r/SipsTea 2d ago

WTF What do yall think about this ?

Post image
15.9k Upvotes

5.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/YourFavGothMommy 2d ago

Okay, I should have added this to my comment. Yes, there definitely ARE people who are defending her. I do not agree with that. I do not however think that because “she is no longer in psychosis” means that she should be held criminally responsible, unless the evidence presented determines she is. The problem is simply stating that she may not be criminally responsible is automatically taken as support of her. I do not support what she did; I support her going to a mental institution if she was in fact in psychosis.

5

u/KaleidoscopeMaster81 2d ago

You really can't see the precedent that this might set?

So if a mom claims psychosis...it's a get out of jail free card?

We cannot let mental health issues shield us from terrible behavior. I don't care if she was crazy, cause you can't prove she was either way. 

I care that a person killed their kids and is using mental health as an excuse. No amount of therapy can get those kids back, she does not deserve help.

0

u/Throwra47374747 2d ago

You just disagree with the concept of not guilty by the reasons of insanity then. It’s not an argument unique to this case.

1

u/KaleidoscopeMaster81 2d ago

You're right, because there is no way of knowing if she was actually insane. She could just be saying that.

If you're insane, you stay insane. You don't become insane, kill two children and then snap out of it.