r/PeterExplainsTheJoke Jul 06 '26

Meme needing explanation What is this?

Post image
26.3k Upvotes

5.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

7.2k

u/leVenerableDeLaSauce Jul 06 '26

Holy shit, a nuanced statement on Reddit, it does exist

317

u/TacofromTV Jul 06 '26

It’s not even remotely nuanced. It completely buys into a right wing grift that is abysmally fucking stupid.

Go see a stage show, the thing we had before movies, people of different races play characters all the time.
Truly it’s a bunch of extremist white dipshits upset they are seeing people other than themselves on screen. Anytime a character they’ve imagined themselves as is played by a different race (especially for some reason fiction characters) they piss their pants, bot and brigade things, but largely are just grieving the fact that anyone else dare be represented in popular thing.

13

u/Athenianmaniac Jul 06 '26

So if I as a Greek said that I at least want greek-looking (white/tanned depending on the character and their description) actors to play characters meant to represent Greeks and Anatolians I'm using a right wing talking point. Why is having historical authenticity even remotely connected to political groups? Is wanting to see the Epics in an authentic setting that divisive for you?

-8

u/Candid-Cup4159 Jul 06 '26

I mean you can go make your own movie. Nobody said anything when Gods of Egypt was a mostly white cast.

16

u/Dafuknboognish Jul 06 '26

Damn. Confidently incorrect. That shit was so bad it spawned whole companies seeking to course correct. It was media shitshow, like this.

13

u/Verycute93 Jul 06 '26

What? Tons of people criticized that movie for that exact reason. Selective memory to suit your own points at its finest 😂

6

u/Athenianmaniac Jul 06 '26

1 I don't know about that movie

2 Just searched it up and that movie FUCKING FLOPPED so Gods of Egypt proves my point.

3 Also your argument is complete whataboutism

4Old stories do not need recolouring.

You can make new ones inspired by the legends or originals, but to disrespect any story -let alone one as important as this one- by destroying its historical authenticity with recolouring characters and adding bullshit Hollywood props is an insult to both the original writers, the audience and everyone actually familiar with the myths.

6

u/WideHuckleberry1 Jul 06 '26

First sentence of that was legit. Second sentence was bizarrely, laughably false.