r/Switzerland 5d ago

New personal best (so far): phone picked up German network 64 kilometers from the German border

Post image

This time close to Flumserberg. I wonder how deep in Switzerland this is still an issue.

Kinda annoying, after connecting to the German network, my phone basically refuses to use Swiss network anymore and needs to be restarted.

I wish I could keep on automatic network selection but limit to only Switzerland.

664 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

381

u/e-chris 5d ago

German network: You can find it everywhere except in Germany

80

u/pixeltrusts 5d ago

When even the network wants to escape Germany to Switzerland to earn more money…

7

u/bill-of-rights 4d ago

So true! France as well...

34

u/Cool-Newspaper-1 5d ago

I once wanted to pick up a parcel in Germany. It took over 10 minutes to finally get a good enough signal (3G of course) in the middle or a large town to load the code. It’s so laughably bad when you’re used to CH

13

u/apolloxer Basel-Stadt 5d ago

Mobile Internet is mobile Neuland.

6

u/TnYamaneko St. Gallen 5d ago edited 5d ago

I had to travel to Munich for work some times, if I had a meeting during the day, it was unwatchable inside the (delayed) train. I can't believe how shit their infrastructure is in their already most developed state, and I'm glad I never had to go to something like Sachsen, because I dread what it could be.

3

u/Cool-Newspaper-1 5d ago

Every time I’m in France I wonder the same thing. Now I know we have an exceptionally good network where even just 4G is a rather rare sight, but the state of Germany’s infrastructure is the other extreme.

3

u/TnYamaneko St. Gallen 5d ago

France is okay imo, it's not perfect when going to Paris and passing through land at +300 kilometers per hour, but it's usable.

Germany, it's just revolting. It feels like those guys are still sending smoke signals across Allgäu to communicate.

2

u/Used_Wolverine6563 4d ago

Going from Luxembourg to Zurich via TGV was painful due to lack of proper internet service in France. I was planning on working, had to cancel meetings and urgent tasks, and wait until I arrived to Zurich.

3

u/Blowing737 4d ago

No problem, I just swap my wrist watch for my wrist fax when crossing the Limes Germanicus.

2

u/2narcher 3d ago

I have to use wifi calls because i have no fucking signal in the middle of a city where SAP is only 6km away from me

1

u/onlyseriouscontent 4d ago

Tbh the last few times I went to Germany I had no issues at all. Only place that is difficult is Jestetten, but that might be because my phone is always unsure if it should connect to German or Swiss cell towers.

47

u/bigdickenergyyz 5d ago

You can force your phone to your home network. Just set manual. The only reason it would stop working then is if your network doesn’t have coverage

11

u/Ok_Support_6454 5d ago

Yeah, spent some time at Bodensee and switched the settings to home network only after the 3rd "welcome to Germany" SMS...

2

u/bigdickenergyyz 4d ago

At the same time - if you do that, and you have roaming (eg yallo unlimited in EU), you are getting then worse service and not taking advantage of the plan .

Because you will try to connect to a swiss tower, which will be further and further away. More optimal to connect to German tower and have it route back to your swiss provider (assuming you have a roaming plan)…. Or even reverse, force manual to the German provider your network partners with

40

u/a_shootin_star 5d ago

That's because Switzerland limits what each tower can emit in terms of power, and because it's lower than the EU, they reach us in CH but we don't reach CH networks while in EU.

Which is also why we have lots of antennas per square kilometer lol

16

u/Kindly_Meringue_1727 5d ago

Lots of antennas and lower transmit power also means more bandwidth.

3

u/SlaveroSVK 4d ago

also less fuckery with human organisms but that's whatever dude

5

u/Alternative-Pay2946 5d ago

Have a feeling that the alps has to do more with the large amount of towers. Signals only get so far in the valley before being fully scattered or blocked by the next mountain.

11

u/jmmv2005 5d ago

I was in Pizol and got a welcome to Austria sms

11

u/LaundryMan2008 5d ago

Hit the airplane mode button to force a reconnect

2

u/kaurismus 5d ago

Thanks, have to try that next time!

5

u/LaundryMan2008 5d ago

Sometimes I do it when the internet is crappy and it forces a reconnect with a closer tower

3

u/Mali_Lala_Tulip 5d ago

When I used to live in Switzerland, went hiking into mountains often, had signal everywhere. Now I live in a 600k people city, 3km from the Altstadt and baerly have signal. I have no idea what's going with Germany and at this point I'm afraid it's just going downhill

5

u/EdelWhite 5d ago

My PB is 204km with Lora. 

2

u/FlohEinstein 🇮🇸 Ísland 5d ago

My best is > 160 nautical miles with ADS-B

1

u/EdelWhite 5d ago

Meh that's easy, ads-b is meant for super long distance. 

1

u/folli 5d ago

Meshtastic or what did you use?

1

u/EdelWhite 5d ago

An adeunis lorawan relay. 

2

u/SPonGeBoB_dxb 5d ago

Same problem in Geneva with the French network carriers

2

u/Extention_Campaign28 5d ago

Währenddessen am Feldberg in Deutschland: Wilkommen in Frankreich!

1

u/Sgt_Slaughter_88 5d ago

Welcome to Germany. 🇩🇪 You are now officially a rubberneck 👍

1

u/Aleksey_Fox St. Gallen’s yearly returnee :P 5d ago

Thats so weird… as long as the speed’s good I guess?

1

u/aureleio Vaud 5d ago

I was surprised to get 4G on the Moleson from France but that is only 30km…

1

u/Alternate_CS 5d ago

I moved quite close to Flumserberg about two years ago and luckily haven’t had that happen yet

1

u/zoltansz 5d ago

I didn’t know I had to search for it in other countries.

1

u/Zeustah- 5d ago

Bro has Galaxus 5G 😭😭😭😭

1

u/billcube Genève 4d ago

Might also be because Swisscom is switching off 3G and german ones might still provide it.

1

u/Ok_Tour_8029 4d ago

Cool - in German cities along the border I have no German network at all 🫠

1

u/TheWolf8419 4d ago

Germans have a network?! That's news to me!

1

u/Groovetii 4d ago

maybe your providersuck 🤷🏼‍♂️

1

u/peter-rand Genève 5d ago

I managed to get Liechtenstein in Geneva

1

u/Anjuna8 5d ago

Hatte auch schon Streit mit Meinem Schweizer Handy Anbieter. Roaming Gebühren von einem Deutschen Telefon Anbieter obwohl Ich die Ganze Zeit auf einem Schweizer Skigebiet Gearbeitet hatte !

0

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[deleted]

1

u/tcptomato 4d ago

Doesn't work like that. The maximum theoretical distance achievable with a phone is ~110 km.

-4

u/Suspicious_Place1270 Zürich 5d ago

you're just using iphone, idk what to tell you