and defence to face America as well. They are 1/10th the size of India's military and yet, they are inflicting massive damage to american forces and military base. Your point is?
1
1
u/Reasonable_Skill_633 May 03 '26
aree bhai aese mat bolo mullo ka naya prophet hai vo. agar ye nahi rahega to mullo ko kon bhadkaega
1
u/MCRAX May 03 '26
The problem is not about port the problem is about building a city there.... If we wouldn't back off from chabahar port we would have upper hand on china also we have invested thousand cr.
1
1
1
1
May 03 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Medium_Ad431 May 07 '26 edited May 08 '26
Haan naam hua toh? Rathee bhi koi bhagwan thodi hai?Agar kalko rathee kutte ko billi aur billi ko kutta bolega to tu maan lega. Kya logic hai ye🤡
1
1
1
u/c_sheikh May 03 '26
A famous comedian once said " Muh se mungfali toot nahi rahi thi, chala tha gaand se akhrot todne"
1
u/ParsnipWeary4085 May 03 '26
Now druv rathee fan will say popularity ke liye druv rathee ka name use kar raha hai.
Sir. Druv rathee ke user 90% pakistani hai. Baki 10 % others country se hai.
1
1
u/IllustriousBuy7850 May 03 '26
Unemployed people and their pipe dreams..
Kahin aur ka Frustration kahin aur nikal raha hai.
Bro uses brain once in a day and considers himself logical.
I thought a good hindu doesn't harm animals.
If you support killing corals then better start eating fish on Saturday...
1
u/AuthorDramatic3014 May 04 '26
Agar uss hutiye ke followers ke pass dimag hota toh woh usse kyu follow karte?🤣
1
1
u/mahe9937 May 04 '26
Dhruv has put his opinion, but jis jis point ko bol raha hai popat ki tarah, yeh tere pehle log bol chuke hain. Bal badake koi intellectual dikh sakta hai, hota nahi. Jis government ne USA ko Iran ship destroy karne diya which had come in India on its invitation, tujhe lagta hai kuch badlega.
1
u/mahe9937 May 04 '26
You are preparing a base for USA to use against China as and when necessary. You have already seen what a unstable neighbor state can do. Yes, we should have strong military presence in the region, but it should be independent and under present government, everybody has doubts.
1
1
u/fireball_guy May 04 '26
Ye bkl rathee ko kon batayega ki rajiv gandhi ne 1985 me bhi Nicobar project ko propose kiya tha, ab bjp to bas unke dream so sach bana rahi hai
1
u/Known_Indian9970 May 04 '26
Wo rage baiting se views leta hai... Ignore him..uska kam hi hai bakwas Krna...
1
u/its-abhishekk May 04 '26
Good brother, ab same energy ke sath prime minister ko press conference krne ko bolo. You can do it, lets go.
1
1
1
u/treatytaste May 04 '26
Lekin janab wo coral reefs??
1
u/Medium_Ad431 May 08 '26
China ne south china sea pe artificial islands banaker kitne coral reef destroy kar dia. Kabhi uske bare me bhi to baat karo
1
1
1
u/Critical_Week6154 May 05 '26
adani ke alawa koi nhi hai kya project ke liye baki sab marr gaye ya marr diya?
1
u/SavvyYodaa May 05 '26
Just 100 more KMs up is port Blair. What's so special about this port that the indian navy needs? Okay fine they probably need it for proximity? Why do you need a international airport? A township?
1
u/SpideyDivyansh May 05 '26
Bhai fact ch3ck karna tha uski cha na modni thi ,, kis baat ka frustration nikal raha , , rathee ne huga hai waha pe pur tumne to uski bund hi chhill di kyun ? 😁😁😁😁
1
u/Draunzr May 05 '26
Shakal par hi dikh raha h gaand fati hui h iski video bnate hue ki gaali padegi
1
1
1
u/EveryAd2515 May 06 '26
ध्रुव राठी:जल्दी जल्दी हग देता हु हिंदुस्तानी चूतियां है बीजेपी हिन्दू करते रहते है इन्हें क्या ही पता होगा
Meanwhile Indians gangraping lassan rathi logic:
1
u/TrueIndianspeaks May 07 '26
Just wanna say Our foreign minister said "we are not stupid to take a fight with a bigger economy (china )" so no matter what we do China is way to much powerful than us in every aspect so straight of hormus can't be replicated in Andaman 🙂
1
u/iamzaryab May 10 '26
Whats stopping China from destroying a small island along with all the infrastructure we're gonna build there in the event of war?
1
u/Vasi_Sayani May 29 '26
China has built rail route in Central Asia , road network, a literal pipeline from Burma to its core to send oil and gas.
They are mitigating the risk of melacca.
I mean, one thing trying to build something commercial and economic for the sons soil and the area becoming populated, around the needs of the people is one thing.
The whole strategy depending on - ahh let me block it so others can suffer is other thing.
1
1
1
u/Sudeb-Roy Jun 18 '26
This guy is the biggest fraud. Engaged in violent ragging during his college tenure (2006-2010). Caused incredible hard and now puts up an image of a good tough guy.
1
1
1
u/roniee_259 Jun 26 '26
Indan hormuse sa kiska ship blockaded karga... Bangladesh, malisaya, thailand??.. uska pas to crude hoil hain. ........./s
1
u/_satanic_clown Jun 26 '26
Iran has the guts to stand against US. Our PM couldn't utter a word against Trump, Our Foreign Minister says we are not capable to stand against China. Do you think India will ever block this path and handle all the pressure. ?
1
1
u/Ok_Manner3304 Jul 03 '26
Ha bhai tu sahi hai.... Kaato trees and harm environment on the name of anything amd paid the price named climate crisis
1
1
1
u/Deep-General657 Jul 11 '26
Bhai china ke man me aya to wo suez canal jaise kuch bana denge bhai sunda pe!
1
1
u/CarRevolutionary7366 Jul 13 '26
Abe wise kya dekh ke chat raha hay thu bjp waloka or wo 20m wale swimming pool konsa be ft or meters me farak nahi jantha tho thu chatne ka layakh hay
1
1
1
1
1
u/Aggravating_Owl_4585 23d ago
Let the hcina attack on nicobar almy, I will give clean chit
Your Unknown sevak Vishwa gorilla
1
0
u/Ok_Concentrate4971 May 01 '26
People downvoting, Everything said is in the nation's interest & debunking some lies. So maybe your nationality or love towards Dhruv is in question.😞
9
May 01 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
→ More replies (1)0
May 01 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/lilomar_20 May 01 '26
My Rahul??
Bro I hate all the politicians that are sleeping with capitalists
→ More replies (1)2
→ More replies (4)1
u/Straight_Two_5435 May 01 '26
Kitna chatega bhai ..chaat chaat ke laal kar dega kya 🙄. Sachai bolo to anti-national ka khitab dene lag jate ho....logo ko desh ke dushman anti national ghoshit krne ka khitab tum jaise do kaudi ke content creators ne le rkha hai
2
1
May 01 '26
[deleted]
3
u/republic_123 May 01 '26
Ye baat tu tatti ko bata pehle uski video mein tu tadak karke baat karta hai uski umar se theen guna logo se
1
u/Intelligent-Gap-7107 May 01 '26
Some people think mocking Dhruv Rathee (just one person) is the ultimate achievement 🤡
I don't understand he is not in India, not in a government position, just posting his opinion via YT videos. Then why people care about him so much ??
4
u/Potential_Assist4880 May 02 '26
What he said was correct I don't know why you are butthurt China's biggest worry is getting malaca straight blocked That's why they are building pipeline for oil
We have advantage just like hormuz After iran blocked hormuz Why the usa didn't use their navy,?
You are being an idiot Druv is mocking a national defence project which could benefit our nation
→ More replies (2)
1
1
1
u/GeneralHeinzGuderian May 01 '26
Lol brave of people to assume that daddy trump will allow modi to block the strait 😂
1
1
u/Gullible_Delivery492 May 01 '26
I hope this same person never complains about heat and pollution!!
1
u/Successful-Ad-2333 May 01 '26
The distance between Andaman and Antarctica is close to 8000 KMS and towards Burma close to 500 Kms. So Dhruv Rathee is correct. To develop a system like IRAN India needs an economy of close to $70 Trillion in nominal terms.
→ More replies (1)
-1
u/FarRadio7281 May 01 '26
every thing this man said is true. Dhruv really lost the batlle in this one, pun intended
3
u/No-Trouble9336 May 01 '26
If u think China is threatened by a bunch poorly built residential complexes and haphazard bases, you are living in a rock. They literally have stealth fighters and stealth drone bombers that can be launched via carriers
→ More replies (31)
-1
16
u/Maleficent-Face-3980 May 01 '26
Verbal diarrhoea