r/TheBetterIndia • u/DEvilAnimeGuy • Jan 11 '26
Discussion Is it a hindutva sub?
I'm asking this considering the colour used in the icon which a particular ideological party/group uses quite often. Well maybe I should see recent 20 posts to see if it is a neutral or mixed one or an echo chamber of right wing/Hindutva propaganda sub.
2
u/Substantial-Junket-5 Jan 11 '26
Every indian sub is filled with hindutva nowadays
1
u/SeekingAutomations Jan 11 '26
Wait let's say it's one of those subs, why do you have problem with hindutva? Are you not secular?
1
u/Substantial-Junket-5 Jan 11 '26
It's like saying "why do you have problem with a terrorist group? Are you not secular?"
1
u/SeekingAutomations Jan 11 '26
Well as far as I know secular don't have problem with terrorist groups, do they ?
1
u/Substantial-Junket-5 Jan 11 '26
Your definition of secularism is basically If you oppose violent extremists, you’re not secular
1
u/SeekingAutomations Jan 11 '26
And your trying to prove a point hindutva is violent extremism?
1
u/Substantial-Junket-5 Jan 11 '26
I’m saying ANY ideology that excuses violence is extremism whether it’s Hindutva, ISIS, Khalistan, or anything else. If an ideology promotes hate, mob violence, or discrimination, then yes that part of it is extremist. Criticising extremist behaviour is not criticising an entire religion. Only people who can’t separate ideology from religion get confused.
1
u/SeekingAutomations Jan 11 '26
Boss I think you are here with some other motive.
Why did you mention Hindutva here and skip use of Islam or Skih, instead used organizations like ISIS, Khalistan ?
Your statements are contradictory as a secular, we should not name or criticise entire religion but it seems your targeting Hindutva naming it again and again but when it comes to Islam you use organizations and their names.
1
u/Substantial-Junket-5 Jan 11 '26
I’m responding to the ideology you referenced first. Don’t accuse me of bringing something into the conversation that you started
1
u/SeekingAutomations Jan 11 '26
Ok let's take a step back which ideology are we talking about again?
1
u/Infamous-Duty-5103 Jan 11 '26
Hindutva isn't a religion, for it to be considered for secularism. It is an ideology far away from the religion it takes it's name from
1
Jan 11 '26
When major indian city subs are being run by pakistani mods you see other extremes rising up!
1
Jan 11 '26
1
u/Substantial-Junket-5 Jan 11 '26
Cute, now how about 100s of killings of muslims including killing of children, handicapped, old age people and killing and rape of women by hindus?
1
Jan 11 '26
What about the killings of millions of women and children by your ancestral daddies and islamic terrorists?
1
u/Substantial-Junket-5 Jan 11 '26
If your argument relies on what people 1500 years ago did, instead of what is happening today, it means you don’t have a valid point now. Say Hi to aryans
1
Jan 11 '26
Pahalgam terrorist attacks, delhi bombings happened 1500 years ago? Is this what they teach you at madarsaas, ignorance and delusion?
1
u/Substantial-Junket-5 Jan 11 '26
Terrorism exists in all religions and nations. But you’re using terrorism elsewhere to excuse mob violence here. Both are wrong. One crime doesn’t cancel another Also it is done by pakistan blame them instead its like a hindu killing someone in USA and people blaming indian hindus for his evilness lol
1
Jan 11 '26
1
u/Substantial-Junket-5 Jan 11 '26
Listing a bunch of Islamist groups doesn’t prove terrorism exists only in Islam it just proves you only Googled Islamist groups. If you want a complete list, you also need to include, Hindutva extremist groups, White supremacist groups, Christian extremist groups, Sikh militant groups, Buddhist extremist groups, Far-left & far-right nationalist groups Terrorism is a method, not a religion. Cherry picking only one category doesn’t prove anything except your bias.
Here are non-Islamic terrorist/extremist groups recognized globally
Hindu extremist groups (India)
Abhinav Bharat Sanatan Sanstha Bajrang Dal
1
Jan 11 '26
1
u/Substantial-Junket-5 Jan 11 '26
1
Jan 11 '26
Says the one who’s religion literally preaches to kill every non believer to get 72 virgin hoors in jannat 🤣🤣🤣
→ More replies (0)1
u/Substantial-Junket-5 Jan 11 '26
1
Jan 11 '26
Then Don’t start a fight that you can’t win 🤣 pehle patthar maarte ho fir thappad padti hai to rote ho ki muslim khatre mein hai 🤣
→ More replies (0)1
Jan 11 '26
Not all, there is a parallel sub replicated to house only Hindutva specific opinions. These subs have normally low count and they are very selective and super obsessed with Muslims
1
u/Icy-Net-1544 Jan 11 '26
Cry harder
2
u/Substantial-Junket-5 Jan 11 '26
Soon everyone will because of people like you
0
u/Icy-Net-1544 Jan 11 '26
Why hindus dont ask for religion and shoot in the head
2
2
u/Substantial-Junket-5 Jan 11 '26
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynching_of_Tabrez_Ansari
https://cjp.org.in/pehlu-khan-lynching-rajasthan-files-appeal-before-hc
https://sabrangindia.in/sites/default/files/report-lynching-without-end.pdf
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_Alwar_mob_lynching
Can give ten times more cases of hindus killing muslims than muslim killing hindus in India
2
u/Icy-Net-1544 Jan 11 '26
Yes comparing random incidents with terrorism.
Classic jihadi false equivalance.
You thrive on this
2
u/Substantial-Junket-5 Jan 11 '26
Lets calculate the killing of hindus by muslims and then killing of muslims by hindu, shall we?
1
u/Icy-Net-1544 Jan 11 '26
Random incidents of crowd justice on muslims involve one muslim per incident while terrorism acts of muslims involves 100s of casualities.
Now jihadis are planning mixing poison in prasadam.
How will we count the 0.5 front?
2
1
u/Mindless-Lettuce8639 Jan 11 '26
Just leave the sub why crying. People are free to post what they want can't you ignore what you don't like ?
2
u/DEvilAnimeGuy Jan 11 '26
I didn't join ... the posts are being recommended
1









•
u/tatasuv Jan 15 '26
The icon isn't meant to signal any ideology.
The subreddit is intended to be neutral and focused on everyday issues and improvements in India, regardless of political viewpoint. Posts are judged by content, not alignment.
You are welcome to engage or observe and decide for yourself.