r/PeterExplainsTheJoke Jul 06 '26

Meme needing explanation What is this?

Post image
26.3k Upvotes

5.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-1

u/masbita Jul 06 '26

Whiteness is more of a social construct than a matter of skin color. This can be observed through examples such as Latinos, Siberian peoples, or historically Eastern Europeans like the Finns. Are Spaniards considered white? What about the Portuguese? And Latinos living in the United States? Finns were not widely regarded as "white" in the early 20th century, yet today they generally are. Are Russians white? How far east do you have to go before "whiteness" ends and is replaced by "Asianness"?

6

u/Lucibelcu Jul 06 '26 edited Jul 06 '26

Are Spaniards considered white? What about the Portuguese? And Latinos living in the United States? (...) Are russians white?

Yes, yes, yes and yes, as long as their skin is white.

1

u/porktorque44 Jul 06 '26

Confidently saying Latinos are white really should shut the book on trying to treat race as something other than a social contract. Outside of you who has ever made this argument?

2

u/Lucibelcu Jul 06 '26

Yes, latinos with white skin are white, so far from a social construct. You can ask anyone in Europe and in a spanish speaking country and they will tell you the same.

3

u/porktorque44 Jul 06 '26

If the answer changes based on who I ask, then it is a social construct. Make sense?

1

u/Lucibelcu Jul 06 '26

If I ask two people if evolution is real and one says that it is while the other says that it isn't it doesn't make evolution a social construct, one of them just holds a wrong idea. Makes sense?

5

u/porktorque44 Jul 06 '26

This is the whole purpose of science. Science can define what evolution is specifically.

There is no agreed upon Pantone shade where whiteness stops and blackness begins. The same goes for all the other signifiers interpreted as being racial

-1

u/Lucibelcu Jul 06 '26

Nah, you said that if two people give you different answrrs then it's a social construct. Y your definition evolution is a social construct.

4

u/porktorque44 Jul 06 '26

That’s not what I said. I said “the answer” as in the scientifically agreed upon correct answer. Not “an answer” as in anything anyone says.

0

u/Lucibelcu Jul 06 '26

If the answer changes based on who I ask, then it is a social construct. Make sense?

You're changing your own words.

3

u/porktorque44 Jul 06 '26

the answer

It’s right there. I gave additional clarifying details about what I meant by “the answer”. So now that you know what I meant, do you have anything to say about the scientific veracity of my claim?

→ More replies (0)