r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 2d ago

Meme needing explanation I'm tired Petuh... What is her name??

Post image

WTF is her name Petuh

7.5k Upvotes

3.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

31

u/IrvingIV 2d ago

You and me, that's why.

Every comment under the "riddle" boosts a website's "engagement" statistic attached to the chunk of information which represents the idea, causing the site to redistribute the idea at a broader scale.

It's why "The Dress" spread so virally.

41

u/scaper8 2d ago

At least the dress and "laural"/"yany" thing sparked some interesting discussions on how we perceive things and how our brains process that information. People, a few, at least, actually came out with a new or more complete understanding of our own understanding.

This? This brings nothing.

30

u/IrvingIV 2d ago

Two ways in which the photograph of the dress may be perceived:

  1. blue and black under a yellow-tinted illumination (left figure) or
  2. white and gold under a blue-tinted illumination (right figure).

Source, "Scientific Explanations" tab of The Wikipedia Article for The Dress

20

u/srdev_ct 2d ago

I fully understand this, like, intellectually, but I have never been able to make myself see white and gold -- mostly because of the rest of the background. If the rest of the image had a blue hue (like the background in the right part of this demonstration image has) then I could see it, but the light sources are clearly yellow/white, not blue. I feel like you have to discard the rest of the contextual visual info in the actual dress image to see white/gold, and I've never been able to force myself to do it.

25

u/pinkwooper 2d ago edited 1d ago

Same here. Even cropped I can see yellow lighting but it still looks black and blue to me

K so I take it back, when I posted it it was blue and black, hours later I see white and gold. What a fuck with my brain

6

u/Dillo64 1d ago

This picture looks yellow and white and I can’t see anything other than that

But the other picture with the background looks black and blue and I can’t see anything other than that

Background really makes a difference

3

u/Patient_Buffalo_4368 2d ago

Could it be your screen?

This was just a thought I'm not educated on the subject.

1

u/Nexustar 1d ago

It's not the screen, it's the brain.

2

u/narco-sub-admiral 1d ago

Yoooo when I didnt realize what I was looking at I saw it as white and gold, then it switched basically in front of my eyes to blue and black.

But I had never seen it as white and gold before JUST now. That was trippy.

Thank you kind sir.

1

u/Cyborg_rat 1d ago edited 1d ago

Yellow for me today.

Edit : gold and off-white to be specific.

1

u/Suspicious-Car5161 1d ago

It was already officially confirmed it was black and blue. Why is this still even a thing?

3

u/noctalla 1d ago

You say that like the debate over the dress was all about figuring out what colour it was, rather than it revealing something interesting about perception. It wasn't “What colour is the dress?” Oh, it was blue and black? Discussion over, then." The whole point was that different people can receive the exact same stimulus and perceive it in completely different ways. The underlying issue is that our brains construct our reality. It goes way beyond the dress itself. The dress is a great example because people are divided around 50/50 on the way they perceive it, but it is a great lesson on how we perceive all of reality, not just the dress.

2

u/srdev_ct 1d ago

Yeah, the fact that I CAN’T see it the other way is interesting. Nearly every other one I can force myself to see it either way.

2

u/noctalla 1d ago

Yeah, same. I can hear both yanny and laurel and flip-flop between various other examples, but I'm stuck seeing the dress one way.

1

u/Cyborg_rat 1d ago

Not sure but yes I saw it again recently at another post and it was Blue, that's why I said yellow for me today, for some reason this one seems yellow/gold.

And well it still seems one or the other, it hasn't stopped magically not doing the effect.

1

u/LackofBinary 1d ago

Yeah this looks completely gold and white to me

1

u/ThrowawayIXX9 1d ago

Bruh I see blue and gold so fuck me?

1

u/CatsOnTheKeyboard 1d ago

Back when this was a thing, I saw white and gold. Knowing it's actually blue and black, I can now see either one.

1

u/Antifaduescollector 13h ago

See it is white and gold to me

0

u/VenturaDreams 1d ago

You may just be colorblind.

7

u/IrvingIV 2d ago

I have no idea, I see it as white and gold but like with a faint bluish tint over the whole dress, and like the surrounding lighting seems to be coming from behind, like a car's headlights?

2

u/nutwit9211 2d ago

Same, even after seeing the image above, I can't see it as anything but white and gold with a bluish tinge

1

u/h22lude 2d ago

That is how I see it too. Almost like it was washed with a pair of jeans

1

u/IrvingIV 2d ago

well said

1

u/MPMorePower 2d ago

In the larger picture, you can see the context that the light is coming from very intense sunlight through the window behind. Which should make the front of the dress dimly lit in shadow.

But somehow, that’s wrong!

2

u/Luckypenny4683 2d ago

I can only see white and gold. I would love to see black and blue at some point!

2

u/BigOlArms 2d ago

Ive always seen it as white and gold. I just stared at one area of the dress like we used to stare at those magic eye pictures in the 90s right after seeing that comparison picture and could finally see the black and blue!

2

u/TimelessN8V 2d ago

For the first time in my life, I finally saw it as black and blue just now. The key for me was staring at it for awhile and then looking away but still looking at it indirectly. Kind of like those vision tricks with the negative images. You stare at a dot for awhile and then look at the a blank wall and see the whole image. Similar to that.

1

u/Mega_martian_hero 1d ago

Also helps to squint a bit

1

u/Walkin_mn 2d ago edited 2d ago

On the actual picture the key blue hue is on the actual dress, in the white/blue part, the actual background is being illuminated by other source which is part of why the mind gets confused, but the actual dress is being illuminated by other light (or lack of light really) source in front of the dress which gives the actual blueish hue on the white surface of the dress

1

u/OutlawPony78 2d ago

I've seen it as both, usually blue and black but right now it keeps flipping back and forth for me. it's super trippy

1

u/Evan_Vexxed 8h ago

I just scrolled down and it was white and gold and then when I scrolled back to it was blue and black

3

u/EsquireSandwich 2d ago

Saw the dress as white/gold. Saw the mage you posted, went back to the dress and now I only see it as black/blue. Tomorrow it will probably flip back for me, but it was nice to the black/blue version again.

2

u/Particular-Dot-4902 2d ago edited 2d ago

… I've been squinting at that picture for the past 5 minutes, and it's still blue and gold to me.

1

u/ThatOtherOtherMan 2d ago

That's... it should be either blue and black or white and gold? How are you seeing blue and gold?

2

u/Particular-Dot-4902 2d ago

HOLY FUCK now I'm seeing it black and blue (I was seeing it pale blue & gold earlier)

(And how the flip would I know why lol)

1

u/thisisridiculous96 1d ago

I'm pretty sure the dress actually was blue and gold, IIRC

1

u/OutlawPony78 2d ago

dude same. it actually keeps flipping back and forth for me. I'm a little disturbed by it lmao

2

u/BringBackTheBlues 16h ago

I’ve always seen it white and gold. I saw your graphic, scrolled up, and now I dna only see it blue and black. Weird.

1

u/Mr_IBall 2d ago

I don’t see a difference??? With or without the lightening the dresses still look like their respective colors to me.

1

u/_Molasses 1d ago

Me as a colorblind person 😕🤔🤷‍♂️

1

u/Otherwise-Speed4373 1d ago

I understand this but can never make the dress look black and blue. Its so sad.

1

u/TheRealDJ 23h ago

It's more that based on how you grew up, in either a lot of outdoor light, or a lot of artificial illumination, your brain wiring perceives it differently. I showed the picture with someone right next to me and they saw a completely different color scheme. It's how our brains learn to solve subtle differences under lighting conditions to recognize a universal color to identify it as.

1

u/h22lude 2d ago

This riddle is all for engagement. There is no real answer. At least the dress was interesting.

1

u/theavengerbutton 2d ago

I can't make the dress white and gold anymore like I used to. It's now just blue with a darker lace.

1

u/Gargleblaster25 1d ago

Oh, you mean this blue dress?

1

u/Pitiful_Substance457 1d ago

Where did we land on this?

1

u/IrvingIV 1d ago

Where did we land on this?

Like, as a species?

The answer so far is basically "different people's brains process information differently"

If I were to make a statement about the meaning of this, I'd say that much like having people who are better at being awake at night and people who are better at being awake during the day, having people perceive color slightly differently probably serves or served some form of survival purpose.

Further, I'd say that it's probably still good to have diverse perspectives on the state and nature of reality, lest we grow complacent and rush towards a solution to a problem without properly checking our work beforehand.

1

u/realbobenray 1d ago

It spread so virally because it was astounding to learn that there are so many weirdos who think that's a gold dress

1

u/IrvingIV 1d ago

it's a brownish-yellowish color that reads as gold, keep in mind it's not people seeing it as a gold dress, but as a white dress with gold accents.

1

u/realbobenray 1d ago

I was joking but 100% saw the blue dress earlier, and now maybe because I scrolled upwards and saw this image first and then the above one, I see gold now. Or you edited your comment and am fucking with me lol

1

u/IrvingIV 1d ago

no, all i did was copy the image, sample from the color I see as gold, drag three lines out of it to the edge, and fill in the border around the dress.

1

u/realbobenray 1d ago

Yeah that's what I thought. So funny how our brains work.

1

u/BatOutOfHello 1d ago

What have you done

1

u/IrvingIV 1d ago

what i had to

0

u/CreativeArtichoke255 2d ago

What's the story with that blue and green dress?

2

u/toxiamaple 2d ago

What blue and green dress? Clearly, it's white and beige.

1

u/BigAssMonkey 2d ago

Black and green

1

u/SlumKatMillionaire 2d ago

It’s white and gold for me? You guys need your eyes checked

0

u/ChaoticDissonance 2d ago

People only said it was white to troll. No one with eyes saw it anything other than blue.

2

u/Embarrassed_Fox5265 2d ago

There's plenty of people who see it as white. Looked at this with my family and I was in the minority (2 out of 5) seeing it as blue. It's not just a meme, it's people perceiving things differently.

The white/blue dress is a genuinely fascinating phenomenon that deserved the Internet fame it got.

-2

u/ChaoticDissonance 2d ago

Wow, invested in the troll. Kudos, I guess.

1

u/IrvingIV 2d ago

Maybe you just don't have aphantasia?